Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byTerence Park Modified over 8 years ago
1
Comparative Foreign Policy Comparative Foreign Policy Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? How does the policy of containment evolve? American Anthem Ch.16 section 1 pp.497-501
2
QAR American Anthem pp 497-498 History of a Free Nation p 878-879 Who are Eisenhower and Dulles? How does Dulles feel about containment? What is Brinksmanship? What is Massive retaliation? What does Eisenhower DO with the advice from Dulles? From the Primary Source doc #23 on DULLES: Why does DULLES believe containment is UNSOUND? (what does unsound mean?)
3
Doc H “…I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.” Truman Doctrine 1947 plan HELPanybody Getting punked by EVIL COMMUNISTS THAT WE HATE. DOC J “…it represents a menace to the world.”
4
DOC I Chicago Tribune March 13,1947 “The outcome will inevitably be war. It probably will not come this year or next year, but the issue is already drawn.” What does this suggest about CONTAINMENT? Are they criticizing or providing an alternative?
5
1949 Who? Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? ANALYZE: What does this say? ANALYZE: What does this say?
6
Truman vs. Eisenhower Truman Doctrine 1.Marshall Plan 2.Berlin Airlift 3.NATO 4.Korean War Truman Doctrine 1.Marshall Plan 2.Berlin Airlift 3.NATO 4.Korean War Eisenhower Doctrine 1.“Domino Theory” 2.Massive retaliation. 3.CIA & covert operations Eisenhower Doctrine 1.“Domino Theory” 2.Massive retaliation. 3.CIA & covert operations “Containment” [George Kennan] “Brinksmanship” [John Foster Dulles] Containment: confinement or isolation of a threat. What does this infer about communists? Brinksmanship: push every threat to the limit of safety. What are the positives to containment? How to contain
7
Lippmann Doc G “American military power is peculiarly unsuited to a policy of containment which has to be enforced persistently and patiently for an indefinite period of time….” Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? What IS the US military suited to do? What would you predict?
8
Brinksmanship The term Brinkmanship refers to pushing a situation to the verge of war, in order to threaten, and encourage one's opponent to back down.Brinkmanship IS the US military suited to do this? Compare this to containment.
9
How Close to the Brink vocab Apocalyptic Brazen Hindsight Psyche Folly Retaliate Parity Bombastic Lunatics Canonized Maxim
10
“ya know the Cold War isn’t so bad” Who? Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? ANALYZE: What does this say?
11
Eisenhower doctrine The doctrine stated that the USA would use armed forces upon request in response to imminent or actual aggression Countries that took stances opposed to Communism would be given aid in various forms.opposed to Communism Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? Was this just a new look at CONTAINMENT? EVOLVE EVOLVE: to change or adapt over time.
12
Domino theory Was this just a new look at CONTAINMENT?
13
Changing foreign policy Cage them in. By playing chicken Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time?
14
Foreign Policy “Hot Spots” 1.1955 Warsaw Pact created. 2.1956 Hungarian Revolution. 3.1958 Berlin Crisis. 4.1960 U-2 Spy Incident 1.1955 Warsaw Pact created. 2.1956 Hungarian Revolution. 3.1958 Berlin Crisis. 4.1960 U-2 Spy Incident EUROPE: Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time?
15
Foreign Policy “Hot Spots” 1.1953 CIA sponsored coup in Iran 2.1956 Suez Crisis. 3.1958 Civil War in Lebanon 1.1953 CIA sponsored coup in Iran 2.1956 Suez Crisis. 3.1958 Civil War in Lebanon Middle East: Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time?
16
Foreign Policy “Hot Spots” 1.1948 O. A. S. [Organization of American States] 2.1954 CIA covert ops. in Guatemala. 3.1950s Puerto Rican independence movement. 4.1959 Castro’s Communist Revolution in Cuba. 1.1948 O. A. S. [Organization of American States] 2.1954 CIA covert ops. in Guatemala. 3.1950s Puerto Rican independence movement. 4.1959 Castro’s Communist Revolution in Cuba. Latin America: Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time?
17
Foreign Policy “Hot Spots” 1.1953 Korean War ends at 38 th. 2.1954 French punked by Indo-China. Geneva Accords 3.1964 China explodes its 1 st A-bomb 1.1953 Korean War ends at 38 th. 2.1954 French punked by Indo-China. Geneva Accords 3.1964 China explodes its 1 st A-bomb Far East:
18
Massive retaliation Use nuclear arsenal if Soviets take offensive actions. IS the US military suited to do this? Compare this to containment.
19
New American President How would changing presidents effect policy? Won election by suggesting Rep let us become in danger. What did I just say about containment? I wonder how my containment policy will play out ?
20
Kennedy Doctrine “Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe, in order to assure the survival and the success of liberty.” 1 1 Containment: confinement or isolation of a threat. Brinksmanship: push every threat to the limit of safety. Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? Was this just a new look at CONTAINMENT? Containment ?
21
Who are these 2 people? Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? ANALYZE: What does this say?
22
Do you really want this? Does containment diminish the threat? Does containment increase the threat?
23
Better develop some options. Alliance for progress Green Berets What do you think these are for? New policy or new method? Compare this to containment. “FLEXIBLE response””.
24
Policy evolution Team mates that tolerate each other due to common enemy. Adversaries that challenge each other with mild threats and have stopped talking nicely. Adversaries that fight A threat too close to home. Brinksmanship is VERY Dangerous. Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? How will Kennedy adapt or evolve with containment as new events close to home occur?
25
Evaluation How much has the American foreign policy really changed? How much has the world position really changed? What alternatives are being offered? Does lack of a better alternative make Containment good by default? Is it a problem with containment as a policy, or how we choose to enforce it? If it is policy is UNENFORCEABLE can it be a good policy? Was CONTAINMENT the correct policy for the time? wcrpft?
26
WCRPFT # 5 Compare and contrast ANY 1 of the “evolutions” of the Containment policy to the original plan in the TRUMAN doctrine. Docs 22 and 23 required. Doc 22: Eisenhower “military industrial complex” speech Doc 23: Dulles “liberation or containment”
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.