1. Japan’s proposal for EPPR-16-10
25/Apr/ 2016
JAPAN AUTOMOBILE STANDARDS INTERNATIONALIZATION CENTER

2. Exemption of F.F.D
Annex 1
Functional aspects of on-board diagnostic (OBD) systems
P20
3. Diagnostic signals
[3.1. Except in the case of grade A OBD, upon determination of the first malfunction of any component or system, “freeze-frame” engine conditions present at the time shall be stored in computer memory in accordance with the specifications in point Stored engine conditions shall include, but are not limited to, calculated load value, engine speed, fuel trim value(s) (if available), fuel pressure (if available), vehicle speed (if available), coolant temperature (if available), intake manifold pressure (if available), closed- or open-loop operation (if available) and the diagnostic trouble code which caused the data to be stored ].
[ Except in the case of grade A OBD, The manufacturer shall choose the most appropriate set of conditions facilitating effective and efficient repairs in freeze-frame storage. Only one frame of data is required. Manufacturers may choose to store additional frames provided that at least the required frame can be read by a generic scan tool meeting the specifications of points 3.9. and If the diagnostic trouble code causing the conditions to be stored is erased in accordance with point of Section II the stored engine conditions may also be erased].
Japan comments:
Japan accepts the exemption of F.F.D in category of Grade-A.
Justification:
F.F.D improves the repair efficiency, however it costs large burden to implement the additional memory of ECU for non-volatile only for the purpose of OBD-I for Grade-A.

3. Exemption of Data stream
Annex 1
Functional aspects of on-board diagnostic (OBD) systems
P20
[3.2. Except in the case of grade A OBD, if available, the following signals in accordance with the specifications in point in addition to the required freeze-frame information shall be made available on demand through the serial port on the standardised diagnostic connector, if the information is available to the on-board computer or can be determined using information available to the on-board computer: number of stored diagnostic trouble codes, engine coolant temperature, fuel control system status (closed-loop, open-loop, other), fuel trim, ignition timing advance, intake air temperature, manifold air pressure, air flow rate, engine speed, throttle position sensor output value, secondary air status (upstream, downstream or atmosphere), calculated load value, vehicle speed, the position of the antilock brake system switch (on/off), the activated default mode(s) and fuel pressure].
The signals shall be provided in standard units based on the specifications in point Actual signals be clearly identified separately from default value [or limp-home signals]
Japan comments:
Data-steam is essential for OBD.
Japan does not agree to the exemption of Data-stream in case of Grade-A.
Justification:
Data-stream contributes for improvement of the repair efficiency and furthermore, it does not require additional cost for ECU of Grade-A.
Data stream is more important information than F.F.D for repairer, especially for the confirmation after the replacement of parts.