Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
Three-Year Results Gore VIBRANT Clinical Study
Gary Ansel, MD, FACC Clinical Director of Peripheral-Vascular Interventionists at Midwest Cardiology Research Foundation, Columbus, OH Assistant Clinical Professor of Medicine, Medical College at Toledo, OH
2
Gary M. Ansel, MD Honoraria: Consulting Fees: Cardiometrics
W.L. Gore and Associates,Inc./Embolitech Consulting Fees: Cardiometrics Covidien/Ev3 Flexible Stenting Solutions Nellix, Inc.
3
GORE® VIABAHN® Endoprosthesis
Polished nitinol support Ultra-thin wall ePTFE tube Unique, durable bonding film Lengths: 2.5, 5, 10, and 15 cm Diameters: 6 – 8 mm Note: no heparin bioactive surface, 5mm diameter, or contoured proximal edge devices were used in the study
4
VIBRANT Take Home Messages
Toughest lesions ever studied in a controlled trial Bare nitinol stent (BNS) fracture still a concern Fractures increase with time Longer stents = more fractures Durable 3-year Results with Minimal Reinterventions for Long Lesions 85% of patients required ≤1 reintervention to maintain patency over 3 year period No amputations Stent grafts restenosed at edge; bare nitinol stents restenosed diffusely Continued understanding of the VIABAHN stent graft technical considerations Recent device (heparin-bonded surface, 5mm diameter) and manufacturing (proximal contoured edge) changes studied in VIPER and VIASTAR clinical studies
5
Gore VIBRANT Clinical Study Investigators
Co-PIs: Gary Ansel, MD; Mid-West Cardiology Research Foundation, Columbus, Ohio Patrick Geraghty, MD; Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri Mark Mewissen, MD; St. Luke’s Hospital, Milwaukee, Wisconsin Core Lab: The Vascular Ultrasound Core Laboratory, Boston, MA Dr. Michael R. Jaff, DO, RPVI, FACP, FACC Site Investigators: David Lasorda, DO, Allegheny General Hospital, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Michael Rush, MD, Holy Cross Hospital, Ft Lauderdale, Florida Jeffrey Goldstein, MD, St. Johns, Springfield, Illinois Bob Smouse, MD, St. Francis, Peoria, Illinois Manju Kalra, MD, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota Sean Lyden, MD, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio R. Andrew, MD, Midwest Heart Foundation, Lombard, Illinois Arun Chervu, MD, Vascular Surgical Associates, Austell, Georgia William Gray, MD, Columbia University Medical Center, New York, New York Romi Chopra, MD, Midwest Institute, Melrose Park, Illinois Sam Money, MD, Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, Arizona David Mego, MD, Arkansas Heart, Little Rock, Arkansas Mark Bates, MD, Charleston Medical Center, West Virginia Richard Begg, MD, Heritage Valley Health System, Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania Barry Katzen, MD, Baptist Cardiac & Vascular Institute, Miami, FL W. Charles Sternbergh, MD, Ochsner Clinic, New Orleans, Louisiana 5
6
Enrollment by Site Study Site Enrolled
St. Luke’s Medical Center, Milwaukee, WI 26 Midwest Cardiology Research Foundation, Columbus, OH 21 Midwest Heart Foundation, Lombard, IL 20 Vascular Surgical Associates, Austell, GA 18 Midwest Institute, Melrose Park, IL 15 Holy Cross Hospital, Ft Lauderdale, FL 11 Prairie Heart (St. John's), Springfield, IL 8 St. Francis, Peoria, IL Arkansas Heart, Little Rock, AK 7 Heritage Valley Health System, Beaver Falls, PA 6 Washington University Hospital, St. Louis, MO 3 Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH 2 Allegheny General Hospital, Pittsburgh, PA Ochsner Clinic, New Orleans, LA 1
7
Study Design 148 randomized patients enrolled
Test Group: GORE® VIABAHN® Endoprosthesis FDA approved for SFA indication, June 14, 2005 Does NOT include Bioactive Heparin Surface Does NOT include Contoured Edge Manufacturing Change n=72 Control Group: Bare Nitinol Stent Commercially available bare nitinol stent as determined by institutional standard of care when treating SFA occlusive disease and were not devices approved for SFA use n=76 GORE®, VIABAHN®, and designs are trademarks of W. L. Gore & Associates
8
Study Endpoints Primary Endpoints Secondary Endpoints
Three-year primary patency (duplex PSV ratio < 2.0 / core lab adjudicated) Safety (30 day composite of major complications) Secondary Endpoints Primary assisted patency Secondary patency Technical success Target vessel revascularization Target lesion revascularization Clinical success Change in ABI from baseline Alternate peak systolic velocity ratios of and 3.0 (core lab adjudicated) Stent fracture on plain X-ray (core lab adjudicated) Primary composite safety and efficacy endpoint Quality of Life Questionnaires Quantitative angiographic assessment of patterns of restenosis in the treated limb when control angiography is prompted 8
9
VIABAHN Endoprosthesis
Patient Demographics VIABAHN Endoprosthesis Bare Nitinol Stent p-value RANDOMIZED SUBJECTS 72 76 Gender (% male) 62.5% 64.5% 0.87 Average Age (years) 69 64 0.01 SMOKING STATUS 0.36 Current / Previous Smoker 81.9% 88.2% Never Smoked 18.1% 11.8% GENERAL MEDICAL HISTORY Diabetes 43.1% 44.7% Myocardial Infarction 23.6% 25.0% 0.85 Hypertension 87.5% 76.3% 0.09 Dyslipidemia 72.2% 77.6% 0.46 Family History of CAD 60.0% 0.05 COPD 12.5% 7.9% 0.42 Prev. PTA on Study Limb (≥ 6 mo) 6.9% 5.3% 0.74
10
Lesion Characteristics
VIABAHN Endoprosthesis Bare Nitinol Stent p-value TREATED OCCLUSIONS 61.1% 56.6% 0.62 TARGET LESION LENGTH (cm) 0.87 Mean (Std Dev) 19 (8) 18 (7) Median (Range) 20 (8 – 40) 16 (8 – 36) LESION CALCIFICATION 0.01 None – Mild 37.5% 57.9% Moderate – Severe 62.5% 42.1% TIBIAL RUNOFF 0.10 1 Vessel 15.3% 22.4% 2 Vessel 50.0% 32.9% 3 Vessel 34.7% 44.7% Technical success was 97% for the VIABAHN stent graft and 96% for Bare Stent (p=1.0)
11
VIABAHN Endoprosthesis
SAFETY Study Endpoint 30-DAY SAFETY OUTCOMES VIABAHN Endoprosthesis Bare Nitinol Stent NUMBER OF ENROLLED SUBJECTS 72 76 PROCEDURE-RELATED SAFETY ISSUES Access / Treatment Site Complications 1* OTHER SAFETY EVENTS Death Myocardial Infarction Acute Renal Insufficiency Study Limb Amputation * The single access site complication was thrombosis in the non-treatment leg, that was resolved with subsequent treatment. Major device-related adverse events at 3 years Embolism (VIABAHN device) and Other (VIABAHN device) No significant difference between arms (p=0.235) No unexpected trends for disease-related Major Adverse Events at 3 years No significant difference between arms (p=0.729)
12
Error bars = 95% confidence interval
VIBRANT 3 year Data Error bars = 95% confidence interval Comment on cross-over: Sixteen Bare Nitinol Stent patients received the VIABAHN Endoprosthesis during subsequent reinterventions, which complicates secondary endpoint comparisons.
13
Error bars = 95% confidence interval
Impact of PSVR Ratio Error bars = 95% confidence interval
14
Treating In-Stent Restenosis Upon Initial Failure of BMS
Freedom from Target Lesion Revascularization Error bars = 95% confidence interval 14 pts in each treatment arm
15
Error bars = standard deviation
Clinical Success Quality of Life Questionnaires Significant improvement in IC and SF-36 physical summary scores at three years No significant difference between treatment groups Error bars = standard deviation
16
Error bars = standard deviation
Clinical Success ABI and Rutherford Category Significant improvement in ABI and Rutherford Category at three years No significant difference between treatment groups Error bars = standard deviation
17
# Repeat Interventions / Subject Error bars = 95% confidence interval
Durable 3-year Results with Minimal Reinterventions for Long Lesions Treated Interventionally No amputations in either study arm # Repeat Interventions / Subject VIABAHN Stent Graft Bare Nitinol Stent 61% 65% 1 25% 22% 2 7% 8% 3+ 5% Error bars = 95% confidence interval
18
Patterns of Restenosis at 1 year
VIABAHN Endoprosthesis Focal edge stenosis comprised 87% of the VIABAHN Endoprostheses failures 50% isolated proximal edge 30% both proximal and distal edges 6% isolated distal edge 14% undetermined Bare Nitinol Stent Diffuse in-stent stenosis comprised 93% bare nitinol stent failures Results are Core Lab-adjudicated
21
Restenosis Patterns Differ and Impact Patient Symptoms
Quality of life and ABI is maintained in failing VIABAHN stent graft limbs compared to Bare Nitinol Stents (through 36 month follow-up) Effect of Stenosis (PSVR > 3) Clinical Outcomes VIABAHN Stent Graft Bare Nitinol Stent p-value Avg ICQ 20 33 < 0.05 Avg ABI 0.94 0.79 Avg Rutherford 0.8 1.2 0.11 ICQ: 0 = best, 100 = worst
22
Clinical Implications of Restenosis Patterns
Flow Dynamics Calculations* Assuming 80% focal (5 mm) versus diffuse (10 cm) restenosis pattern Pressure Drop in diffuse, in-stent stenosis is an order of magnitude higher than a focal edge stenosis Flow Rate through diffuse, in-stent stenosis is reduced by 50% as compared to flow through an edge stenosis *data on file
23
Stent Fractures for Bare Nitinol Stents are still a concern
Bare Nitinol Stents have a significantly higher fracture rate than the VIABAHN device (58% vs. 4.9%, respectively; p < 0.001) Fracture incidence increases over time Fractures are dependent on lesion length Fractures not always associated with overlap Bare Nitinol Stent Fractures at 36 Months Lesion Length Fracture No Fracture 8-15 cm 11% 89% 16-25 cm 55% 45% 26+ cm 73% 27% Error bars = 95% confidence interval
25
So if only we can limit stent graft edge restenosis the world will be a better place
26
VIBRANT Increases Our Understanding of the VIABAHN Stent Graft
Technical and Device Considerations Newest Device Iteration Demonstrated Efficacy 1000 Limbs in Literature VIBRANT Study VIPER, VIASTAR Studies Technical Considerations Healthy-to-healthy Avoid extreme oversizing Accurately measure vessel diameter New Device Characteristics Heparin Bonded Surface 5mm device SFA indication 6 Fr Profile Manufacturing Change Contoured proximal edge VIPER: 90% patency when sized appropriately, 79% if not and 5 mm did the best.
27
VIBRANT Take Home Messages
Toughest lesions ever studied in a controlled trial Bare nitinol stent (BNS) fracture still a concern Fractures increase with time Longer stents = more fractures Durable 3-year Results with Minimal Reinterventions for Long Lesions 85% of patients required ≤1 reintervention to maintain patency over 3 year period No amputations Stent grafts restenosed at edge; bare nitinol stents restenosed diffusely Continued understanding of the VIABAHN stent graft technical considerations To see how educated engineering can be successful stay for the VIPER trial update shortly after this talk 27
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.