1. Introduction to Program Learning Assessment
Ed Morgan , or
Ed Morgan,
Associate Director, Center for the Enhancement of Learning and Teaching, Tufts University

2. Steps to a Sustainable Assessment Plan
Goals for learning in the degree program
Measurable Learning Objectives (Competencies, Intended Outcomes, etc.)
Student work, opinions, observations, that are Aligned and that Measure
For the student journey, a Curriculum Map
Gather together to assess, review results, and reflect Individually, to celebrate or make adjustments
This is an outline of an average process. This is to serve as inspiration for creating your own.

3. Goals for the degree program
In five years, you see a student at the airport. What do we want that students to know, be able to do, or care about?
To know is for knowledge (cognitive),
To do is for Skills (Behavioral), and
Cares (Affective) are for attitude, or emotion
Imagine you meet with program faculty, what would you need to have this conversation?

4. Measurable Learning Objectives
Measurable = Action / behavioral verbs (E.g. List, compare and contrast, apply, produce) How, can you see learning?
The key to measuring learning is to make it visible, and thus using the words understand, know, appreciate, (etc.), are thought processes, and not at all visible. So we avoid them in learning objectives. Instead use action or behavior verbs. See the “Sherfield and Moody Classification” document (handout) to select accurate and more fun words!
Handout: Criteria to evaluate Learning Objectives…

5. Examples of Measureable Objectives (Sentence stems…)
Will articulate their assumptions about students.
Will write a lesson plan.
Integrate effective communication processes into professional.
Collaborate with others to promote ….
Synthesize knowledge as the foundation for providing…

6. Evaluate these Objectives
Apply management principles and tools that are used to conserve biological diversity at levels from genes to landscapes (case studies, final poster project) .
Sometimes course instructors simply copy program objectives into their syllabus. A fair critique of my examples is that some are clearly course objectives. Program objectives are generally one step above course objectives, more general.
Source: Conservation Biology Syllabus

7. Evaluate these Objectives 1
Create geographic data from maps (georeferencing) (measure)
Understand key symbols for the interpretation of maps
“Understand” is a thought words, and is not visible. So we cannot tell if a student “understands”.
Source: GEOG 50: Introduction to GIS Syllabus

8. Evaluate these Objectives 2
Describe 5 of the ways in which both change and continuity have affected cultural history ( Write, chalk board, examples).
Appreciate the differences between western and eastern music traditions.
Next: If you have learning objectives, and courses that students follow on a journey, then you need, a map
Music 315: A Seminar in World Music Syllabus

9. Evaluate these Objectives 3
Select, effectively integrate, and document appropriate resource materials from library databases and print holdings [Music 315: A Seminar in World Music Syllabus].
Write essays that satisfy the specific needs of audiences in the disciplines of the sciences, social sciences, and humanities [English, 300-level].

10. Uses of a Curriculum Map
Identify useful evidence in assignments
Highlight the gaps and redundancies in teaching and learning within the curriculum,
Plan for purposefully increasing the level and quality of student knowledge, skills and cares,
Reveal the homogeneity or diversity of Assessment forms among classes.
This is about the student journey.
Solve problems for faculty, with evidence (aligned assignments, with clear criteria)
Duplication can be purposeful, or boring
Measured, documented growth and development of skills 
Variety of assessments to produce graduates with critical thinking skills that can be applied in communities and professions, 

11. Useful to quickly see student progress along each learning objective/intended outcome

12. CH 1/Introduction to Community Health CH 2/Health Care in America
Courses
CH 1/Introduction to Community Health
CH 2/Health Care in America
CH 30/CH Research Methods
Learning Outcomes
Students can understand how multiple disciplines bring unique perspectives to cross-cutting questions of health and societies.
[Measureable assignment]
Students can explain and assess social and behavioral interventions to improve the health of populations.
Here you can see more clearly how each course assignment moves students along.

13. Who has an external accreditor?
Usefulness of this chart: Directly document the relationship between the AVMA (external accreditor) Learning Outcomes, the DVM Curriculum’s learning activities, and assessments of student knowledge, skills and values.
This is also useful for General Education objective alignment with course assignments.

14. Gather to assess
Purpose: Examine “evidence” of program student learning, discover gaps in learning, plan adjustments to ensure optimal learning.
When: End of semester or year
What evidence?: Assignments you selected,
Who: Colleagues to talk, and synchronize
Fun!
Informing adjustments (solving problems):
E.g. Fashion Design; Zippers
E.g. Chemistry, multiple-choice,

15. Evaluation Criteria (Rubrics)
Provide equity to all students through clarity
Can be an equalizer with students with different preparation levels
Provides consistency across grading
A tool for student learning – how?
A tool for teacher reflection – how?
Criteria are how assignments become direct evidence, objective evidence, useful for adjustments,
How to develop:
Graphic arts teacher: >10 years, comments provided to students,
Copy and crap detector
Purpose is to provide useful feedback to students