1. Intercomparison between 1D Fog Forecasting Models
In Lindenberg (Germany)
COST 722 – Working Group 2 – Larnarca May 2005

2. Participants Mathias Müller, University of Basel, 1D COBEL-NOAH
- Olivier Liechti, Analyse and Concept, tBM
Andreas Bott and Matthieu Masbou,
University of Bonn, PAFOG

3. Fog Periods We proposed 2 Periods : With FOG : 24 – 29 September 1998
: fog 3-7 h and 8-10 h
: fog 3-11 h
: no fog
: fog 3-9 h and h
: fog 0-10 h
Without FOG : 15 – 17 October 1998

4. Input Data 12 or 18 UTC Atmospheric Profiles - Temperature
- Liquid Water Content
- Specific Humidity
- Cloud Cover
Soil Profiles
- Soil Humidity
- Soil Temperature
- Soil Ice Content

5. 24 September 1998

6. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

7. Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

8. Visibility 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

9. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

10. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

11. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

12. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

13. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

14. Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

15. Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

16. Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

17. 25 September 1998

18. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

19.
Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

20.
Visibility 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

21.
Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

22.
Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

23. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

24. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

25. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

26.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

27.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

28.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

29. 26 September 1998

30.
Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

31.
Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

32. Visibility 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

33. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

34. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

35. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

36. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

37. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

38.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

39.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

40.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

41. 27 September 1998

42. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

43.
Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

44. Visibility 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

45. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

46. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

47. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

48. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

49. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

50.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

51.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

52.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

53. 28 September 1998

54. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

55. Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

56. Visibility 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

57. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

58. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

59. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

60. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

61. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

62.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

63.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

64.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

65. 29 September 1998

66. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

67. Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

68. Visibility 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

69. Sensibility Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

70. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

71. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

72. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

73. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

74.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

75.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

76.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

77. 15 October 1998

78. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

79. Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

80. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

81. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

82. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

83. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

84. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

85.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

86.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

87.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

88. 16 October 1998

89. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

90. Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

91. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

92. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

93. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

94. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

95. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

96.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

97.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

98.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

99. 17 October 1998

100. Liquid Water Content
COBEL-NOAH
tBM
PAFOG

101. Temperature 2m
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

102. Sensible Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

103. Latent Flux
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

104. Specific Humidity Profile 00
Specific Humidity Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

105. Specific Humidity Profile 06
Specific Humidity Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

106. Specific Humidity Profile 12
Specific Humidity Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

107.
Temperature Profile 00
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

108.
Temperature Profile 06
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

109.
Temperature Profile 12
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

110. Annexe
Radiative Fluxes

111. IR DOWN Profile
3 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

112. IR DOWN Profile
4 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

113. IR DOWN Profile
5 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

114. IR DOWN Profile
6 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

115. IR DOWN Profile
7 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

116. IR DOWN Profile
8 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

117. IR DOWN Profile
9 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

118. IR DOWN Profile
10 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

119. IR DOWN Profile
11 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

120. IR UP Profile
3 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

121. IR UP Profile
4 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

122. IR UP Profile
5 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

123. IR UP Profile
6 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

124. IR UP Profile
7 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

125. IR UP Profile
8 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

126. IR UP Profile
9 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

127. IR UP Profile
10 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

128. IR UP Profile
11 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

129. Short Wave DOWN Profile
6 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

130. Short Wave DOWN Profile
7 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

131. Short Wave DOWN Profile
8 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

132. Short Wave DOWN Profile
9 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

133. Short Wave DOWN Profile
10 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

134. Short Wave DOWN Profile
11 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

135. Short Wave DOWN Profile
12 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

136. Short Wave UP Profile
6 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

137. Short Wave UP Profile
7 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

138. Short Wave UP Profile
8 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

139. Short Wave UP Profile
9 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

140. Short Wave UP Profile
10 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

141. Short Wave UP Profile
11 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM

142. Short Wave UP Profile
12 UTC
Measures
PAFOG
COBEL-NOAH
tBM