1. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only Market Operations Engagement Group Customer Data July 13, 2016 Presentation material does not represent the views of the Joint Utilities Engagement Group as the group is still in discussion on these topics. Please do not redistribute this deck.

2. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 2 Agenda TimeTopic

3. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 3 Engagement Group Ground Rules* All stakeholder engagement (advisory group and engagement group) meetings, webinars and information exchange are designed solely to provide an open forum or means for the expression of various points of view in compliance with antitrust laws. Under no circumstances shall stakeholder engagement activities be used as a means for competing companies to reach any understanding, expressed or implied, which tends to restrict competition, or in any way, to impair the ability of participating members to exercise independent business judgment regarding matters affecting competition or regulatory positions. Proprietary information shall not be disclosed by any participant during any stakeholder engagement meeting or its subgroups. In addition, no information of a secret or proprietary nature shall be made available to stakeholder engagement members. All proprietary information which may nonetheless be publicly disclosed by any participant during any stakeholder engagement meeting or its subgroups shall be deemed to have been disclosed on a non-confidential basis, without any restrictions on use by anyone, except that no valid copyright or patent right shall be deemed to have been waived by such disclosure. AG & EG discussions will be open forums without attribution and no public documents by the AG or EG will be produced unless publication is agreed upon by the group. *Ground Rules adapted from the JU Advisory Group

4. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 4 Overall Engagement Group Purpose & Objectives Purpose The Market Operations Stakeholder Engagement Group (EG) is an open forum for stakeholders who are actively engaged in the REV process and the Distributed System Implementation Plan (DSIP) filings to provide input to, and exchange ideas with, the Joint Utilities of New York (JU) on topics related to grid operations as identified by the Joint Utilities Stakeholder Advisory Group (AG). Objectives The AG will advise the JU on the sequence and priorities of topics that Engagement Groups should discuss. The AG will also provide input on Engagement Group members, discussion scope, and any output documents that would advance greater shared understanding. The Engagement Groups will hold discussions on identified topics in order to achieve greater shared understanding of issues covered in the DSIP filings, and to build toward common ground through iterative discussion and feedback.

5. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 5 Market Ops - Near term schedule (subject to revision) 7/11 AG Customer Data (Tuesday mornings) DER Sourcing (Tuesday afternoons) Granular Pricing EVSE (scheduling TBD) July 12 NYC 8/1 7/25 7/18 8/8 August 10 NYC July 13 NYC Collection Frequency, Reporting Frequency and Availability of Usage Data July 26 Albany Aggregation of Usage Data August 9 NYC Additional Data Needs July 19 (By Phone*) August 2 (By Phone*) *Additional phone sessions will be held as needed End of July (By Phone*) TBD 8/15 July 13 NYC Share Existing NWA Plans and Lessons Learned July 26 Albany Dependencies With Other REV and Related Proceedings August 9 NYC Potential Refinements to NWA Procurement Approach July 19 (By Phone*) August 2 (By Phone*)

6. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 6 Customer Data Topic Description Customer Data may identify the person or entity to which it applies Customer information may include usage data, account/profile data, end-use and other qualitative data, and results from customer-specific analyses Customer usage data is a subset of customer information and contains a customer's usage or production of energy o The Commission’s REV Track 2 Order defined Basic Data as "the usage for each applicable rate element, including usage bands specified in the applicable tariff. This is the level of data necessary to render, reconstruct and understand the customer's bill" o Usage data can be shared with authorized third parties, or aggregated by various groupings for use by third parties

7. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 7 Customer Data Engagement Group Charter Purpose: Explore the Joint Utilities' approaches for facilitating market mechanisms that effectively support and encourage the adoption of Distributed Energy Resources while meeting customers’ needs and complying with the DSIP Guidance Order Topics and Scope: Customer Data Customer Data Data Collection, Reporting Frequency and Availability of Usage Data o Discuss how often usage data might be collected by the utility, how often it would be made available to customers/authorized agents, and at what quality level o Discuss customer data platform-related sensitivities (e.g. AMI versus non-AMI systems) Aggregation of Usage Data o Discuss standardized aggregated data offerings (e.g. kW and kWh by rate class, tax district, zip code) o Discuss utility-sided aggregated data system automation efforts and reporting methods o Discuss standards for anonymizing aggregated data to protect individual customer privacy (e.g. 15/15 rule) Additional Data Needs o Explore and identify additional useful customer information beyond usage data o Note: pricing for Basic and Value-Added data is a Track 2 matter

8. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 8 Stakeholder Presentations

9. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 9 Break

10. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 10 JU Presentation

11. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 11 Customer Usage Data The Track 2 Order defined the basic level of customer data that is to be provided at no incremental cost as the usage data for each applicable rate element, including usage bands as specified in the applicable tariff. The Joint Utilities support providing customer usage data to both customers and authorized third parties as a means of facilitating DER adoption Basic Data Value-Added Data All utilities plan to provide customer usage data via some combination of the utility bill, Green Button Download/Connect, EDI, and the utility's online customer engagement platform(s)

12. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 12 Customer Usage Data The Joint Utilities are in different positions when it comes to implementing real-time interval data platforms Current data delivery mechanisms will be in place for the near-term Utilities implementing AMI: Basic usage data provided via Green Button Connect, EDI, or alternative platform Utilities not implementing AMI: Basic usage data will be provided via Green Button Download, EDI, or alternative platform The Utilities will work together to develop specifications for transmitting any additional data fields beyond what is provided through Green Button Connect, in future phases

13. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 13 Data Delivery platform The Joint Utilities are in different positions when it comes to implementing real-time interval data platforms Current data delivery mechanisms will be in place for the near-term Utilities implementing AMI: Basic usage data provided via Green Button Connect, EDI, or alternative platform Utilities not implementing AMI: Basic usage data will be provided via Green Button Download, EDI, or alternative platform The Utilities will work together to develop specifications for transmitting any additional data fields beyond what is provided through Green Button Connect, in future phases

14. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 14 Data Collection and Reporting Practices Current data collection and reporting practices will continue for the first few years of AMI deployment Utilities Implementing AMI: Basic and Value-Added Customer Usage Data from interval meters will be reported in increments of between five minutes to one hour, and will be made available for customer and authorized third party access within 24 hours of collection Customer Usage Data will be reported in bill-ready quality within 24 hours of collection Some utilities may choose to report this data in partially VEE'd* quality sooner than 24 hours after collection Utilities Not Implementing AMI: Customer usage data will be reported in bill-ready quality at the end of the billing cycle (e.g. monthly) Existing practices for interval-metered customer data sharing will continue

15. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 15 Deep Dive Discussion

16. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 16 Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 16 Thank you for joining us! Please contact info@jointutilitiesofny.orginfo@jointutilitiesofny.org or visit our website www.jointutilitiesofny.org for more informationwww.jointutilitiesofny.org

17. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 17 Appendix

18. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 18 Advisory Group Members ContactOrganizationTitle NY DPS Tammy MitchellDept. of Public Service Chief, Electric Distribution Systems DER Provider Carlos GonzalezSolarCity Director, Grid Engineering Solutions DER Provider Pete FullerNRG VP, Market & Regulatory Affairs DER Provider Bill AckerNY-BEST Executive Director DER Provider Greg GellerEnerNoc Director, Regulatory & Government Affairs Large Customer Mike MagerCouch White, LLP Partner Large Customer Anthony FioreCity of NY Director, Office of Energy Small Customers & Consumer Groups Erin Hogan Dept. of State Utility Intervention Unit (UIU) Senior Project Manager at NYSERDA State/Public power Maryam SharifNYPA Program Manager, Clean Energy Technology Environmental Miles FarmerNRDC Legal Fellow Environmental Rory ChristianEDF Director, NY Clean Energy Marketers Chris KallaherDirect Energy Director, Government & Regulatory Affairs Wholesale market Mike DeSocioNYISO Senior Manager, Market Design at NYISO NYSERDA John SaintcrossNYSERDA Assistant Director, Smart Grid Research IPPNY Chris WentlentExelon VP, Energy Policy Joint Utilities Tom MimnaghConEdison Department Manager Joint Utilities Damian ScianoConEdison Director, Distributed Resource Integration Joint Utilities John LeanaNational Grid Director, Strategy Joint Utilities Lori ColeAVANGRID Manager, Regulatory & Tariffs Joint Utilities John BorchertCentral Hudson Senior Director of Energy Policy and Transmission Development Facilitator Paul De MartiniICF International AG Facilitator

19. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 19 Engagement Process Overview *Initial DSIP engagements dates based on individual JU workshop schedule during this period. **ITWG beginning in March, EG begins in May. *** Stakeholder technical conferences to engage a wider set of participants to inform technical discussions and share Engagement Group results, as needed and in consultation with the Advisory Group Source: Plan for stakeholder engagement process as reflected in May 5 th DSIP filing Stakeholder Engagement Schedule FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec Distribution Planning** 2017 Grid Operations Market Operations Advisory Group Mtgs Supplemental DSIP Engagement Groups DSIP Final GuidanceInitial DSIP FilingsSupplemental DSIP Filing Stakeholder Technical Confs*** Jan 2016 Initial DSIP Stakeholder Engagement*

20. Draft for Discussion Purposes Only 20 Supplemental DSIP Topics—Based on Final Order Distribution System Planning Topics Engagement Groups Probabilistic Planning Load Flow Analysis NWA Suitability Interconnection Technical Working Group Grid OperationsMarket Operations DER Forecasting Demand Forecasting Hosting Capacity Interconnection ISO/DSP Roles, Responsibilities, Interaction Cyber Security Monitoring & Control System Data Electric Vehicle Supply Equipment DER Sourcing - Procurement Customer Data Granular Pricing Currently scheduled Engagement Group topics Currently scheduled Advisory Group topics