1. WP4 Rome WS Introduction Group Work Session EDIT EKE RÉKA KOVÁCS ZOLTÁN ASZALÓS ZOLTÁN CSERHÁTI Health Services Management Training Centre Semmelweis University _____________________________ Rome, 3rd December 2014

2. THREE GROUPS defined HWF mobility challenge area focus on THREE GROUPS Each group has a defined HWF mobility challenge area the group members focus on in the discussion 1."Worldwide students" – Mobility in professional training 2."Promised land" – Reliance on foreign health professionals 3."Damaged HWF and health care provision"– Facing loss 2

3. THREE ANALYTICAL DIMENSIONS A Terminology of HWF mobility types Objectives (HWF P)BINDICATORS C Methodology 3

4. THREE STATEMENTS THREE STATEMENTS These reflect WP4 suggestions on related D042 recommendations, thus discussion is also to validate that recommendation 1. WORLDWIDE STUDENTS 2. PROMISED LAND 3. DAMAGED HWF & CARE 4 THREE ANALYTICAL DIMENSIONS A, B, C

5. Objectives of the group work To validate the statements To explore and define HWF mobility type(s), objective(s) of datacollection (HWF planning) (A) To reveal the related HWF mobility indicators (B) To reveal the methodological challenges for data collection (C) To explore available country experiences, potential best practices (also for D042) 5

6. TYPOLOGY TABLE The mobile individual health professional The borders 1. The livelihood mobile/migrant HP Free mobility within the EU: the internally removed borders 2. The career oriented mobile/migrant HP National immigration regimes: the externally selective borders 3. The backpacker The culturally constructed border 4. The commuter 5. The undocumented mobile/migrant HP 6. The returner 6

7. INDICATORS GROUP 1. ‘WORLDWIDE STUDENTS’ TRAINING MOBILITY GROUP 2. ‘PROMISED LAND’ RELIANCE ON FOREIGN HWF GROUP 3. ‘DAMAGED HWF & CARE’ FACING LOSS Students’ intake,Percentage of foreign among all health professionals (stock) HWF Outflow: “Intention to leave” – applications for conformity certification, Number of graduates,Number of recognition of foreign diplomas (FT) Number of recognized domestic diplomas abroad Participation in scholarship training programmes, Number of newly registered foreign HPs (FT, FB, FN) (flow), Number of returners, Proportion of foreign students, Number of granted visas for non EU citizen HPs, Number of commuters, Quotas, numerus clausus, etc. Number of migrant HPs according to specialisation, etc. Data on circular mobility, etc. 7

8. Time schedule Group session 11.00-13.00 LUNCH 13:00-14:45 Interactive plenary feedback 13.45-14.45 8

9. Facilitation and feedback Each group has An invited facilitator, and a WP4 member Enthusiastic and committed (to contribute) group members A presenter from the group - plenary feed-back on the group work + ONE question the group shares ‘Voting’ on indicators 9 GroupInvited facilitatorWP4 member Group 1MelanieEdit Group 2MattRéka Group 3PaoloZoltán Cs.

10. GROUP MEMBERS GROUP 1 MelanieGROUP 2 MattGROUP 3 Paolo 1.Audéoud-Fauris, Michèle 2.Caron, Vincent 3.Das, Sarada 4.Dokova, Aneta 5.Eke, Edit 6.Fellows, John 7.Gorria, David 8.Gouveia, Ana Paula 9.Moreno, Carlos 10.Soetorp, Oyvind 11.Steinberg, Pascale 12.van Berkel, Leon 13.Testerini, Donatello 14.Zaremba, Arleta 1.Ailasmaa, Reijo 2.Björk, Margrét 3.Dumont, Gretel 4.Fantechi, Alessandro 5.Glinos, Irene 6.Kovacs, Reka 7.Lopes, Mário Amorim 8.Molina, Frances 9.Romestaing, Patrick 10.Rothgang, Heinz 11.Skitsou, Alexandra 12.Tønnessen, Christopher Nicolai 13.van der Velden, Lud 14.van Hoegaerden, Michel 1.Andrioti, Despena 2.Arias, Pilar Carbajo 3.Balogh, Zoltán 4.Cserhati, Zoltan 5.De Ponte, Giulia 6.Kostadinova, Dora 7.Kotowicz, Aleksandra 8.Kovacova, Miloslava 9.Letona, Maritxu Pando 10.Mickeviciute, Kristina 11.Nemerenco, Ala 12.Parra, Filomena 13.Perfilieva, Galina 14.Vassallo, Paula 10