1. SEXUAL HARASSMENT IN THE SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT
Adapted from: Port Arthur Independent School District

2. Introduction
Legal issues in dealing with sexual harassment by students
Individual duties to recognize and prevent harassment in the school environment.
8/12/2009

3. EMPLOYEE / STUDENT HARASSMENT/ABUSE
STUDENTS HAVE A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO BE FREE FROM SEXUAL HARASSMENT AND /OR SEXUAL ABUSE WHILE ATTENDING SCHOOL
8/12/2009

4. NO STRICT LIABILITY FOR DISTRICT
DISTRICT MAY BE HELD LIABLE FOR SUPERVISORY FAILURES RESULTING IN THE SEXUAL ABUSE OF STUDENTS IF POLICY-MAKING OFFICIALS ACTED WITH DELIBERATE INDIFFERENCE TO THE WELFARE OF SCHOOL CHILDREN
8/12/2009

5. WHAT IS DELIBERATE INDIFFERENCE
SCHOOL OFFICIAL HAD ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE OF ABUSE OR KNOWLEDGE OF FACTS PLAINLY POINTING TO ABUSE
OFFICIAL HAS AUTHORITY TO TAKE CORRECTIVE MEASURES
OFFICIAL FAILS TO TAKE ACTION THAT WAS OBVIOUSLY NECESSARY TO PREVENT OR STOP THE ABUSE; AND
FAILURE CAUSES CONSTITUTIONAL INJURY TO CHILD
8/12/2009

6. DISTRICT CAN BE HELD LIABLE FOR STUDENT TO STUDENT SEXUAL HARASSMENT OR ABUSE
HARASSMENT MUST OCCUR “UNDER OPERATIONS “ OF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AND MUST BE SEVERE, PERVASIVE AND OFFENSIVE
DISTRICT IS LIABLE IF ACTS WITH DELIBERATE INDIFFERENCE
8/12/2009

7. What is sexual harassment among students?
Student to student harassment includes unwelcome verbal, physical, or visual conduct of a sexual nature that is severe and pervasive.
8/12/2009

8. Harassment is unwelcomed conduct.
Girls can harass boys;
Harassment can happen between members of same sex;
Group of girls spreading sexual rumors about another girl
Conduct may be physical, verbal or nonverbal.
8/12/2009

9. What should I do if I see this type of student harassment?
Report it to campus administration;
Treat as a discipline issue, consistently;
If serious refer to campus principal immediately;
Principal should investigate , choose appropriate discipline technique; and
Report to law enforcement if crime has been committed on campus.
8/12/2009

10. Transgender Discrimination
8/12/2009

11. Logan v. Gary Comm. Sch.
Transgendered male, wore girls clothes and accessories to school. He asked to wear dress to prom. Principal said no to dress but suggested woman’s pants suit.
8/12/2009

12. Logan v. Gary Comm. Sch. (cont.)
History
December 2007 Complaint filed with the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, Hammond
September 2008 Court denies school district's motion to dismiss the case, allowing the lawsuit to go forward.
January 2011 Gary Community School Corporation settles this matter with Logan for an undisclosed amount on terms agreeable to all parties. The settlement includes revisions to the school district's dress code and non-discrimination policies such that both policies now include specific protections for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender students. The school district also agrees to conduct training for the administration and school board members on lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) issues and respectful treatment of LGBT people.
8/12/2009

13. Case Example
Federal appellate court upholds $200,000 jury verdict against Florida district for student-on-student sexual harassment
Mathis v. Wayne County Bd. of Educ., No (6th Cir. Aug. 23, 2012)
Abstract: A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (KY, MI, OH, TN) has upheld a jury verdict for $200,000 for the parents of two male middle school students who were sexually harassed by their basketball teammates in the school’s locker room, affirming the district court’s denial of the school board’s renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law.
Having reviewed the evidence, the panel rejected WBOE’s allegation and agreed with the district court that there was ample evidence before the jury from which reasonable jurors could have concluded that WBOE’s response constituted “deliberate indifference” under Title IX, and was insufficient to provide a safe environment in this student-on-student sexual harassment case.

14. District Title IX Coordinator
Reports of discrimination based on sex, including sexual harassment (involving students), may be directed to the Title IX coordinator. The District designates the following person to coordinate its efforts to comply with the Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, as amended: Dana Jackson, Director of Counseling Service, 2602 S. Belt Line Rd., Grand Prairie, TX 75052
District ADA / Section 504 Coordinator
Reports of discrimination based on disability may be directed to the ADA/Section 504 coordinator. The District designates the following person to coordinate its efforts to comply with Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, which incorporates and expands upon the requirements of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973: Sharon Boothe, Director of Special Program, 2602 S. Belt Line Rd., Grand Prairie, TX ,
The Deputy Superintendent shall serve as coordinator for purposes of District compliance with all other antidiscrimination laws.