Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Watch in slide show mode to observe (modest) animation.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Watch in slide show mode to observe (modest) animation."— Presentation transcript:

1 Watch in slide show mode to observe (modest) animation.
comments questions: papers, etc:

2 How Much Progress with “Progress”? A Dialectical Monologue
How Much Progress with “Progress”? A Dialectical Monologue Dan M. Kahan Yale University & many x 103 others

3 How Much Progress with “Progress”? A Dialectical Monologue
How Much Progress with “Progress”? A Dialectical Monologue or Something Dan M. Kahan Yale University & many x 103 others

4 What am I talking about? Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you
Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

5 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

6 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

7 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

8 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

9

10

11 study_dismiss scale (α = 0.85)

12 Cultural Cognition Worldviews
Risk Perception Key Low Risk High Risk Hierarchy climate change nuclear power air & water pollution guns/gun control Marijuana legalization Abortion procedure Anti-terrorism cats/ridiculous birds Hierarchy-individualism Hierarchy-communitarianism Individualism Communitarianism Marijuana legalization Abortion procedure Anti-terrorism cats/ridiculous birds climate change nuclear power air & water pollution guns/gun control Egalitarian-individualism Egalitarian-individualism Egalitarianism

13 Marijuana legalization cats/ridiculous birds
Cultural Cognition Worldviews Risk Perception Key Low Risk High Risk Hierarchy climate change nuclear power air & water pollution guns/gun control Individualism Communitarianism Marijuana legalization Abortion procedure Anti-terrorism cats/ridiculous birds climate change nuclear power air & water pollution guns/gun control Egalitarianism

14 Control Condition

15 Anti-pollution Condition

16 Geoengineering Condition

17 study_dismiss scale (α = 0.85)

18 Anti-pollution Condition

19 Geoengineering Condition

20 Diff. in Study dismiss (Std D’s)

21 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

22 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

23 Diff. in Study dismiss (Std D’s)

24 1.00 0.50 0.00 -0.50 -1.00 Dismissiveness (z-srore) Hierarch. individ.
Study dismiss (z-srore) Egal. commun. control antipollution geoengineering N = Combined English & US general population samples. Error bars denote 0.95 CIs.

25

26 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop talking about it

27 What am I talking about? Are people motivated by “progress”?
Thesis: Sure, I’ll show you Antithesis: No, take a closer look Synthesis: Sure, if you just stop looking at it

28 Angst over consumerism? Where??

29 You mean this?

30 Against capitalism? Seriously?

31 This is a fashion statement, . . .

32 so is this. . .

33 so are these . . .

34 . . . this is a worldview.

35 . . . it’s real . . .

36 . . . it’s antiliberal . . .

37 . . . it’s antimarket . . .

38 . . . it’s antidemocratic . . .

39 . . . it’s anti-progress . . .

40 and it’s not even on the table here!

41 the only thing that’s on the table are the tokens of a demeaning, petty symbolic status compeition

42 the only thing that’s on the table are the tokens of a demeaning, petty symbolic status compeition driven by intellectually juvenile, self-promoting entrepreneurs Naomi.klein.inc Rush.Limbaugh.inc

43 So don’t play that stupid game.
Stop looking & looking & looking at it. “Messaging” liberal democracy doesn’t motivate people. Living it does.

44 So don’t play that stupid game.
Stop looking & looking & looking at it. “Messaging” liberal democracy doesn’t motivate people. Living it does.

45 So don’t play that stupid game.
Stop looking & looking & looking at it. “Messaging”/arguing liberal democracy doesn’t motivate people. Living it does.

46 So don’t play that stupid game.
Stop looking & looking & looking at it. “Messaging”/arguing liberal democracy doesn’t motivate people. Living it does.

47 www. culturalcognition.net
“I am you!” 47


Download ppt "Watch in slide show mode to observe (modest) animation."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google