1. West Kowloon Cultural District: Let’s separate the key issues … Arts and culture development Urban planning and public architecture Venue building, ownership and management Policy Funding Governance

2. There are many unresolved issues in the administration of Hong Kong Arts and culture development Urban planning and public architecture Venue building, ownership and management PolicyStudy ignoredIncrementalNew venues needed Funding Home affairs monopoly Piece meal Lowest cost Home affairs monopoly GovernanceHome affairs monopoly 30 departments and no leader Home affairs monopoly

3. West Kowloon: HK$200bln land swap for HK$30bln venues and arts Arts and culture development Urban planning and public architecture Venue building, ownership and management Policy WKCD Study ignored Import Incremental Clustering all together New venues Dictated and built in one go Funding WKCD Home Affairs monopoly Land swap HK$15bln Piece meal Lowest cost Land swap $$$ + Canopy Home Affairs monopoly Land swap B.O.T Governance WKCD Home Affairs New Trust 30 departments One developer Home Affairs New Trust

4. The way forward: HK$30bln land sales for HK$30bln venues and arts Arts and culture development Urban planning and public architecture Venue building, ownership and management Policy Hong Kong Study ignored Consult and implement Incremental Victoria harbour New venues needed Add 1 by 1 Funding Hong Kong Home Affairs monopoly Diversify Piece meal Lowest cost Quality Home Affairs Privatise and diversify Governance Hong Kong Home Affairs monopoly Diversify 30 departments Integrated Chief planner Home Affairs Privatise and diversify

5. West Kowloon is an expensive, inefficient and lazy solution. Tackling the hard job of adapting the administration and policies to today’s arts, culture and planning requirements is what Hong Kong needs.

6. Integrated planning – working together on the best plan for HK