1. PDP in Japan Update Toshio Tachibana Policy-WG
toshio.tachibana at mail.rakuten.co.jp
NIR-SIG
APNIC27 Manila, Philippines
2009/2/25 1

2. PDP in Japan Open Policy Forum provide by Policy-WG.
online forum “ip-users” maillist.
offline forum “JP Open Policy Meeting”
PolicyWG
中立的な立場からの；
議論/情報交換の場(OPF)の提供
アドレス利用者とJPNICの調整
ip-users
mailing list
offline
forum
(twice a year)
OPF
JP Open Policy
Meeting
online
Internet Resource
User
JPNIC
アドレスポリシーに関する
意見/質問の表明
情報提供/提案を実施
勧告内容の実装検討
OPFへの検討結果・実装予定の報告
INPUT
advice for implment 2

3. What is OPM and Policy-WG?
JPOPM organized by Policy-WG
off line forum(meeting)
part of PDP for Japan Community
Policy-WG
Independent group from JPNIC.
Fully volunteered 3

4. Member of Policy-WG Chair: Member： Tomohiro Fujisaki/NTT
Masaru Akai / e-trees.Japan,Inc.
Yukihiro Oki / So-net Entertainment Corporation
Toshio Tachibana / Rakuten, Inc.
Fuminori Tanizaki / NTT SMARTCONNECT CORPORATION
Akira Nakagawa / KDDI CORPORATION 4

5. Do you remember? There are opinion, concern and comments from
a lot of comment post to sig-policy ML from Izumi-san
Subject: Re: [sig-policy] Inter-registry transfers (was:thoughts on prop-068)
Subject: Re: [sig-policy] general opinions about the transfer proposal(s)
Subject: Re: [sig-policy] Requests from routing/packeting concerns
There are opinion, concern and comments from
Japanese Community!!
How can we post a lot of opinion?
Result get could by our challenges. 5

6. Motivation We must post opinion and comment.
When transfer proposal posted
We think this proposal
provide very important changes to history of IP management.
had serious effect on Japanese Community.
We must post opinion and comment.
We propose other perspective if necessary. 6

7. Our Challenges
We(JPNIC and Policy-WG) want comment and opinion from JP- Community for transfer proposal more and more.
Discussed for solve this issue.
“How can we provide information for transfer proposal to community?”
“What kind of method for get comment from community we have?”
We want held two events done before next APOPM. 7

8. JPOPM Showcase 2 Date: 21st January 2009 Place: Kochi, Japan
the day before JANOG23 Meeting
Place: Kochi, Japan
same place as JANOG23 Meeting
about 50 peoples 8

9. JPOPM Showcase 2 activity for outreach to stakeholders
introduce policy development process
discussion for specific topic
transfer proposal discussion by operator perspective. 9

10. Special JPOPM Date: 10th Feburary 2009 Place: Tokyo, Japan
about 60 peoples(onsite) and many people attend by online(streaming and chat). 10

11. Special JPOPM
provide information about proposal document what propose to next APOPM.
get comment and concern
for 30 minutes.
collect opinion for transfer proposal
opinion for each proposal
[prop-050] IPv4 address transfers
[prop-067] A simple transfer proposal
[prop-068] Inter-RIR transfer policy
for 3 hours(take two breaks) 11

12. Result We got a lot of opinion and comments from JP-Community.
Izumi-san can translate and post to sig- policy ML.
Some comment to our opinion from sig- policy then feedback to ML in Japanese.
discussion continues now
We can bring comments to meeting(Policy-SIG)
see you policy-sig on tomorrow :-) 12

13. Thank You 13