Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byLaurence Ball Modified over 8 years ago
3
ARGUMENT SIDE EFFECTS THE BOGEYMAN OF THE NEOLIBERAL STATE WHAT EXACTLY IS POVERTY? WHAT ARE THE EFFECTS OF POVERTY?
4
ON CRIME PERPETRATION ON CRIME VICTIMIZATION ON THE PRODUCTION OF DISABILITY ON PROCESSING BY THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
5
MAIN ELEMENTS OF EFFECTIVE POVERTY REDUCTION STRATEGY › LABOUR MARKET › PUBLIC SERVICES › INCOME SUPPORT › COMMUNITY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
6
ADVOCACY FOR POPULATION-WIDE POVERTY REDUCTION IS A GOOD STRATEGY (WITH MEASURES TO INSURE INCLUSIVENESS)TO: › PREVENT CRIME PERPETRATION BY AND VICTIMIZATION OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, INCLUDING INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES, BECAUSE: POVERTY RATES ARE MUCH HIGHER AMONG PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES THAN AMONG THE GENERAL POPULATION POVERTY IS A SIGNIFICANT DRIVER OF CRIME PERPETRATION THROUGH SEVERAL PATHWAYS POVERTY IS A SIGNIFICANT SOURCE OF VULNERABILITY TO CRIME VICTIMIZATION
7
IMPROVED HEALTH STATUS FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES IMPROVED EDUCATION AND TRAINING OUTCOMES DECREASED INCIDENCE OF DISABILITY
9
EVERYBODY THINKS THEY KNOW WHAT POVERTY IS, BUT FEW CAN DEFINE IT (SIMILAR TO HAPPINESS) MADE MORE DIFFICULT BECAUSE CANADA HAS NO OFFICIAL POVERTY LINE DEFINITIONS MATTER: WHAT YOU THINK (HEAD) AND FEEL (HEART) POVERTY IS HAS A LOT TO DO WITH HOW YOU RESPOND TO IT
10
QUESTION “WHAT ARE THE TWO MOST IMPORTANT CHARACTERISTICS THAT DEFINE THE PHENOMENON CALLED “POVERTY”. INSTRUCTIONS › REFLECT ON THIS FOR 3 MINUTES › WRITE DOWN TWO SHORT PHRASES › GO AROUND THE TABLE TWICE SHARING YOUR IDEAS › DISCUSS FOR FIVE MINUTES AND CHOSE THE TWO MOST IMPORTANT
11
STANDARD OF LIVING AT BOTTOM OF SOCIO-ECONOMIC STATUS HIERARCHY › INCOME › EDUCATION › OCCUPATION › LOCATION ABSOLUTE › PHYSICAL SUBSISTENCE › NO REFERENCE TO SOCIAL AND CULTURAL NEEDS › EXPERT STANDARDS › MARKET BASKET MEASURE
12
GOALS OF: › SOCIAL ROLE PERFORMANCE › PARTICIPATION IN SOCIALLY SANCTIONED RELATIONSHIPS AND ACTIVITIES › ADHERENCE TO CULTURALLY SANCTIONED EXPECTATIONS POSITION IN INCOME DISTRIBUTION LOW INCOME MEASURE – LESS THAN ONE HALF OF MEDIAN INCOME FOR HOUSEHOLD SIZE
13
FOR HOUSEHOLD SIZE OF FOUR PERSONS AFTER TAX (DISPOSABLE) 2012
14
FOR HOUSEHOLD SIZE OF ONE PERSON AFTER TAX (DISPOSABLE) 2012 $20,784
15
RECENT DATA ARE LIKELY INVALID LIKELY DUE TO SAMPLING BIAS IN VOLUNTARY NATIONAL HOUSEHOLD SURVEY- PARENT SURVEY OF CANADIAN SURVEY ON DISABILITY UNLIKE ANY OTHER DATA REPORTED SLIGHTLY LOWER RATES OF VERY LOW INCOME (UNDER $5,000) FOR DISABLED (7.0%) OVER NON-DISABLED(10.2%) Statistics Canada. Table 115-0014 - Total income for adults with and without disabilities, by age group and sex, Canada, provinces and territories, CANSIM
16
IN 2005 CANADIAN WITH DISABILITIES HAD AN AVERAGE INCOME OF $33,600 ; ALMOST 10% LOWER THAN NON- DISABLED CANADIANS ($37,200). IN 2004 17.1% OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES HAD EARNINGS BELOW $5,000, COMPARED WITH 12.4% OF PEOPLE WITHOUT DISABILITIES. SOURCE: COLLIN, C. AND JENSEN, H. (2009). A STATISTICAL PROFILE OF POVERTY IN CANADA. OTTAWA. ON: LIBRARY OF PARLIAMENT, PARLIAMENTARY INFORMATION AND RESEARCH SERVICE
17
POVERTY HAS BEEN DEMONSTRATED TO BE A SIGNIFICANT DETERMINANT OF PERPETRATION OF CRIME; BUT THE RELATIONSHIP IS INDIRECT, OPERATING THROUGH SEVERAL PATHWAYS: › CONFLICTUAL AND STRESSFUL FAMILY ENVIRONMENTS › SOCIAL EXCLUSION FROM ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL OPPORTUNITY STRUCTURES › RESIDENCE IN SOCIALLY DEPRIVED DISORGANIZED NEIGHBOURHOODS RELATIONSHIP IS STRONGEST FOR VIOLENT CRIME
18
RESEARCH HAS DEMONSTRATED THAT POVERTY INCREASES VULNERABILITY TO VICTIMIZATION THROUGH: › OVER-REPRESENTATION IN DEPRIVED HIGH CRIME NEIGHBOURHOODS › OVER-REPRESENTATION OF FAMILIES WITH HIGH LEVELS OF STRESS AND CONFLICT IN WHICH VIOLENCE IS MORE LIKELY TO OCCUR › MARGINALITY RESULTING IN LACK OF PROTECTIVE RESOURCES › OVER-REPRESENTATION IN SOCIALLY DISORGANIZED NEIGHBOURHOODS WITH LIMITED SOCIAL SUPPORT › STIGMATIZATION AND LOW POSITION IN STATUS HIERARCHY
19
POOR PERPETRATORS ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE DETECTED WHERE THERE IS SPACE FOR POLICE AND PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION THE POOR ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE CHARGED POOR ARE LESS LIKELY TO BE DIVERTED TO NON-JUDICIAL REMEDIES POOR ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE HELD IN CUSTODY AWAITING TRIAL POOR HAVE LESS ACCESS TO HIGH QUALITY LEGAL REPRESENTATION POOR ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE CONVICTED POVERTY IS ASSOCIATED WITH MORE SEVERE SENTENCES, INCLUDING LONGER INCARCERATION
20
RESEARCH HAS ESTABLISHED POVERTY AS A CAUSAL FACTOR IN INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY MEDIATED THROUGH A RANGE OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND PSYCHOSOCIAL RISK FACTORS IN THE U.S. IT HAS BEEN ESTIMATED THAT ELIMINATION OF CHILD POVERTY WOULD PREVENT 10% OF INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY. SOURCE: Emerson, E. (2007). Poverty and people with intellectual disabilities. Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews, 13(2), 107-113.
22
LABOUR MARKET POLICY › ADEQUATE MINIMUM WAGES › CREATION OF WELL-PAYING JOBS › ACCESS TO EDUCATION AND TRAINING › ACCESS TO WORK PLACE DISABILITY ACCOMMODATIONS
23
ADEQUATE INCOME SUPPORT AND SUPPLEMENTATION PROGRAMS GOOD PUBLIC SERVICES › PUBLIC, SOCIAL AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING › DEVELOPMENTAL CHILD CARE › ACCESSIBLE HEALTH CARE, INCLUDING PHARMACARE › ADEQUATE ACCESS TO LEGAL AID COMMUNITY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TO DECREASE BOTH MATERIAL AND SOCIAL DEPRIVATION OF NEIGHBOURHOODS WHERE POOR ARE OVER- REPRESENTED
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.