1. Multi-disciplinary Approach for Industrial Phases in Space Projects Evolution of classic SE into MBSE Harald EisenmannAstrium Satellites Joachim Fuchs ESA INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop 21-22 January 2012

2. 22.01.2012 - 2INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Need for Evolution of Systems Engineering  Systems Engineering is well established in European Space Projects  Key success factor for European Space Projects  Mature standards for Space Systems Engineering  Changing Project Environment demands for a change  Increased complexity, shrinking budgets  Changing business models  Problem oriented approaches vs Product orientation  Improvement on processes required  Model-based, cross discipline collaboration  …

3. 22.01.2012 - 3INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Design Analysis AIT Engineerin g MBSE for Space requires efficient collaboration of the following … Thermal Engineerin g Mechanical Engineerin g Operational Engineerin g Electrical Engineerin g Payload Engineerin g Control Engineerin g Software Engineerin g Simulator Engineerin g Requirements Engineering

4. 22.01.2012 - 4INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop System Engineering Process, some aspects … Incremental Development Concurrent Engineering Building block orientation Design Iterations

5. 22.01.2012 - 5INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Multi-disciplinary tool integration “as they are” requires …  Process driven independent data model  Shared (data management) services  Cost efficiency for shared elements

6. 22.01.2012 - 6INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Concepts, Properties and Views, driving the conceptual data model Requirements Functional Decomposition Operational Modes Mechanical Modes Electrical Architecture Integration Procedures Operational Procedures TM / TC Mechanical Architecture …

7. 22.01.2012 - 7INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Engineering Data Categories Conceptual data model, simple class model will not do … Core Conceptual Data Model Traceability Functional Architecture Operational Architecture Physical Architecture AIT Data Operational Procedures Monitoring & Control Data Verification Data Engineering Data Item Static Definition Run Time Definition Equipment Type Categories Equipment Type Categories Discipline-specific Categories Discipline-specific Categories System Level Categories System Level Categories Conceptual Data Model instance of Requirements

8. 22.01.2012 - 8INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop … Flight Model-B Flight Model-A electr Default Configuration FM-A str-y head electr head electr str-y head electr … … aoc str-x System Design … Power … RW Eq-B STR Conceptual data model: “as designed”, “as configured”, “as built”, … STR-ESTR-H Dev-D D-A-0 D-A-1 D-B-0 D-B-1 D-1 Dev-C C-0 C-1 D-0 TheSystem E-A-0 E-A-1 E-A-2 E-B-0 E-B-1 AOC S/C str-xstr-y head … aoc … str-z … electr Realized Items S/N 1J-230

9. 22.01.2012 - 9INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Tool A Model-management functions required for interdisciplinary tool integration Common Design Model Representation Model Reasoning Consistency Compare Branching Merge Ownership Tracking Versioning Transformation Adaptor Tool AAdaptor Tool B Tool B

10. 22.01.2012 - 10INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Data Management functions as common platform for end user applications Checking Consistency Data Set Compare Data Set Branching Data Set Merge Ownership Tracking Versioning Model Transformation Specific Tool Integration System Model Representation Data Retrieval & History Import / Export Model Annotation File Management 2-D Visualization 3-D Visualization Result Visualization Virtual AIT Diagram Editing Table Editing Model Exploration Category Definition Model Browsing Reference Database Design EditorVisualization Tool

11. 22.01.2012 - 11INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Hierarchical decomposition of repositories along the project hierarchy System Model Editor System Model Editor System Model Editor Analyis Tool Visualization Tool Design Browser Design Browser Analysis Tool Design Browser Design Browser Design Browser System Model Editor System Model Editor System Model Editor Analyis Tool Visualization Tool Design Browser Design Browser Analysis Tool Design Browser Design Browser Design Browser System Model Editor System Model Editor System Model Editor Analyis Tool Visualization Tool Design Browser Design Browser Analysis Tool Design Browser Design Browser Design Browser System-level Equipment level

12. 22.01.2012 - 12INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Runtime Functions Managing evolution and cost efficiency Conceptual Data Model Code Generation System Model Representation Define Model Manage Model Browse Model Visualize Model Engineering Category Library

13. 22.01.2012 - 13INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Formalized presentation, based on the underlying semantics given

14. 22.01.2012 - 14INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop AOC Analysis Functional System Simulation Thermal Analysis Power Analysis … System Performance Integrated System Level Design and Verification System Trade Analysis Multi-disciplinary Shared System Model System Verification System Exploration

15. 22.01.2012 - 15INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Where do we stand today  Clear separation of model and representation / use of model  Respect of domain specific models and languages  Good understanding of process  Identified the challenge of data interoperability  Ongoing Projects  ESA ‘Virtual Spacecraft Design’ (VSD): Multidisciplinary modelling and model exploration tool  EU project Verde: Improving Design – Analysis Iterations and link to Modelica  Spin-off in use in operational context (e.g. System DB)

16. Where are we going  Integration of more analysis tools  Extension to all verification methods (testing…)  Configuration / model management  Evolution of Conceptual Data Modeling Languages (e.g. OWL, SIMF, Ecore++)  Interoperability / convergence of engineering models and ontologies  Introduction in industrial SE process and in customer / supplier relationship on all levels 22.01.2012 - 16INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop