1. Raising the Bar to Capture More Energy Savings
Marc Hoffman
Executive Director
Consortium for Energy Efficiency

3. Defining the highly efficient

4. Classic Demand Pull of Programs

5. Efficiency programs have invested millions to build the ENERGY STAR brand
Northeast
NYSERDA: $61.6 million
Massachusetts electric utilities: $ 3.7 million
Connecticut electric utilities: $ 1.1 million
Pacific Northwest
NW Alliance (excluding rebates): $ 3.8 million

6. Increasing Brand Awareness

7. Dividends of increased sales

8. New York’s Energy$mart Program ENERGY STAR 2003 Results

9. SUCCESS !

10. A victim of our own success?

11. How Do We Raise the Bar? ENERGY STAR & CEE Tier 2 CEE Tier 3

12. Raising the Bar Increases Savings
Former ENERGY STAR & CEE Tier 1
New CEE Tier 1
New CEE Tier 2
New CEE Tier 3
New ENERGY STAR
Tier 1

13. Washers: CEE Tiers Raise the Bar What will 2007 bring?
Level
[per 2002 spec]
2002
2004
2007
MEF WF
Tier 1
1.26
11.0
Tier 2
1.42
9.5
Tier 3
1.6
8.5
Tier 4A
1.8
7.5
1.8?
7.5?
Tier 4B
5.5
2.0
6.0
2.2
4.5
ENERGY STAR levels
Current Proposal MEF: 1.72 WF: 8.0

14. Raising Bar - Clothes Washers
Minimum
Standard
ENERGY STAR
Tier 1 &
Tier 2
Tier 3
Tier 4
0.5 1
1.5 2
2.5
2002
2004
2007
Modified Energy Factor

15. US Pacific Northwest Plan projects important role for clothes washers

16. Let’s keep raising the bar
Former ENERGY STAR & CEE Tier 1
New CEE Tier 1
New CEE Tier 2
New CEE Tier 3
New ENERGY STAR
Tier 1