1. IPv6 Status Stuff Phil DeMar Summer 2011 JointTechs meeting July 14, 2011

2. Site IPv6 Status (Survey…)

3. Site IPv6 Survey (7/13/2011) 14 responses, including most of the Open Science labs Site IPv6 WAN connectivity:  IPv6 WAN connectivity in place11 Four have some level of production network support  No IPv6 peering in place 3 Two indicated no plans to do so  Feb 2011 ESCC survey: 6 of 10 sites had ESnet IPv6 peering

4. Site IPv6 Survey (II) Level of current planning efforts:  Identified project, with organized planning effort 6 (4)  Recognized project, organized planning not under way4 (3)  Informal/adhoc planning effort2 (2)  No significant ongoing planning effort1 (1)  Other1  Comments:  Structured for h/w; applications is a challenge  IPv6 included as part of core network upgrade

5. Site IPv6 Survey (III) Upper management buy-in:  Actively engaged7 (4)  Aware, but not actively engaged6 (1)  Not yet on their radar0 (1)  Other1 Resource availability for planning / deployment:  Active project with budgeted effort in FY11 & FY127  Identified project; no FY11 budget, but expect FY123  Opportunity cost; out of general support effort4  Question: what about non-networking staff IPv6 effort?

6. Site IPv6 Survey (IV) Scope of current IPv6 planning:  Network infrastructure & staff136  Computer security infrastructure & staff115  System support & staff 63  Web services 7\  DNS 9 2  Mail services 5 /  Other 4  Comments:  HPC – aware, but not actively engaged  Network research group involved  IPAM application support

7. Site IPv6 Survey (V) Projections on OMB deliverables (2012): Previous survey (2/1/2011): no reported IPv6 services  Comments: E-mail going to cloud (Google)

8. Site IPv6 Survey (VI) Preparation for 2014 deliverables:  Focusing tightly on 2012 deliverables7  Studying impact(s) of 2014 deliverables5  Actively planning for 2014 milestones0  Other2

9. Site IPv6 Survey (VII) Most significant barriers to 2012 compliance:  Communications and awareness of impact to the research and scientists  Getting coordinated effort across the spectrum of the IT enterprise.  Will consider 2012 as milestone goal, not necessarily required mandate.  Decentralized IT organizations.  Determining what must be done to make all public facing systems compliant.  Replacing/upgrading the core network infrastructure.  I don't think we have any barriers. IPv6 to the main facility website will be via an F5 to translate IPv6 addresses on the outside to IPv4 on the inside.  Resources  People resources.  Lack of funding and tools (e.g. IPAM, Security)  Resources, training, management directive, a business case.

10. Site IPv6 Survey (VIII) ESCC role in helping sites to meet 2012 milestones:  Continue to provide IPv6 technical forum environment.  Help motivate the NLCIO to provide a directives and funding.  Help in information campaign, spread awareness, importance, urgency of IPv6 adoption to IT communities.  A cookbook for compliance would be VERY helpful.  Facilitate best practices, common approach & lessons learned between SC Labs  Provide money!

11. ESCC IPv6 TF Activities

12. DOE IPv6 Activities Update Working groups setup to deal with aspects of IPv6 support:  IPv6 IT Management  IPv6 Technology  IPv6 Cyber Security  IPv6 Outreach Scope of DOE IPv6 2012 objectives defined:  “Public-facing interfaces” defined as intended for the general public  IPv6 services limited explicitly to web, e-mail, & DNS Labs place in DOE IPv6 plan is ‘fuzzy’  Included in the scope of the overall plan  Not included in DOE response to OMB data call on public services  Expected to ~meet OMB deadlines & contribute IPv6 knowledge

13. ESCC IPv6 Task Force Activities 13 1. IPv6 Planning Process TF  Phil DeMar, Paul Martinez, Louella Panaga, Jim Schroeder, Ted Sopher  Document not completed, but significant progress 2. IPv6 Technical Implementation Checklist TF  Mike Sinatra, Kevin Oberman, contributions by many others…  Progress toward a checklist, umhhh, not so good… 3. IPv6 Implications for Security Infrastructure TF  Farmed out to Network Security Monitoring (NSM) group…  They are supposed to develop a checklist from a cyber security perspective

14. Preliminary Site IPv6 Planning TF Checklist 14 Objective: Develop structured checklist as a planning template Basic structure: Ordered set of steps to follow in planning Drafted from a 2012 deliverables perspective Guidance and/or recommendations on each step

15. Site IPv6 planning checklist (II) 15 Establish initial IPv6 impact assessment group Scope spectrum of site effort w/ cost guesstimate Management buy-in process Key technical decisions of a strategic nature Test / development environment Draft target (2012) deployment Lay out roadmap(s) to achieve target deployment Implementation planning guidance Documentation & training

16. Site IPv6 technical checklist (preliminary) 16 Strategy: Organize IPv6 implementation guidance & recommendations into distinct components:  A structure for developing tutorials & checklists  Allows a tighter focus on target audience Mike Sinatra (ESnet) working on corresponding tutorials Basic structure within each component: Identify specific issues or areas of concern Differentiate between 2012 & 2014 implications Provide guidance and/or recommendations

17. Site IPv6 technical checklist (preliminary) 17 Addressing checklist  Address block selection & acquisition  Subnet allocation model  Address configuration model (static & stateful/stateless autoconfig)  Use of site/local addresses (ULAs)  Site multi-homing considerations Routing checklist:  Selection/configuration of routing protocols  WAN connectivity / peering issues  Neighbor discovery & Stateless Autoconfig (SLACC)  IPv6 tunneling considerations  NAT issues

18. Site IPv6 technical modules (II) 18 Host IPv6 Address Management (IPAM) Domain Name Service (DNS) issues Guidance on IPv6 implementation for public services IPv6 performance issues & considerations Test / Development Environment(s) IPv6 network (service?) management & monitoring Host IPv6 considerations