1. PAR Review - Meeting Agenda and Comment slides - San Antonio 2016
July 2016
doc.: IEEE /1326r1
November 2016
PAR Review - Meeting Agenda and Comment slides - San Antonio 2016
Date:
Authors:
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

2. Abstract-Snapshot Nov 6-11, 2016, San Antonio, TX, USA
July 2016
doc.: IEEE /1326r1
November 2016
Abstract-Snapshot
Nov 6-11, 2016, San Antonio, TX, USA
PARs under consideration:
802c - Amendment: Local Medium Access Control (MAC) Address Usage, PAR Modification
802.1AR:  Standard - Secure Device Identity, PAR and CSD
802.1CS - Standard: Link-local Registration Protocol, PAR and CSD
802.3cg - Amendment: 10 Mb/s Operation over Single Balanced Twisted-pair Cabling and Associated Power Delivery , PAR and CSD
Amendment: Low-power wake-up radio operation, PAR and CSD
– Standard: Coexistence of Unlicensed Wireless Systems in an Automotive Environment , PAR and CSD
Meeting times: Monday PM2, Tuesday AM2, Thursday AM2
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

3. PAR Review SC – November 2016 Chair: Jon Rosdahl
July 2016
doc.: IEEE /1326r1
November 2016
PAR Review SC – November 2016 Chair: Jon Rosdahl
Draft Agenda:
Monday Agenda:
Welcome
Approve Previous Minutes
Determine order of review
Review PARs/CSD posted for review this week.
Recess
Tuesday Agenda:
Complete review of PARs/CSD and post comments to 802 WGs
Thursday Agenda:
Review Response to Comments
Prepare Report for WG closing plenary
Adjourn
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

4. Motion to Approve Previous Minutes
November 2016
Motion to Approve Previous Minutes
Move to approve doc 11-16/0986r0 < 0PAR-minutes-july-2016-session.docx> as the minutes for PAR Review SC from July 2016 Plenary in San Diego. Moved: Mike Montemurro 2nd: Stuart Kerry Results: 4-0-1
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

5. November 2016
Par Review Comments
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

6. November 2016
802c - Amendment: Local Medium Access Control (MAC) Address Usage, PAR Modification
No Comment
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

7. 802.1AR: Standard - Secure Device Identity, PAR and CSD
November 2016
802.1AR:  Standard - Secure Device Identity, PAR and CSD
No Comment
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

8. 802.1CS - Standard: Link-local Registration Protocol, PAR and CSD
November 2016
802.1CS - Standard: Link-local Registration Protocol, PAR and CSD
PAR:
5.2 “rapidly, accurately, and efficiently”
do you have any metric to quantify these adverbs.
5.5 – expansion of first use Acronym
Change MRP "802.1Q Multiple Registration Protocol“
to “802.1Q Multiple Registration Protocol (MRP)”
5.5 – Quantify: smaller vs bigger – give numeric range for each.
CSD:
1.2.1 – MRP acronym expansion needed.
Change “New applications like industrial automation” to “New applications in industrial automation”
1.2.3 LRP and LLDP expansion needed
Suggestion – add a use case example to expand the 2nd paragraph What is IS-IS? Please expand.
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

9. November 2016
802.3cg - Amendment: 10 Mb/s Operation over Single Balanced Twisted-pair Cabling and Associated Power Delivery , PAR and CSD
Replace 5.2.b. Scope of the project: with “Specify additions to and appropriate modifications of IEEE Std to add 10 Mb/s Physical Layer (PHY) specifications and management parameters for operation and associated optional provision of power on single balanced twisted-pair copper cabling.” 5.5 – change “IEEE 802.3” to “IEEE Std 802.3” 5.6 suggestion is to delete “factory, process” as they are redundant 8.1 – add “5.2.b. - IEEE Std – <full title of standard.>
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

10. November 2016
Standard: Coexistence of Unlicensed Wireless Systems in an Automotive Environment , PAR and CSD
Change scope 5.2 to “This recommended practice recommends dynamic parameter values for IEEE 802 and Bluetooth devices operating in the 2.4 GHz band to enhance their performance in the automotive environment.” 5.4 request to quantify “improvements in throughput, latency, reliability, PESQ (Perceptual Evaluation Speech Quality) score etc” 5.4 change “for example” to “such as” 5.4 delete “the” prior to physical layer and medium access…(two instances)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

11. November 2016
Standard: Coexistence of Unlicensed Wireless Systems in an Automotive Environment , PAR and CSD
5.4 change
“The typical scenarios the recommended practice will include:
Interference among IEEE devices in the 2.4 GHz band.
Interference between IEEE devices and non IEEE devices in the 2.4 GHz band.
Non-IEEE devices in the 2.4 GHz band include but are not limited to Bluetooth devices.” To
“The recommended practice addresses interference scenarios among and between 2.4 GHz IEEE 802 and non-IEEE 802 devices (e.g. Bluetooth).”
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

12. November 2016
Standard: Coexistence of Unlicensed Wireless Systems in an Automotive Environment , PAR and CSD
5.5 replace the Need for Project with “The automotive environment is one of the 2.4 GHz wireless environments with rapidly increasing deployment. This environment differs from the enterprise or residential environments. Automotive environments are characterized by high density of access points and stations (e.g. in traffic jams) with inter-AP distance of 2m-3m and dynamically changing interference conditions. There is extensive use of non IEEE 802 technologies in the 2.4 GHz band, which require consideration of coexistence issues. This recommended practice aims to improve coexistence and performance in 2.4 GHz.
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

13. 802.11 Amendment: Low-power wake-up radio operation, PAR and CSD
July 2016
doc.: IEEE /1326r1
November 2016
Amendment: Low-power wake-up radio operation, PAR and CSD
1.1 Project Number – change to “P802.11ba” 2.1 Title – need to quantify “Low-power” suggest “Low-power (less than 1mill-watt)” 5.2.b. The scope uses “normal” which should be removed. Is it really a new PHY layer that uses both 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz bands? Use of “packets” seems odd to use rather than “frame”? Can this work in the 3 GHz, 60Ghz or Whitespace bands as well? The current scope statement seems to be a listing of market points for the amendment. Proposed Scope replacement text 5.2.b Scope of the Project: This amendment defines physical (PHY) layer and medium access control (MAC) layer specifications that enables operation of a wake-up radio (WUR). The WUR defines an active receiver with expected power consumption of less than one milliwatt.
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

14. 802.11 Amendment: Low-power wake-up radio operation, PAR and CSD
November 2016
Amendment: Low-power wake-up radio operation, PAR and CSD
5.5 suggested changes:
Change “Devices based on the power save modes of the IEEE standard periodically wake up from a sleep… “
To “Devices based on the IEEE power save modes periodically wake up from a sleep…”
Change “Therefore, for the standard to be competitive, the IEEE WG needs to develop power efficient mechanisms “
To “Power efficient mechanisms need …”
Delete “This project addresses this need. This project is also expected to benefit traditional devices with WLAN interfaces such as smartphones.”
8.1 delete the 5.2.b. note (all the text).
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

15. November 2016
Responses From 802 WGs
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

16. November 2016
Final Report to
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

17. Motion To Approve Report
July 2016
doc.: IEEE /1326r1
November 2016
Motion To Approve Report
Move to accept 11-16/1326rX as the report from PAR Review SC for the November plenary.
Moved:
2nd:
Results:
This Document
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)

18. References IEEE 802 PARs Under consideration Webpage: Minutes:
July 2016
doc.: IEEE /1326r1
November 2016
References
IEEE 802 PARs Under consideration Webpage:
Minutes:
Previous Plenary: 11-16/986r0:
< july-2016-session.docx>
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)
Jon Rosdahl, (Qualcomm)