Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

An overview of turbulent transport in tokamaks

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "An overview of turbulent transport in tokamaks"— Presentation transcript:

1 An overview of turbulent transport in tokamaks
Michael Barnes Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics University of Oxford

2 Turbulence and confinement
What determines particle, momentum, and energy transport in magnetically confined plasmas? (spoiler: it’s microturbulence) How big is turbulent transport and can we reduce it? (practical MCF question) What are the properties of microturbulence in (nearly) collisionless, magnetized plasma?(fundamental physics question, interesting in laboratory/space/astro plasmas)

3 Turbulence and transport in hot, magnetized plasmas

4 Turbulence and transport in hot, magnetized plasmas

5 Toroidal drift instability (ITG/ETG)

6 Toroidal drift instability (ITG/ETG)

7 Toroidal drift instability (ITG/ETG)
+ + + vE E vE E + + + vE E

8 Good curvature vs. bad curvature

9 Good curvature vs. bad curvature

10 Turbulence stable on inside
+ + + vE E vE E + + + vE E

11 Instability has a critical gradient
Growth rate of instability in bad curvature region increases with magnitude of temperature gradient: Plasma in bad curvature region is swept along field lines into good curvature region, making a competition between stabilization and destabilization. Expect net instability when: This implies a critical temperature gradient necessary to sustain instability:

12 What wavelengths are unstable?
Instability depends on charge separation via magnetic drifts Growth rate of instability related to rate at which charge separation occurs: If gyroradius large compared to perturbation scale, reduces instability drive

13 What wavelengths are unstable?
+ + + E E + + + E

14 Turbulent fluctuation amplitude small
Density (n) Eddy size ~ ρ L Position

15 Estimate for turbulent transport
Random walk step size ~ eddy size ~ gyration radius Average time between steps ~ eddy turnover time ( ) Combine with diffusion equation to get estimate for energy confinement time: 105 10-5 s

16 Estimate for turbulent transport
Random walk step size ~ eddy size ~ gyration radius Average time between steps ~ eddy turnover time ( ) Combine with diffusion equation to get estimate for energy confinement time:

17 How good must the confinement be?

18 Kinetic corrections So far, picture has been essentially fluid, even though collisional mean free path is long; what about kinetic effects? Not all particles travel at sound speed along field Significant number of particles travel slower Some particles are trapped in bad curvature region due to magnetic mirroring

19 Turbulence determines plasma profiles
Turbulence diffusion coefficient depends strongly on temperature: Core Diffusion coefficient large in core where temperature is high, making it difficult to go above critical temperature gradient Energy input Edge Edge temperature is very important! Critical T’ T’/T

20 Range of scales Time scale (seconds) 10-12 10-10 10-8 10-6 10-4 10-2 1
Gyromotion Turbulence Mean profiles Collisions Space scale (meters) 10-5 10-3 10-1 10 103 Gyromotion Mean Profiles Turbulence Collisions

21 Formation of small scales in v-space

22 Formation of small scales in v-space

23 Formation of small scales in v-space
Drift velocity = Particles with Larmor orbits separated by turbulence wavelength ‘see’ different averaged potential Drift velocities decorrelated, thus phase mixing Schekochihin et al., PPCF 2008

24 Kinetic description of dynamics

25 Numerical expense (brute force)
Time scale (seconds) 10-12 10-10 10-8 10-6 10-4 10-2 1 Temporal grid: ~1013 time steps Collisions Space scale (meters) 10-5 10-3 10-1 10 103 Spatial grid: ~106 grid points x 3-D = 1018 grid points Velocity grid: ~10 grid points x 3-D = 103 grid points Total: ~1034 total grid points

26 Gyrokinetic description of dynamics
Average over fast gyro-motion and follow ‘guiding center’ position Eliminates fast time scale and gyro-angle variable (6-D  5-D)

27 Numerical expense (gyrokinetics)
Time scale (seconds) 10-12 10-10 10-8 10-6 10-4 10-2 1 Temporal grid: ~109 time steps gyrofrequency Space scale (meters) 10-5 10-3 10-1 10 103 Perpendicular spatial grid: ~106 grid points x 2-D = 1012 grid points Parallel spatial grid: ~10 grid points x 1-D = 10 grid points Velocity grid: ~10 grid points x 2-D v-space = 102 grid points Total: ~1024 total grid points (1010 savings)

28 Multi-scale gyrokinetics
Decompose f into mean and fluctuating components: Mean varies perpendicular to mean field on system size while fluctuations vary on scale of gyro-radius: Fluctuations are anisotropic with respect to the mean field: => Turbulent fluctuations are low amplitude: => Mean profile evolution slow compared to turbulence:

29 Gyrokinetic-Poisson system
Gyrokinetic equation: Quasineutrality: Equilibrium:

30 Multi-scale gyrokinetics
Turbulent fluctuations calculated in small regions of fine space-time grid embedded in coarse grid for mean quantities GS2 Trinity

31 Numerical expense (multi-scale GK)
Time scale (seconds) 10-12 10-10 10-8 10-6 10-4 10-2 1 Temporal grid: ~105 time steps mean-fluctuation separation Space scale (meters) 10-5 10-3 10-1 10 103 Perpendicular spatial grid: ~105 grid points x 2-D = 1010 grid points Parallel spatial grid: ~10 grid points x 1-D = 10 grid points Velocity grid: ~10 grid points x 2-D v-space = 102 grid points Total: ~1018 total grid points (106 savings)

32 Simulating gyrokinetic turbulence

33 Simulating gyrokinetic turbulence
v v||

34 Can we use the machinery just developed (gyrokinetics) to determine basic turbulence properties?

35 Turbulent heating Assume turbulent plasma dominated by electrons and hydrogenic ions How much are passive minority ions heated by turbulence? Gyrokinetics restricts us to isotropic heating because magnetic moment is conserved Turbulent heating mechanism is Joule heating:

36 Cartoon of mass-dependent fluctuations
Acceleration = heavy ions F acceleration light ions v||

37 Cartoon of mass-dependent fluctuations
heavy ions F acceleration light ions v||

38 Heating from GK simulation
Simple picture consistent with GK simulations and solar wind observations Minority ion temperatures in solar wind Heating from GK simulation Schmidt et al., Geophys. Res. Lett. (1980). Barnes et al. PRL (2012)

39 Fundamental properties of GK turbulence
Take GK and make a few simple conjectures: Isotropy in plane perpendicular to B-field Position and velocity space scales linked Parallel streaming time and nonlinear turnover time comparable at all scales (critical balance) Parallel length at outer scale set by system size (connection length)

40 Smooth, isotropic v-space (kρ < 1)
Assume Quasineutrality:

41 Definition of nonlinear time scale:
Critical balance Physical idea: two points along field correlated only if information propagates between them before turbulence decorrelated in perpendicular plane Definition of nonlinear time scale: Critical balance:

42 Outer scale

43 Outer scale Injection rate comparable to nonlinear decorrelation time:
Combine with critical balance:

44 Outer scale Take parallel length scale to be connection length
Connection length = distance along field line from outside to inside ~ qR q = number of toroidal transits per poloidal transit. measures pitch of field line

45 Outer scale Take parallel length scale to be connection length
With and , can solve for and and

46 Heat flux and Assume most energy contained in outer scale and use diffusive estimate for heat flux: with

47 Turbulence scaling tests
Barnes et al., PRL 2011

48 Inertial range

49 Inertial range (kρ < 1)
Flux of free energy (nonlinear invariant) scale-independent in inertial range: Free energy:

50 Matching Match solution from outer and inertial scales

51 Inertial range (kρ << 1)
Flux of free energy (nonlinear invariant) scale-independent in inertial range: Free energy:

52 Inertial range (kρ << 1)
Convert expression for into 1D spectrum Use critical balance with to relate and

53 Inertial range spectra
Barnes et al., PRL 2011

54 Correlation function:
Critical balance test Correlation function: Barnes et al., PRL 2011

55 Inertial range critical balance
Barnes et al., PRL 2011

56 Turbulence properties
Barnes et al., PRL 2011 Schekochihin et al., ApJ 2009

57 Dissipation scale Dissipation range

58 Dissipation scale At dissipation scale, dissipation rate comparable to nonlinear decorrelation rate Decorrelation in v-space due to finite Larmor radius


Download ppt "An overview of turbulent transport in tokamaks"

Similar presentations


Ads by Google