1. Technical Guidance for High Performance and Sustainable Buildings Matt Gray OFEE Symposium June 6, 2007

2. Overview The Need for Sustainability Policy Drivers FEMP and Sustainability Interagency Sustainability Working Group (ISWG) Tools and Resources DOE and Sustainability Overcoming Barriers to Sustainability Sandia National Lab JCEL Building

3. Sustainable buildings balance the triple bottom line by utilizing an integrated approach to design, construction, operation and decommissioning Social Benefits EnvironmentalBenefits Economic Benefits Increased worker productivity and reduced utility costs Improved quality of life for facility occupants and society in general Buildings account for nearly 40% of global greenhouse gas emissions The Triple Bottom Line of Sustainability

4. Federal Design and Construction Market The Federal government operates in over 3 billion square feet in about 500,000 buildings At least 80% of the Federal complex in 10 years will consist of buildings in the current building portfolio Great opportunity for lifecycle cost- effective energy savings exists for new construction AND existing buildings Sustainability efforts taken today save 20- 70% of the energy use in new and existing buildings

5. New Construction Policy Drivers OMB A-11 (2002) Incorporates sustainable design as standard practice (life-cycle cost analysis, energy/water efficiency, indoor environmental quality) throughout the Federal sector EPACT 2005, Section 109 DOE to issue new federal building standards requiring … –Where lifecycle cost-effective, buildings shall be designed to achieve energy consumption levels at least 30% below ASHRAE 90.1-2004 –Cost effective sustainable design principles shall be applied to the siting, design, and construction of all new and replacement buildings –In annual budget requests and reports to FEMP, each agency shall list all new buildings and identify which ones meet the standards

6. Policy Drivers - Sustainable MOU Federal Leadership in High Performance and Sustainable Buildings MOU White House Summit on Federal Sustainable Buildings –January 24-25, 2006 –Meeting with more than 150 top Federal facilities managers and decision-makers 19 Federal Agencies signed the MOU, including DOE Agency representatives at the Summit

7. Sustainable MOU Guiding Principles REDUCE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT OF MATERIALS ENHANCE INDOOR ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY PROTECT AND CONSERVE WATER USE INTEGRATED DESIGN OPTIMIZE ENERGY PERFORMANCE Guiding Principles for Federal Leadership in High Performance and Sustainable Buildings

8. Policy Drivers - EO 13423 Sustainable Buildings Elevates Sustainable MOU for new construction and major renovations 15% of building inventory to incorporate the MOU’s Guiding Principles by FY 2015 Greenhouse Gases Energy Efficiency Water Conservation Sustainable Procurement Renewable Energy Pollution Prevention Petroleum Reduction Alternative Fuels

9. FEMP Sustainable Building Program Program Goal Lead Federal agencies efforts to institutionalize sustainability into policies, procedures, and practices for new construction and existing buildings Program Strategies Partner with other DOE offices, Federal agencies, non-profits, and private industry to leverage limited resources Reduce Federal agency duplication of effort; streamline and standardize requirements, processes, and implementation tools Influence design and construction community at planning stages, targeting each of the 5 Guiding Principles, and verify that design intentions translate into high performance buildings Maximize potential of existing buildings, largely through the O&M/sustainable commissioning http://www1.eere.energy.gov/femp/sustainable/

10. Partnerships and Outreach FEMP Sustainable Buildings Program Federal Agencies GSA, DoD, EPA, DOI, NASA and almost all other major and independent agencies Private Sector Organizations Sustainable Buildings Industry Council American Institute of Architects Alliance for Sustainable Built Environments Construction Industry Manufacturers of Sustainable Products Non-Profit Organizations U.S. Green Building Council Green Globes New Buildings Institute ASHRAE Alliance to Save Energy Government Organizations Interagency Sustainability Working Group Federal Facility Council Office of the Federal Environmental Executive Federal Green Building Council

11. Interagency Sustainability Working Group (ISWG) “Being able to connect with others across the federal sector … improves the quality of our work. The networking has resulted in new projects and new ideas on how to improve the performance of green buildings.”

12. ISWG Mandate Authority –Working Group under the Interagency Energy Management Task Force since 2001 ~300 members (50-60 active) from across the Federal government Bi-monthly meetings; intranet site Purpose: –Serves as forum for information exchange –Advocates for sustainable building practices in new construction and existing buildings –Eliminates barriers to sustainable design in the Federal sector by developing policy, technical guidance and other resources Tour at USGBC Headquarters Washington, DC ISWG Bi-Monthly Meeting March 13, 2007

13. Recent ISWG and Federal Accomplishments Initiated and led the development of the interagency Sustainable MOU, which has been incorporated into EO 13423 Developed the Technical Guidance and the Model Program Implementation Plan for Implementing the Sustainable MOU Sowing the Seeds 2007 Closing the Circle Award 157 Energy Star ® Facilities, by Agency 57 Federal LEED ® Certified Facilities

14.  Pentagon Washington, DC US Dept. of Energy Headquarters Washington, DC   Yellowstone National Park Wyoming  Fort Carson Colorado Springs, CO  Institute of American Indian Arts Sante Fe, NM  Grand Canyon Arizona       Denali National Park Alaska US Navy Memphis, TN Marine Corps Oahu, Hawaii The Presidio San Francisco, CA Fort Baker California Yosimite National Park California Fort Simcoe Job Corps White Swan, WA Bureau of Prisons Washington, DC Accomplishments – Technical Assistance SUSTAINABLE BUILDING TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE Milwaukee Job Corps Center Milwaukee, WI  EPA Region 8 Denver, CO  Smithsonian Environmental Research Center Edgewater, MD  Zion National Park, Utah

15. Zion Visitor Center is an example where FEMP and Building Technologies working with DOI-NPS reduced energy consumption by 70% with integrated design principles FEMP Tech Assistance Example: Integrated Design at Zion 1.Set specific sustainability criteria in RFPs 2.Use design charrettes 3.Define clear and quantifiable energy goals Compare energy use to a reference standard (such as 30% below ASHRAE 90.1-2004) 4.Verify goals throughout the process Using computer simulation tools, review and confirm at each stage of design stage – 50%, 90%, FINAL 5.Commission the building Compare actual performance to estimated performance, after one year of operation

16. Whole Building Design Guide Design Guidance focused on Federal facilities: –Building Types –Design Objectives: Sustainable, Accessible, Aesthetics, Cost- Effective, Functional, Historic, Productive, Safe/Secure –Products and Systems Interagency cooperation managed by NIBS August 2006: about 27,000 hits and 33,500 downloads per day www.wbdg.org

17. www.eere.energy.gov/femp/highperformance FEMP’s High Performance Federal Buildings Database: 36 Federal Case Studies DOE Sustainable Building Databases www.eere.energy.gov/buildings/database/ BT’s High Performance Buildings Database: 94 Total Case Studies

18. Accomplishments – Publication Examples The Business Case for Sustainable Design in Federal Facilities (2003) Building Cost and Performance Metrics: Data Collection Protocol (2005) Greening Federal Facilities – Second Edition (2001)

19. DOE Pursuing Leadership in Sustainable Building DOE Implementation Plan for the Sustainable MOU –Ad hoc DOE Sustainability Working Group –Currently implementing Action 1 of the Plan, Coordinate DOE Policies and Establish Programmatic Framework Assessments of Programmatic Framework for New Construction and Existing Buildings –Phase I is currently underway, focusing on new construction –Phase II is next, which will focus on existing and in-process buildings Link Sustainability with Acquisition of Capital Assets and Real Property Asset Management –Developing Sustainable Building Guide for Acquisition of Capital Assets –Integrating sustainability into Three Year Rolling Timeline of Real Property Asset Management Plan –Developing process for incorporating sustainability into existing reporting

20. Overcoming Barriers to Federal Sustainable Buildings BARRIERSTRATEGY High demand for training with limited resources Work with other organizations to increase available resources Compliance with EO 13423 Develop business case for third party certification Incorporate additional first costs of sustainable building into budget submissions Focus more attention on O&M within the ISWG and other groups Uncertainty regarding sustainable building metrics and reporting requirements Develop guidance through the ISWG Technical Guidance Task Group Confusion on incorporating life-cycle costing into sustainable building Develop guidance through the ISWG Technical Guidance Task Group

21. Conclusion Sustainability has arrived, and we’re moving fast with modest resources EO 13423 and the Sustainable MOU –Sustainable Building as an umbrella for all of the goals FEMP has taken a leadership role in sustainability –ISWG is thriving, going from 20 members to ~300 –Technical guidance and outreach –DOE Leadership Tools and Resources –Whole Building Design Guide –FEMP Technical Assistance –Publications –High Performance Building Databases NREL Science and Technology Facility – LEED ® Platinum

22. Contact Info Matt Gray DOE/FEMP 202-586-0067 Matthew.gray@ee.doe.gov www.ofee.gov www.wbdg.org/sustainableEO www.wbdg.org/design/greenspec.php http://www1.eere.energy.gov/femp/sustainable/ www.eere.energy.gov/femp/highperformance/index.cfm