1. CALORIMETER CELL MONITORING TOOL Viacheslav Shary

2. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL2 INTRODUCTION Goals: Detect the problems which were not found in the previous stages of the data quality check. Provide the data quality information for further use: e.g. lists of cells, BLSs with unusual large or small signal. This information is of interest for the reconstruction and simulation programs and, of course, for the data analysis.

3. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL3 THE SCHEME Raw calorimeter data from event distributor. Only ZERO BIAS events. on-line rcp file off-line rcp file dq_calo package Thumbnail calorimeter data. Only ZERO BIAS events. text report file (for shifter) input file for the database file with root trees

4. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL4 DATA QUALITY (DQ) CHECK EVENT DQ CHECK N cells, total energy, total squared energy MET, SET CELL DQ CHECK (per run) N entries, total energy, total squared energy Fraction of bad events i.e. events with parameters out of limits bad cells and BLSs, i.e. channels with energy and/or RMS out of limits Run data quality: GOOD, REASONABLE, BAD Lists: bad cells, bad BLSs, BLSs without signal

5. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL5 BLS QUALITY CRITERIA BLS is BAD if mean energy E 2.0 GeV; RMS 2.5 GeV; more than 5 bad cells in the BLS bad cell have a mean energy E 5 GeV All limits can be changed via rcp file.

6. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL6 RUN QUALITY CRITERIA If percentage of BAD events > 10% the run quality is BAD. Else if number of cells with mean energy out of limits > 24 the run quality is BAD. Else if number of ZERO_BIAS events in the run < 100 the run quality is UNKNOWN. Else if number of BLSs without signal > 1 the run quality is BAD. Else if number of BLSs without signal > 0 the run quality is REASONABLE. Else if number of BAD BLSs > 0 the run quality is REASONABLE. Else if percentage of BAD events > 2% the run quality is REASONABLE. Else the run quality is GOOD.

7. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL7 OUTPUT EXAMPLES WWW: http://d0-france.in2p3.fr/WORKING_GROUPS/DQ/ At this page the following information is available. 1.Run list with corresponding qualities 2.Run report with bad cells BLS list 3.2d histogram for many runs

8. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL8 An example of 2d (  -  ) histograms. The Z axis corresponds to the mean energy per entry in each cell (GeV).

9. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL9 An example of 2d (  -  ) histograms. The Z axis corresponds to the mean energy per entry in each cell (GeV).

10. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL10 An example of electronics 2d histogram. X is ADC number. Y is serial channel number. Z is the mean energy per entry in the cell (GeV).

11. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL11 An example of electronics 2d histogram. X is ADC number. Y is serial channel number. Z is the mean energy per entry in the cell (GeV).

12. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL12 An example of 2d (  -  ) histograms. The Z axis corresponds to the mean energy per entry in each cell (GeV).

13. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL13 RESULTS RUNS TOTALGOODREAS.BADUNKN. 160000 - 169999 (August – December) 6011234132342 170000 - 177681 (January – May) 4852381795414

14. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL14 TYPICAL PROBLEMS (1) Usually runs have 0-2% of bad events, but some runs have near 25%. These runs have 1 or 2 BLSs with a cell(s) with a huge signal. These runs should be declared BAD, because it can affect physics quantities. Some runs have no signal from several BLSs. Quality - BAD. Some runs have no signal from one BLS. Quality - REASONABLE.

15. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL15 TYPICAL PROBLEMS (2) There are runs with large signal in all BLSs in one crate during some time. Quality - BAD. Runs have frequently the following problem: 1 or 2 BLSs with a large signal (average signal per entry 2-10 GeV and RMS near 2-10 GeV). Usually these BLSs are the same in several runs. This problem affects missing E T and probably other physics quantities. Quality - REASONABLE.

16. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL16 Missing E T (E cell >0, without CH) PEAK ~ 2 GeV, FWHM ~ 3 GeV FWHM/2.36 ~ 1.3 GeV

17. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL17 MISSING E T FOR ZERO BIAS PEAK, GEV FWHM FWHM/2.36 all cellsE>0E>100 MeV all cells4.5 7.5 3.2 3.5 5.5 2.3 3.5 5.5 2.3 without CH2.5 4.5 1.9 2 3.0 1.3 2 3.0 1.3

18. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL18 MET for good & reasonable runs REASONABLE QUALITY FWHM ~ 3.5 GeV GOOD QUALITY FWHM ~ 3 GeV

19. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL19 MET for reasonable runs CORRECTION: BAD CELLS AND CELLS IN BAD BLS ARE NOT USED FOR MET CALCULATION BEFORE CORRECTION AFTER CORRECTION

20. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL20 MET for good & correc. runs GOOD QUALITY CORRECTED REASONABLE QUALITY

21. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL21 MET for good & reasonable runs REASONABLE QUALITY GOOD QUALITY REASONABLE & GOOD QUALITY

22. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL22 MET for reasonable runs BEFORE CORRECTION AFTER CORRECTION CORRECTION: BAD CELLS AND CELLS IN BAD BLS ARE NOT USED FOR MET CALCULATION

23. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL23 MET for good & correc. runs GOOD QUALITY CORRECTED REASONABLE QUALITY

24. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL24 ISSUES & PERSPECTIVES (1) How to organize the permanent monitoring and feedback with shifters ? The package was tested online by Laurent. How to proceed further ? In the output text file shifter can find an information about run problems (lists of bad cells and BLSs). How to make the data quality information available ? The runs quality database can be used to save lists of bad cells and BLSs. The bad cells can be removed from calorimeter data chunk.

25. BEAUNE, 2003CELL MONITORING TOOL25 ISSUES & PERSPECTIVES (2) Now it’s time to try this tools! i.e. one can compare analysis results for good and reasonable runs. What would the next step for calorimeter data quality be ? Are there other hardware failure that we can detect ? Shared energy problem ? Do we need to look at physics trigger to detect some problem ? Possibly, one could use clusters (CellNN) from reco to assert the impact of hardware problems on physics. It could also help discover warm zones, local inefficiencies and so on.