Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byProsper Houston Modified over 8 years ago
1
Moving Forward – Maximizing Your Energy Management 2009 and 2010 Rate Issues WPSC Executive Team Barb Nick – SR Vice President Energy Delivery & Customer Service Dennis Derricks – Director – Electric Regulatory Policy WIEG May 8, 2008
2
2 2009 and 2010 Rate Issues Review of 2007/2008 Rate Case Discuss 2009/2010 Rate Case
3
3 2007 Rate Case January 2007 Rate Order Electric $56.7M (6.6%) Gas $18.9M (14.4%)
4
4 2007 Rate Case - Electric Reliability ATC Infrastructure Fuel and Purchased Power Coal and Rail Costs Purchased Power Fox Energy Center Recovery of Reduced Coal Delivery Deferral
5
5 2007 Rate Case - Electric Reliability (cont’d) Weston 4 Construction and Staffing Plant Maintenance Weston 3 De Pere Energy Center
6
6 2007 Rate Case - Gas Infrastructure improvements Manufactured Gas Plant Remediation Costs Exhausted Insurance Proceeds
7
7 2008 Rate Case No Rate Case Filing for 2008 Annual General Rate Cases since 2000 Fuel Increase: 2.5% increase January 2008 $23M Included certain ATC and deferred MISO costs Interim Fuels Increase
8
8 2009 Rate Case - Electric Rate Request for 2009 Electric $77.1M 7.75% from March 2008 Fuels Increase rates $106.8M 11.16% from January 2008 rates
9
9 2009 Rate Case - Gas Rate Request for 2009 Gas $11.7M 7.89% from January 2007 rates
10
10 2009 Rate Case - Electric KNPP Refund (51%) 2006 and 2007 rates were subsidized using the refund Proceeds are now exhausted Weston 4 Costs (17%) Non-Fuel O&M Depreciation Return
11
11 2009 Rate Case - Electric Emission Compliance Costs (13%) Emission Allowances Hardware installations Transmission Costs (7%) MISO ATC Other (12%) Primarily Weston 3 lightning strike costs
12
12 2009 Rate Case - Gas Manufactured Gas Plant Remediation Costs (-1.9M) Additional insurance proceeds recovered WPS Gas laterals for Guardian Pipeline (100%) Second interstate pipeline for service territory Competition
13
13 2010 Rate Case - Electric Electric $3.5M 0.33% from January 2009 rates Plus Fuel Re-Opener No Gas Increase
14
14 2010 Rate Case - Electric Generator Maintenance $5.4M Combustion Turbines Transmission Costs $2.2M ATC and MISO Environmental Compliance -$4.0M Less reliance on Allowances
15
15 2010 Rate Case - Electric Neither 2009 or 2010 rates reflect impact of Crane Creek Wind Project 99 MW Wind Farm in Iowa Required by WI Renewable Portfolio Standard WPS’ application currently under review at PSCW $10.4M in 2009 Additional $19.9M in 2010 Costs will be partially offset by fuel cost savings Production Tax Credits
16
16 Cost of Capital Rate of return on equity Rate increase reflects 10.9% after tax return on equity WPS has requested 11.5% after tax return on equity
17
17 2009 Rate Case – Tentative Time Table April 1 2008 April-June 2008 September- October 2008 December 2008 January 2009 Rate Case filed at Public Service Commission Public Service Commission Review Rate Design filed at the Public Service Commission Public Service Commission rate hearings Public Service Commission rules on rate changes 2009 rate changes go into effect April 1, 2008 April-June Sept-Oct Dec. 2008 Jan. 2009 May 15, 2008
18
18 Historical Return on Equity Year Authorized Return Actual Return 200212.3%11.50% 200312.0%10.40% 200412.0%12.61% 200511.5%8.63% 200611.0%9.48% 200710.9%≈9.9% 200810.9%TBD 200911.5% RequestedTBD
19
Moving Forward – Maximizing Your Energy Management Fuel Window
20
20 What is the Fuel Window? Process that adjusts rates for fuel variability Electric Utilities are not allowed to recover fuel one for one by statute in Wisconsin Cost of gas for distribution is one for one Volatility of fuel cost has increased “Large” swings in fuel costs are addressed by fuel window which reduces some of the fuel volatility risk
21
21 How does it work? If cost of fuel YTD exceeds or falls below the rate case level by a given percentage on a $/MWH basis, we are allowed (if exceeds), or required (if less than) to file to update our fuel costs. Percentages are 8% for Jan, 5% for Feb, and 2% for rest of year Projection for remainder of year also taken into consideration
22
22 Some of concerns of the Fuel Window Time frame Rate decreases processed quickly Rate increases delayed by notification and hearing process Adjusted rates calculated for annual period, applied for remainder of year so prior period is not recovered Some parameters for forecasting remainder of the year not allowed to be updated
23
23 What is the Process? Fuel Forecast completed Submitted as part of rate case filing PSCW staff & intervenors Audit information Take position Testimony submitted by all parties Rate Case hearing Commission determines position & fuel window
24
24 What’s in the Window? What’s In? Forecasted fuel costs Coal, including transportation Natural gas Hydro generation Wind generation Purchased power MISO RSG & Congestion & Losses Reduced for estimated opportunity sales What’s Out? Purchased power capacity costs Power plant non-fuel costs (fly ash and fuel handling expense) Third party wheeling costs (ATC)
25
25 What causes volatility? Natural gas prices Purchase power prices Spot purchases Fox Energy Center Combined Locks Combustion Turbine prices Unplanned Power Plant outages Planned outage schedule changes Generation mix changes
26
26 UR-118 2007 Cumulative Fuel Window $22.00 $22.50 $23.00 $23.50 $24.00 $24.50 $25.00 $25.50 $26.00 $26.50 $27.00 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOVDEC Dollars per MWH Upper limitLower limitFuel WindowUR118 Rate Case FB200610EU200703EU200706FB200705 EU200709EU200712Actuals 25.15 24.24 23.19
27
27 UR-118 ReEstimated 2008 Cumulative Fuel Window
28
28 What are we doing about it? Natural Gas hedging plan implemented Coal contract portfolio mix Fuel Forecast improvement process Looking at individual processes that make-up fuel forecast Currently Production Cost Study & Load Shape Participating in process to review Fuel Window at PSCW
29
29 Fuel Window Questions?
30
30 WPS Cost Drivers Cost Drivers Infrastructure (Weston 4, Guardian, Transmission) Coal Gas Environmental Renewables
31
31 WPS Cost Drivers – Cost Composition
32
32 WPS Cost Driver - Weston 4 Nearly complete 500 MWs, highly efficient Environmentally sound On budget Built safe Online this summer Fuel savings for customers
33
33 WPS Cost Driver - Guardian Pipeline Will bring new gas pipeline capacity to region Will bring competition to region In service later this year
34
34 WPS Cost Driver - Renewables Assorted hydro, wind, biomass, landfill gas Wind Farms 58 MW from Forward Energy wind farm in WI 99 MW development in northeastern Iowa 150 MW development in southeastern Minnesota Investigating others
35
35 2007 WPS Cost Driver - Projected Generation Mix Coal 68% Coal 54% 2008
36
36 WPS Cost Control Where WPS Has Reduced Costs Infrastructure almost done Weston 4 fuel savings Weston 4 financing Rail Contracts ATC Planning O&M
37
37 WPS Cost Control Construction of Weston 4 Significant Fuel Savings (≈$40M) 2009 compared to 2007 Employee Benefit Cost Reductions ($14.8M) Manufactured Gas Plant Insurance Recoveries ($1.9M)
38
38 Commitment To The Customer To be committed to the customer means listening to the customer… “my costs are increasing, but I have to deliver lower costs to my customers” “I wish I were regulated so I could pass on my costs” “I am an expert in my business – I don’t want to be an expert in the electricity business – WPS should help” “What are you doing to reduce costs” “Help me reduce my per unit costs”
39
Moving Forward – Maximizing Your Energy Management Questions?
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.