Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byHilda Morgan Modified over 8 years ago
1
Damien M. Schiff Pacific Legal Foundation
2
Takings Tests Physical taking (categorical) Third-party physical taking (categorical) Deprivation of all economically viable use (categorical) Regulation has gone “too far” Economic impact Reasonable investment-backed expectations Nature of regulation
3
The bundle of sticks The parcel as a whole Background principles Public trust doctrine Nuisance Reasonable and beneficial use
4
Williamson County Final decision Denial of compensation Avoiding preclusive merger
5
Discretion over the remedy, including declaratory judgments Sensitive issues of state law, including land-use regulation
6
Six years from date of accrual Government-accelerated erosion Rule of stabilization Substantial encroachment Damages are reasonably foreseeable
7
Exhausting the permitting process The futility exception N.B. Williamson County partially irrelevant Water rights as usufructuary rights
8
Physical versus regulatory takings Public trust, reasonable use, and in-stream uses Right to storage versus right to beneficial use
9
First English Evangelical Lutheran Church versus Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council Permanent versus temporary easements Valuation Before and after Fair market rental
10
Generally a federal issue Permanent or temporary policy? What’s wrong with a tort remedy?
11
Proximate causation Substantial cause and effect relationship Strict liability
12
Palazzolo v. Rhode Island Reasonable investment-backed expectations Reset even within family Windfall avoidance
13
Due process interlude The excessive rents/fair return rationale Pennell v. City of San Jose: protection of consumer welfare a legitimate interest supporting price controls Pervasively regulated industries
14
Spot zoning Degree of economic impact Nature of government action
15
Public beach easements Rolling easements Erosion versus avulsion
16
Nollan/Dolan Essential nexus Rough proportionality Real property versus money
17
Vested Rights Common law rule Development Agreements No exemption from state and federal regulations Normal rules of contract interpretation
18
www.pacificlegal.org
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.