1. Goals: WGLC draft-ietf-lemonade-goals-04 Kue Wong jkwong@nortelnetworks.com

2. Goals: WGLC Comments (1) Editorial nits –All accepted Clarifications –Section 5.2.1: recipient replies in format of the original message - was not discussed –Section 6.1 restriction to IMAP extension a pragmatic WG decision whereas 5.1.1 and 5.1.2 are design principles more generally applicable –Goals document is a document of historical record - as such reference (section 6.1.1.1) to IMAP channel need not be excised –Section 7.1.2: Keypad is rudimentary keyboard: comment accepted –Section 8.5: update to most recent MMS architecture not necessary -- moving target -- important only to get proper reference

3. Goals: WGLC Comments (2) Clarifications –Poor phrasing - “support existing service as before” => backwards compatible with Internet Mail -- needs rewording “Mobile” not just “wireless” - accept as better term “without intermediation” means “through use of only Internet Mail (IETF) protocols” NOT “no transcoding” -- needs rewording Issues related to possible misinterpretation of purpose of Goals doc –These driven by desire for definitive “mobile e-mail service” functionality (see appendix [next slide] for list) –GOALS document NOT a WG “working” requirements document –Rather a historical record of decisions made and their context –(capture low hanging fruit - extend Internet mail so that it can be used by mobiles NOT create definitive “mobile e-mail”) –Additional functionality and new charter items agreed to by the WG/IESG & rationale for these need to go into a GOALS2 document –This document role may need additional clarification in this doc. ??? Thanks to all!

4. Goals: WGLC Comments (Appendix) Proposed additional “mobile e-mail” functionality –(perceived as goals doc issues) 1. graceful degradation 2. DRM 3. S2C notification - also inband versus outband notifications 4. e2e security 5. Factoring in support for operators 6. relationship to PIMs 7. e-mail handling of firewalls 8. reference to OMA mobile e-mail service direction and definition 9. positioning with respect to IM