Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byMagnus Hicks Modified over 6 years ago
1
Beyond-standard model physics searches in neutron and nuclear beta decay
Stefan BaeΞ²ler Inst. Nucl. Part. Phys.
2
Table of contents Beyond-standard model physics searches in neutron and nuclear beta decay: Is the Cabbibo Kobayashi Maskawa (CKM) matrix unitary? π β² π β² π β² = π π’π π π’π π π’π π ππ π ππ π ππ π π‘π π π‘π π π‘π β π π π Various unitarity tests possible; the most precise one is the one in the first row: π π’π π π’π π π’π 2 =1 V-A structure of weak interaction: Scalar- and tensor (S,T) interactions, which could be mediated by non-standard intermediate bosons, causes beta decays with one of the leptons having the opposite helicity. e- π π π π e- π π p n π π π π π π π π
3
Established determination of π½ ππ
0 + ,1 Use beta decay. Most precise in superallowed beta decays: (Partial) lifetime: π‘ 1/2 , π΅π
1 π πΈ π‘ = 2π β <πππ π» π> 2 Integration: 1 ππ‘ = πΊ πΉ 2 π π’π 2 πΎ <π π π> 2 Mass difference π 0 + ,1 Can be computed with precision only in some cases, In which the nuclear wave function overlap is well-known. For superallowed decays, π=1 and <π π π> 2 β2. β Good to a few percent, see left 3080 ππ‘ (π ) 3060 3040 10 20 30 40 π of daughter (from Hardy, Towner, PRC 91, (2015))
4
Established determination of π½ ππ
0 + ,1 Use beta decay. Most precise in superallowed beta decays: (Partial) lifetime: π‘ 1/2 , π΅π
1 π πΈ π‘ = 2π β <πππ π» π> 2 Integration: 1 ππ‘ = πΊ πΉ 2 π π’π 2 πΎ <π π π> 2 Mass difference π 0 + ,1 If there is an issue, it is believed to be the isospin-breaking correction that is nuclear structure dependent. Can be computed with precision only in some cases, In which the nuclear wave function overlap is well-known. Improvement: Apply corrections: β±π‘=ππ‘ 1+ πΏ π
β² 1+ πΏ ππ β πΏ πΆ 10 C 22 Mg 38 Ca 46 V 14 O 26 m Al 34 Cl 38 m K 50 Mn 62 Ga 74 Rb 34 3090 Ar 42 Sc 54 Co Energy-dependent rad. corr. Isospin-breaking correction (to matrix element) β±π‘ (π ) 3080 Nucleus-dependent rad. corr. This quantity contributes with largest uncertainty to π π’π 3070 Inner rad. corr. 3060 10 20 30 40 1 β±π‘ = 2πΊ πΉ 2 π π’π 2 πΎ 1+ Ξ π π
π of daughter (from J. Hardy, I. Towner, PRC 91, (2015))
5
Determination of π½ ππ Use Kl3 (Ke3 or KΞΌ3) semileptonic decays, e.g. πΎ πΏ β π + + π β + π π : Ξ πΎπ3 =(ππππ€π)β
π π’π π + πΎπ πΌ πΎ π 1+ πΏ πΈπ πΎπ + πΏ ππ 2 πΎπ Correction to phase space integral for charged Kaons Lepton formfactor phase space integral Radiative correction Current issue: π + πΎπ 0 needs to come from theory (Lattice-QCD). Present averages are: π π π + πΎπ 0 π π’π PDG16 average, based onβ¦ 2+1 0.9677(37) ππ₯π+π
πΆ 9 πΏππ‘ PRD87, (2013), JHEP 06, 164 (2015) 2+1+1 0.9704(24)(22) π‘β exp PRL112, (2014) Use ratio of leptonic decays: πΎ Β± β π Β± + π π / π π +πΎ to π Β± β π Β± + π π / π π +πΎ Ξ πΎπ2 Ξ ππ2 = π π’π π + πΎ π π’π π + π corrections Result is π π’π = ππ₯π π
πΆ πΏππ‘ Use hadronic tau decays: E.g., πβπΎ+ π π Ξβ| π π’π β 2 (with theory input) Result is π π’π =0.2202(15) NB: I havenβt talked about π π’π . π π’π is determined from decays of B/D mesons. Its value, π π’π = β
10 β3 is controversial, but small enough to be neglected here.
6
Test of CKM unitarity in the first row.
π π’π 2 =1β π π’π 2 β π π’π 2 CKM Unitarity test ( π π’π π π’π π π’π 2 =1 ) was perfect for a decade, after being off for even longer (Kaon experiment has moved). Now, updates of lattice calculations of the Kaon form factors put agreement in question.
7
Observables in Neutron Beta Decay
Observables in neutron beta decay, as a function of generally possible coupling constants (assuming only Lorentz-Invariance): Jackson et al., PR 106, 517 (1957), C. F. v.WeizsΓ€cker, Z. f. Phys. 102,572 (1936), M. Fierz, Z. f. Phys. 105, 553 (1937) e- π π p n π π Fierz interference term Beta-Asymmetry Neutrino-Electron-Correlation Neutron lifetime 8
8
Coupling Constants of the Weak Interaction
gA = GFΒ·VudΒ·Ξ» π π β1 β π π 2 +3 π π΄ 2 Coupling Constants in Neutron Decay π΄=π΄ π= π π΄ π π p = (udu) u e- WΒ± Ξ½e gV , gA gV = GFΒ·VudΒ·1 d n = (ddu) n β p + e- + Ξ½e Primordial Nucleosynthesis Solar cycle WΒ± e- Ξ½e n p n + Ξ½e β p + e- WΒ± e+ Ξ½e p + p 2H+ p + p β 2H+ + e+ + Ξ½e Start of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis, Primordial 4He abundance Start of Solar Cycle, determines amount of Solar Neutrinos 9
9
Neutron Lifetime Measurements
Beam: Decay rate: ππ ππ‘ = π π π Bottle: Neutron counts : π= π 0 π β π‘ ππππ with 1 ππππ = 1 π π π π€πππ UCN from source UCN Storage bottle(s) Shutter UCN detector Many new experiments: Somehow improved material bottles (e.g. Serebrov et al.) Magnetic bottles (e.g. UCNΟ, C.-Y. Liu et al., LANL; ΟSPECT, W. Heil, M. Beck et al., TRIGA Mainz; HOPE, O. Zimmer et al., ILL Grenoble, PENELOPE, S. Paul et al., TU MΓΌnchen ) Beam Lifetime (only at NIST)
10
The Beta Asymmetry π π e- p n π π PERKEO II
π π e- p n π π Electron Detector (Plastic Scintillator) Decay Electrons π=β1.2755(30) from M.P. Mendenhall et al., PRC 87, (2013) Polarized Neutrons Note: The PERKEO III collaboration plans to release their beta asymmetry result, with Ξπ΄ π΄ βΌ2β
10 β3 , corresponding to πΏπ π βΌ7β
10 β4 , any day now. Split Pair Magnet PERKEO II Magnetic Field π=β1.2748(+13/β14) from D. Mund et al., PRL 110, (2013)
11
Determination of coupling constants
Determination of ratio π= π π΄ π π from π΄= β2 Re π + π π or π= 1β π π 2 : Note: π should be fixed by standard model. However, precision of its calculation from first principles is insufficient: PNDMEβ16 LHPCβ12 LHPCβ10 RBC/UKQCDβ08 Lin/Orginosβ07 RQCDβ14 QCDSF/UKQCDβ13 ETMCβ15 CLSβ12 RBCβ08 1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 π π =2 π π =2+1 2+1+1 π f = π = π π΄ / π π ΞΞ»/Ξ» = 0.03% (Nab goal) PERKEO II (2013) UCNA (2013) UCNA (2010) ( ) Byrne (2002) Average: ( ) PERKEO II (2002) (21) Mostovoi (2001) Yerozolimskii (1997) PERKEO II (1997) ( ) Liaud (1997) PERKEO I (1986) Stratowa (1978) -1.28 -1.26 -1.24 π=ππ΄/ππ Most recent flavor Lattice-QCD result from PNDME: T. Bhattacharya et al., PRD 94, (2016)
12
Test of CKM unitarity in the first row.
For neutron data to be competitive with superallowed decays, one wants: Ξ π π π π βΌ0.3 s (Neutron lifetime experiment underway were discussed earlier) Ξπ π βΌ3β
10 β4
13
The PERC facility @ FRM II
Electron or proton detector Scintillator (e-), Silicon, β¦ PERC facility: Active decay volume in a 8 m long neutron guide e,p selector is magnetic Filter: phase space, systematics PERC can be coupled with various spectrometers PERC Magnet delivery planned for fall 2017 Goal for beta asymmetry π΄: Ξπ΄ π΄ β€5β
10 β4 β Ξπ π β€2β
10 β4 (Requires polarization control)! D. Dubbers et al., Nucl. Instr. Meth. A 596 (2008) 238 and arXiv: MAC-E filter (βaSPECTβ) RΓB spectrometer β¦ G. Konrad, SMI Cryostat π΅1 = 6 T π΅0 = 1.5 T User System
14
( π π is inferred from proton time-of-flight)
Idea of SNS n e- π π p Fundamental Neutron Physics Beamline Spallation Neutron Source (SNS) π ππ πΞβπ πΈ π 1+π π π πΈ π cos π ππ +π π π πΈ π 8 meters Kinematics in Infinite Nuclear Mass Approximation: Energy Conservation: πΈ π = πΈ π,πππ₯ β πΈ π Momentum Conservation: π π 2 = π π 2 + π π 2 +2 π π π π cos π ππ Goal: Determine π π 2 , πΈ π spectrum Ξπ π β€ 10 β3 β Ξπ π β€3β
10 β4 ( π π is inferred from proton time-of-flight) Cold Neutron Beam from left General Idea: J.D. Bowman, Journ. Res. NIST 110, 40 (2005) Original configuration: D. PoΔaniΔ et al., NIM A 611, 211 (2009) Asymmetric configuration: S. BaeΓler et al., J. Phys. G 41, (2014)
15
What if the test of CKM unitarity fails?
Like all precision measurements, a failure of the unitarity test would not point to a single cause: Various possibilities exist, among those are: Heavy quarks: Exotic muon decays: All direct determinations of π π’π use πΊ πΉ from muon lifetime. If the muon had additional decay modes (πβπ+π+β¦), πΊ πΉ (and π π’π ) would be determined wrong. E.g., π + β π + + π π +π π (wrong neutrinos) would be very relevant for neutrino factories. (Semi-)leptonic decays of nuclei through something other than exchange of π Β± bosons: πβ² π β² πβ² π·β² = π π’π π π’π π π’π π π’π· π ππ π ππ π ππ π ππ· π π‘π π π‘π π π‘π π π‘π· π πΈπ π πΈπ π πΈπ π πΈπ· β π π π π· π π’π· 2 =1β π π’π 2 β π π’π 2 β π π’π 2 W. Marciano, A. Sirlin, PRL 56, 22 (1986) P. Langacker, D. London, PRD 38, 886 (1988) K.S. Babu and S. Pakvasa, hep-ph/ Specific models: E.g. W. Marciano, A. Sirlin, PRD 35, 1672 (1987). R. Barbieri et al., PLB 156, 348 (1985) K. Hagiwara et al., PRL 75, 3605 (1995) A. Kurylov, M. Ramsey-Musolf, PRL 88, (2000) Energy scale of new physics: Ξβ₯11 TeV V. Cirigliano et al., NPB 830, 95 (2010)
16
Search for effective scalar (S) and tensor (T) interaction
π π π π e- π π p n π π π π π π π π Traditional low energy effective Lagrangian: β πππ =β πΆ π π πΎ π π π β
π πΎ π πβ πΆ π β² π πΎ π πΎ 5 π π β
π πΎ π π β πΆ π΄ π πΎ π πΎ 5 π π β
π πΎ π πΎ 5 πβ πΆ π΄ β² π πΎ π π π β
π πΎ π πΎ 5 π + πΆ π π π π β
π πβ πΆ π β² π πΎ 5 π π β
π π + πΆ π π π ππ π π β
π π ππ πβ πΆ π β² π π ππ πΎ 5 π π β
π π ππ π + πΆ π β
π πΎ 5 π π β
π πΎ 5 πβ πΆ π β² β
π π π β
π πΎ 5 π + h.c. In SM, πΆ π = πΆ π β² =1, πΆ π΄ = πΆ π΄ β² =π, all others zero. The Fierz term is unique in that it is the only term that is first-order sensitive to S,T Decay rate βπ πΈ 1+π π π πΈ
17
Search for effective scalar (S) and tensor (T) interaction
Low-Energy search for scalar current: Determine Fierz term π πΉ =β( πΆ π + πΆ π β² )/ πΆ π in superallowed Fermi decays: J. Hardy, I. Towner find πΆ π + πΆ π β² 2 πΆ π = (90% CL) (from J. Hardy, I. Towner, PRC 91, (2015)) Improvements possible with measurements using light nuclei Using this, and combination of β± π‘ β1 β 1+ π πΉ πΎ π π πΈ , π π β1 β(1+3 π 2 ) 1+ π π π π πΈ with π π β πΆ π + πΆ π β² πΆ π +3 πΆ π + πΆ π β² πΆ π΄ , and beta symmetry π΄= π΄ 0 / 1+ π π π π πΈ (for π): R.W. Pattie et al. get πΆ π + πΆ π β² 2 πΆ π΄ =β0.0007(27) (90% CL) from R.W. Pattie Jr., PRC 88, (2013) & PRC 92, (E) (2015) SB 2016 update: πΆ π + πΆ π β² 2 πΆ π΄ =β (90% CL) after G. Konrad, ArXiV:1007:3027 Resolution of neutron lifetime issue would give large improvement.
18
Effective field theory for beta decay at quark level
Effective low-energy Lagrangian: β πππ =β πΊ πΉ π π’π π πΏ β
π πΎ π 1β πΎ 5 π π β
π’ πΎ π 1β πΎ 5 π + π π
β
π πΎ π 1β πΎ 5 π π β
π’ πΎ π 1+ πΎ 5 π + π π β
π 1β πΎ 5 π π β
π’ π + π π β
π π ππ 1β πΎ 5 π π β
π’ π ππ 1β πΎ 5 π β π π β
π πΎ π 1β πΎ 5 π π β
π’ πΎ 5 π + terms with π that involve righthanded π π +h.c. Unobservable, suppressed with π/ π π Unobservable, all corr. coeff. only sensitive in second order Connection with traditional coupling constants from nuclear and neutron physics: πΆ π + πΆ π β² 2 = πΊ πΉ π π’π π π 1+ π πΏ + π π
πΆ π΄ + πΆ π΄ β² 2 =β πΊ πΉ π π’π π π΄ 1+ π πΏ β π π
πΆ π + πΆ π β² 2 = πΊ πΉ π π’π π π π π πΆ π + πΆ π β² 2 = πΊ πΉ π π’π π π π π π’ π= π π π π π’ π ππ π= π π π π ππ π β¦
19
Scalar(S) and tensor(T) interactions in beta decay
Other searches for Beyond Standard Model Physics: S,T interactions (fermions with βwrongβ helicity), e.g. through Wβ bosons; weak magnetism; second class currents; β¦ Low-energy experiments (mostly 0 + β 0 + , πβπππΎ); π π,π from quark model Low-energy experiments (add π < 10 β3 in n, 6He); π π,π from quark model Low-energy experiments, π π,π from Lattice QCD Low-energy experiments, π π,π from Lattice QCD LHC: 8 TeV, 20 fb-1 LHC: 14 TeV, 10,300 fb-1 LHC-Search for ππβπ+π+ other stuff and ππβπ+π+ other stuff
20
region (field maximum)
The determination of the Fierz Interference term π in neutron decay with Nab n e- π π p π ππ πΞβπ πΈ π 1+π π π πΈ π cos π ππ +π π π πΈ π decay volume 0 kV - 30 kV +1 kV magnetic filter region (field maximum) Neutron beam TOF region (low field) 4 m flight path skipped 1 m flight path skipped 0 V -30 kV 2 4 6 8 E e , k i n ( V ) Y l d a r b . u t s = +0.1 SM Electron spectrum: Goal: π π β€3β
10 β3
21
The determination of the Fierz Interference term π π in neutron decay with UCNB @ LANL
Key component Diagram courtesy of: Albert Young π΅ exπ = π ββ β π ++ π ββ + π ++ β π΅+ π π π π /πΈ 1+π π π /πΈ Goal: π π β€ 2..3 β
10 β3
22
6He little-b measurement at UW
Fierz interference term π from He-6 beta decay 6He little-b measurement at UW M. Fertl1, A. Garcia1, M. Guigue4, P. Kammel1, A. Leredde2, P. Mueller2, R.G.H. Robertson1, G. Rybka1, G. Savard2, D. Stancil3, M. Sternberg1, H.E. Swanson1, B.A. Vandeevender4, A. Young3 1University of Washington, 2Argonne National Lab, 3North Carolina State University, 4Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Use cyclotron radiation spectroscopy. Similar to Project 8 setup for tritium decay. M. Fertl et al., PRL 114, (2015) Goal: measure βlittle bβ to 10-3 or better in 6He Statistics not a problem. Determine eβs energy at birth
23
Thank you for your attention!
Summary and outlook Measurement of coupling constants in weak interaction allows test of the unitarity of the CKM matrix is most precisely done in the first row; some tension (again). Substantial improvement of precision not in sight. Measurement of Fierz term in beta decay allows the search for new physics that manifests itself at low energies as scalar and/or tensor interaction. This is competitive to searches at LHC, and experimental improvements are likely in the near future. The latter needs form factors ( π π and π π ) to connect nuclear and quark-level description. Recent work in theory (Lattice QCD) determined them at the 10% level. Experimental verification desirable. Thank you for your attention! GrΓΆΓer
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.