Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
YOUNGSTER’S VISION OF THE WORLD
EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World Claude GRASLAND (Univ. Paris Diderot) Clarisse DIDELON (Univ. Le Havre)
2
FP7 Eurobroadmap partners…
1. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique – France 2. Université Paris Diderot - Paris 7 (UPD) - France 3. Université Libre de Belgique (ULB) - Belgium 4. Centro de Estudos Geogràficos (CEG) - Portugal 5. Nordic Center for Spatial Development – Sweden 6. IRMCo - Malta 7. University Alexandru Ioan Cuza (UAIC) - Romania 8. Dokuz Eylül University (DEU) – Turkey 9. University of São Paulo (USP) - Brazil 10. CAUPA Cameroon 11. East China Normal University (ECNU) - China 12. University of Delhi - India
3
A 3 years project ( ) Subjective (di)visions of the World : WP.2 and W.P.3 Political (di)visions of the World : WP.4 Functional (di)visions of the World : WP.5 Integrated visions : WP.6
4
A Worldwide survey 18 Countries 43 Cities 9341 Students Arts Business
Politics Engineer Health Social Science
5
INTRODUCTION : STUDENTS EXPERIENCE OF THE WORLD
EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World Mobility of students and scales of belonging
6
Questions of Part A
7
International mobility (1)
8
International mobility (2)
9
Communication
10
Scales of belonging
11
A. THE CONCEPTS OF KNOWLEDGE AND ASYMETRY
EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World The example of Tunisian Students
12
Question of part B
13
General framework for analysis
DO NOT MENTION … WOULD LIKE TO LIVE IN … WOULD NOT LIKE TO LIVE IN … LIVE OR HAS LIVED IN ..
14
(1) Analysis of countries quoted
DO NOT MENTION … WOULD LIKE TO LIVE IN … WOULD NOT LIKE TO LIVE IN … LIVE OR HAS LIVED IN ..
15
(2) Analysis of countries ignored
DO NOT MENTION … WOULD LIKE TO LIVE IN … WOULD NOT LIKE TO LIVE IN … LIVE OR HAS LIVED IN ..
16
(3) Analysis of countries where students come from
DO NOT MENTION … WOULD LIKE TO LIVE IN … WOULD NOT LIKE TO LIVE IN … LIVE OR HAS LIVED IN ..
17
CONCEPTS & MEASURE NB : 255 Students observed in Sfax
A : 244 answered to question B Y : 59 would like to live in Germany N : 19 would not like to live in Germany KNOWLEDGE = (Y+N) / A (0 to 100%) => 32 % of students mentionned Germany ASYMETRY = (Y-N) / (Y+N) (-1 to +1) => indicate a positive but balanced attraction
18
Knowledge: Example of Tunisia
19
Knowledge: Comments on Tunisia
France is quoted in 1st rank by 79% of Tunisian, which is more than usual (51%) USA are quoted in 2nd rank by 53% of Tunisian, which is a bit less than usual (60%) Neighbours countries are over-mentionned ( Algeria, Lybia, Egypt, Italy …) Iraq and Iran are less mentionned than usual (which means less negatively …) Etc…
20
Knowledge: general results
21
Knowledge: General results
22
Asymetry: Example of Tunisia
23
Asymetry: Comments on Tunisia
Some countries are more positive for Tunisian : ex. France (+0.95 instead of +0.67) Some countries are less positive for Tunisian : ex. UK (+0.31 instead of +0.77) Some countries are more negative for Tunisian : ex. Morocco (-0.36 instead of -0.05) Some countries are less negative for Tunisian : ex. Iran (-0.56 instead of -0.95) Some countries reverse from negative to positive : ex. Turkey (+0.83 instead of -0.37) or Syria (-0.95 to +0.57)
24
Asymmetry: General results
25
Asymmetry: General results
26
K & A : Example of Tunisia
27
K & A: Specificities of Tunisia
28
From measure to mental maps
In which countries would you like to live in the near future ? The SIZE of circles should be proportional to the degree of KNOWLEDGE by students. The COLOUR of circles should be related to ASYMMETRY. With opposite colours for LIKE and DISLIKE.
29
WORLD MAPS (Tunisia)
30
ZOOM MAPS (Tunisia)
31
ANAMORPHOSIS From … The SIZE of countries should be proportional to the degree of KNOWLEDGE by students. The COLOUR of countries should be related to ASYMMETRY. With opposite colours for LIKE and DISLIKE. … to
32
B. COMPARISON OF MENTAL MAPS OF STUDENTS
EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World Visualisation of states where students would like or not like to live
33
OLD EU MEMBER STATES
34
France
35
Belgium
36
Sweden
37
Portugal
38
NEW MEMBER STATES
39
Malta
40
Hungary
41
Romania
42
EASTERN NEIGHBORHOOD
43
Moldova
44
Turkey
45
Azerbaïdjan
46
SOUTHERN NEIGHBORHOOD
47
Egypt
48
Tunisia
49
Senegal
50
Cameroon
51
« BRIC » COUNTRIES
52
Brazil
53
Russia
54
India
55
China
56
Correlation between positive visions (LIKE)
Cameroon & Senegal Egypt & Tunisia CHINA INDIA EUROPEAN UNION RUSSIA BRAZIL
57
Correlation between negative visions (NOT LIKE)
Cameroon & Senegal CHINA BRAZIL Turkey WESTERN EUROPE Egypt & Tunisia EASTERN EUROPE & RUSSIA INDIA
58
C. ELABORATION OF A SYNTHETIC WORLD MAP
EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World Can we summarize the visions of the students of the 18 countries of the survey ?
59
Type A1 : Global Pull
60
Type A1 : Global Pull
61
Type A2 : Balanced Pull
62
Type A2 : Balanced Pull
63
Type B: Mixed Push-Pull
64
Type B : Mixed Push-Pull
65
Type B : Mixed Push-Pull
66
Type C.1 : Balanced Push
67
Type C.1 : Balanced Push
68
Type C.2 : Global Push
69
Type C.2 : Global Push
70
Type C.2 : Global Push
71
Typology of world states
72
D. THE LAWS OF PERCEPTION
EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World What can explain the choice of countries where students would LIKE to live ?
73
Qualitative assumptions
Because they have heard of the country Because it is rich Because it is open to migration Because it is not far Because it has historical linkage Because it has a common language …
74
Quantitative formalisation
75
(1) Size effect Hypothesis: BIG countries are more attractive than SMALL countries. 83 2
76
(1) Size effect H1 is true for all countries with very high level of significance
77
(2) Economic effect Hypothesis: RICH countries are more attractive than POOR countries. 59 20
78
(2) Economic effect H2 is true for all countries with very high level of significance
79
(3) Density effect (migratory policy)
Hypothesis: EMPTY countries (open to migration) are more attractive than FULL countries (closed to migration) 48 16
80
(3) Density effect H3 is true for all countries but significant only for 6 out of 18
81
(4) Distance effect Hypothesis: NEAR countries are more attractive than REMOTE countries 188 47
82
(4) Distance effect H5 is true for all countries but not very significant for France and not at all for China
83
(5) Neighbourhood effect
Hypothesis: CONTIGUOUS countries are more attractive than NON CONTIGUOUS 15 2
84
(5) Neighbourhood effect
H5 is true only for France and Azerbaïdjan. The reverse hypothesis is true for Tunisia, Egypt, Cameroon and Russia.
85
(6) Language effect Hypothesis: countries with COMMON LANGUAGE are more attractive than others 11 3
86
(6) Language effect H6 is true and significant for the majority of countries. But it is sometime not significant and is reversed in the case of Azerbaijan
87
(7) Historical effect Hypothesis: countries with former COLONIAL RELATIONS are more attractive than others 59 188
88
(7) Historical effect H6 is true for some countries (India, Malta, Tunisia …) but reversed for others (Azerbaïdjan, Cameroon, Senegal).
89
Huntington, Ravenstein & Diderot
E. CONCLUSION EUROBROADMAP PROJECT - FP7-SHS Visions of Europe in the World Huntington, Ravenstein & Diderot
90
Huntington’s interpretation of results could be something like …
Egyptian or Tunisian students would not like to live in Israël in a near future Muslims don’t like Jews Indian students would not like to live in Pakistan or Bangladesh Hindi don’t like Muslims European students would not like to live in subsaharian Africa Whites don’t like Blacks
91
Huntington’s interpretation of results could be something like that …
ALL OF THIS NICELY SUPPORT THE THEORY OF THE CLASH OF CIVILIZATIONS, ISN’T IT? BUT …
92
Ravenstein’s interpretation of results could be different
Egyptian would not like to live in Israël in a near future It is very common to have a negative picture of at less one neighbor country. Indian students would not like to live in Pakistan or Bangladesh the memory of war and conflict is a barrier that decrease through time European students would not like to live in subsaharian Africa Students are more attracted by richer countries , what else ?
93
Ravenstein’s interpretation of results could be something like that …
MENTAL MAPS ARE GOVERNED BY SOME GENERAL LAWS BASED ON SIZE AND DISTANCE. DON’T FOCUS ON RESIDUALS !
94
The last word … Si la raison gouvernait les hommes, si elle avait sur les chefs des nations l'empire qui lui est dû, on ne les verrait point se livrer inconsidérément aux fureurs de la guerre. D. Diderot
95
Thank you for your attention !
The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Community's Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/ ) under grant agreement n°
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.