1. Grand Forks Municipal Parking System Study Recommendations Downtown Parking Study Review Committee October 9, 2014 Transportation Planning Services Downtown Grand Forks Parking Study Final Report September, 2011

2. Agenda for today Update on Executive Corners Financial information for the ramp  Assessments  Parking leases Review Signage Recommendations Information on last week’s Fargo Presentation

3. Update on Executive Corners Site

4. Financials for Parking System – 2015 Budget Revenues  Parking Leases - $286,540  Parking Assessment - $85,000  County Management Fee - $80,000  Misc Income - $1,500  Total - $453,040 Expenditures  Salaries - $27,031  Maintenance/Operations - $311,947  Capital Expense - $69,800  Construction Reserve - $44,262  Total - $453,040

5. O&M Parking Assessments Recommendations 1.Expand district boundaries 2.Assess costs to property owners, not businesses 3.Calculate assessments on “form based” ratio 4.Collect assessments same way as snow removal and grass mowing Actions 1.Adopt an ordinance incorporating all recommendations

6. Expand O&M District  Reconciles O&M and construction district boundaries  Spreads assessments over more properties  Covers all on- and off-street parking in downtown area

7. Current vs. Proposed Formula All Properties3.15 Exceptions High School/Mission1/employee + 1/5 students/bed Hotels/Motels1.00/room Residential1.00/unit (50% Senior) Church0.2 Theater0.15/seat Warehouse0.2 Theater (per seat)0.08 Community/Fraternal and Lodge0.50 Warehouse0.50 Manufacturing, Printers, Newspapers0.75 Hotel/Motel (per room/suite)1.00 Bowling Alley (per lane)2.00 Church, Synagogue, Temple2.00 Fitness Center2.00 Mortuary/Funeral Home2.00 Banks10 + 1/500 Medical5.00 Professional3.33 Boarding/Lodging/Dormitory (per person)0.50 Elderly Only (per unit)0.33 General (per unit)0.50 Furniture, Appliance, Flooring2.00 General7.00 Secondhand/Used/Thrift3.50 Auto4 + 2/service bay Beauty/Barber5.00 Travel/Floral/Photography5.00 Government10 + 1/500 High School1/employee + 1/5 students Restaurant/Bar (p/s/f for every 3,150 s/f)1/175, + 1/350, + 1/525, +1/700 Note: Ratios are per 1,000 gross square feet unless otherwise noted CurrentProposed Uses241 + 5 exceptions Ratios147 BillingsQuarterlyAnnually VerificationsMultipleAnnually DataStaff survey or Self-reporting City Assessing Department

8. Example Non-resident square feet = 4,802 Formed based ratio = x 3.15 subtotal = 15,126 Per thousand = 15.0 Basement square feet = 4,802 Warehouse ratio = x 0.20 subtotal = 960 Per Thousand = 1.0 Individual Residential = 16 Residential ratio = 1 Parking = 16.0 Total Parking = 32.0 old method 16.7 One-owner, basement storage, apartments

9. Wayfinding Signage

14. Next Meeting October 23 rd That meeting will focus on recommendations Discuss what is next?  Wholesale update to the Plan?  Final Recommedations?