1. 1 Nicholas Souchlas, PBL (11/15/2011)
IDS120h GEOMETRY WITH SHIELDING VESSELS
SHIELDING MATERIAL: 60% W + 40% He vs. 60% WC + 40% H2O
USING Be FOR PART OF BP1 AND BP2
SIMULATIONS FOR 60% W + 40% He SHIELDING
WITH SUPPORTING RIBS FOR VESSELS
Nicholas Souchlas, PBL (11/15/2011) 1

2. >4 MW proton beam, Np = 100,000/500,000
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N = 500,000 events simulation for 60% W + 40% He and
60% W + 40% H2O shielding.
# BP1 and BP2 with Be sections (N=100,000).
# N = 100,000 simulation with supporting ribs for vessels.
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING: 60% W + 40% He , 60% WC + 40% H2O
(WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np = 100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E = 8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx = σy = 0.12 cm. 2
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=100,000 AND N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h with shielding vessels.
# Different cases of shielding material.
# N=500,000 events simulation for 60%W+40%He AND
60%W+40%H2 60%W+40%H2 SHIELDING SHIELDING
# Energy counting for N=500,000 events simulation for 80%W+20%He SHIELDING
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING:60%W+40%He , 80%W+20%He, 88%W+12%He ( WITH W VESSELS)
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000/500,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h: introducing shielding vessels (STST OR W)
Different cases of shielding material.
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING: 60%WC+40%H2O/60%WC+40%H2O/
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h: introducing shielding vessels (STST OR W)
Different cases of shielding material.
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING: 60%WC+40%H2O/60%WC+40%H2O/
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.
IDS120h: introducing shielding vessels (STST OR W)
Different cases of shielding material.
>mars1510/MCNP
>10-11 MeV NEUTRON ENERGY CUTOFF
>SHIELDING: 60%WC+40%H2O/60%WC+40%H2O/
>4 MW proton beam, Np=100,000
>PROTONS ENERGY E=8 GeV.
>GAUSSIAN PROFILE: σx=σy=0.12 cm.

3. IDS120h:SHIELDING VESSELS ( USING W ).
Bob Weggel(7/26/11)
Bob Weggel(7/26/11)
SC1
BEAM PIPE
BP1: 1 cm STST → 1 cm W
BP2/BP3: 1 cm STST → 2 cm STST
TUBE 1 (= BP1) AND TUBE 2 WITH cm AND 2 cm THIKNESS IN THE SH1 VESSEL ARE MADE OF W TO FURTHER REDUCE THE POWER DEPOSITED IN THE RESISTIVE COILS.
5 cm DISTANCE BETWEEN VESSELS AND SC COILS FOR CRYOGENIC COOLING COMPONENTS
0.5 cm SPACE BETWEEN TUBE 2 OF SH1 AND RS1,
AND 1.0 cm BETWEEN TUBE 1 OF SH4 AND RS5
SC2
SC3
SC4
SC5
6 cm
4 cm
SC6
5 cm
4 cm
SC7
5 cm
15 cm
SH4
4 cm
5 cm
4 cm
10 cm
2 cm
3 cm
3 cm
SH3
RS:1-5
10 cm
10 cm
2 cm
SH2
2 cm
5 cm
BP3
10 cm
BP2
SH1
5 cm
2 cm
BP1
2 cm
1 cm W 3

4. IDS120h: SHIELDING VESSELS DETAIL PLOTS.
SHVS4
SH7
SH4
SHVS3
SH8
SH9
RS#3+4
RS#3
SH2
SH3
RS#1+2
SH1
SHVS2
BP3
BP2
SHVS1
BP1 4

5. IDS120h WITH SHIELDING VESSELS: N = 500,000 EVENT SIMULATIONS
60% W + 40% He vs. 60% WC + 40% H2O 5

6. POWER DEPOSITED IN SC SOLENOIDS (SC#).
POWER DEPOSITED IN THE SC COILS
SC1: kW --> kW SC1-6: kW --> kW SC#1-19: kW --> kW. 6
CODES FOR THE CASES
POWER DEPOSITED IN SC SOLENOIDS (SC#).
SC1:0.516 kW -->0.06 kW SC1-6:0.684 kW-->0.074 kW SC#1-19:0.825 kW-->0.184 kW.

7. 7 MORE POWER IN SH#1-4 SH#1: 867.50 kW --> 893.50 kW (+26.00 kW)
POWER DEPOSITED IN THE SHIELDING (SH#), SHIELDING VESSELS (SHVS#), AND SH1 W TUBE 2 (SH1T2)
MORE POWER IN SH#1-4
SH#1: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH#2: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
TWO SH1 STST FLANGES: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH1 2 cm W TUBE#2: kW --> kW ( kW) 7
LESS POWER IN SH1, SH2 !!!!
SH1: kW--> kW(-26.0 kW)
SH2: kW--> kW(-46.0 kW)
SH#1-4: kW--> kW( kW)
TWO SH1 STST FLANGES:59.15 kW-->85.05 kW (+25.9 kW)
SH1 2 cm W TUBE#2:45.38 kW-->32.05 kW( kW)
MORE POWER IN SH#1-4
SH#1: kW--> kW(+26.0 kW)
SH#2: kW--> kW
SH#1-4: kW--> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN SH#1-4
SH#1: kW--> kW(+26.0 kW)
SH#2: kW--> kW
SH#1-4: kW--> kW ( kW)

8. 8 POWER DEPOSITED IN RESISTIVE MAGNETS (RS#) AND BEAM PIPE (BP#).
MORE POWER IN RS#1-5
RS#1+2: kW --> kW ( kW)
RS#1-5: kW --> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN BP#1,BP#2
BP#1: kW --> kW ( kW)
BP#2: kW --> kW (+7.05 kW)
BP#1-3: kW --> kW ( kW) 8

9. 9 TOTAL POWER DEPOSITED IN DIFFERENT AREAS AND SC#1-11 PEAK VALUES.
MORE POWER IN SC#1-19: kW --> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN SH#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN RS#1-5: kW --> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN BP#1-3: kW- -> kW ( kW)
TOTAL POWER IS TRG STATION: kW --> kW ( kW)
SC#1 PEAK: > mW/g ~ NO CHANGE
SC#1-19 PEAK: ~ SMALL DIFFERENCE 9

10. IDS120h WITH SHIELDING VESSELS: N = 100,000 EVENT SIMULATIONS
SH = 88% W + 18% He, BP1: LAST 50 cm Be, BP2: FIRST 10 cm Be 10

11. BP1: 60 cm W
BP1: 50 cm Be
BP2: 10 cm Be
BP2: STST 11

12. 12 POWER DEPOSITED IN THE SC COILS.
SC1: kW --> kW SC1-6: kW  kW SC#1-19:0.228 kW --> kW.
SLIGHT INCREASE IN THE TDP. 12

13. POWER DEPOSITED IN THE SHIELDING (SH#), SHIELDING VESSELS (SHVS#), AND SH1 W TUBE 2 (SH1T2)
MORE POWER IN SH#1,SH#2
SH#1: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH#2: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN SHVS#1 SHVS#2
SHVS#1: kW- -> kW (+3.6 kW)
SHVS#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH1 2 cm W TUBE#2: kW --> kW ( kW) 13

14. 14 POWER DEPOSITED IN RESISTIVE MAGNETS (RS#) AND BEAM PIPE (BP#).
MORE POWER IN RS#1-5
RS#1+2: kW --> kW ( kW)
RS#1-5: kW --> kW ( kW)
MUCH LESS POWER IN BP#1
BP#1: kW --> kW ( kW)
BP#2: kW --> kW ( kW)
BP#1-3: kW--> kW ( kW) 14
MUCH POWER IN BP#1
BP#1: kW-->79.00 kW ( kW)
BP#2: kW--> kW
BP#1-3: kW--> kW (-64 kW)
MUCH POWER IN BP#1
BP#1: kW-->79.00 kW (-64 kW)
BP#2: kW--> kW (-64 kW)
BP#1-3: kW--> kW

15. 15 TOTAL POWER DEPOSITED IN DIFFERENT AREAS AND SC#1-11 PEAK VALUES.
~SAME POWER IN SC#1-19: kW --> kW
MORE POWER IN SH#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
MORE POWER IN RS#1-5: kW --> kW ( kW)
MUCH LESS POWER IN BP#1-3: kW --> kW ( kW)
TOTAL POWER IS TRG STATION : kW --> kW ( kW)
SC#1 PEAK : > mW/g ~ NO CHANGE
SC#1-19 PEAK: ~ SMALL DIFFERENCE
SC# WTH !!?? 15

16. ENERGY FLOW FOR IDS120h FOR 88% W + 12%He, WITH BP1, BP2 PARTIAL Be, FROM 100,000 EVENTS
/ kW At R= 2 m
/ kW
at z = -2.5 m
/ kW
at z = 19 m
/ kW At R = 2 m
TOTAL POWER GOING THROUGH THE SURFACES: / kW
TOTAL POWER IN TARGET STATION: / kW
POWER DIFFERENCE FROM 4 MW ~ / kW
SH1,SH2 TDP PEAK SLIGTLY HIGHER ~ 11 W/g
BP1, BP2 TDP PEAKS ABOUT THE SAME, BINS SIZE PROBLEMS
FURTHER INVESTIGATION REQUIRED. 16

17. IDS120h WITH SHIELDING VESSELS: N = 100,000 EVENT SIMULATION
SH = 60% W + 40% He, INTRODUCING SH VESSELS STST SUPPORT RIBS 17

18. SH2--> 2 cm THICK STSTS SLAB ALONG y-z PLANE.
SH3--> 2 cm THICK STST DISCS EVERY 100 cm.
SH4--> 2 cm THICK STST DISCS EVERY 10 cm. 18

19. SH2--> 2 cm THICK STST SLAB ALONG y-z PLANE.
SH3--> 2 cm THICK STST DISCS EVERY 100 cm.
SH4--> 2 cm THICK STST DISCS EVERY 10 cm.
SH2, SH3, SH4 RIBS DETAILS
SH2 RIB DETAILS
(Longitudinal)
SH3 RIB DETAILS
(Transverse)
SH4 RIB DETAILS
(Transverse) 19

20. 20 POWER DEPOSITED IN THE SC COILS.
SC1: kW --> kW SC1-6: kW--> kW SC#1-19: kW --> kW.
SLIGHT INCREASE IN THE TDP. 20

21. 21 LESS POWER IN SH#1, SH#2, SH#4
POWER DEPOSITED IN THE SHIELDING (SH#), SHIELDING VESSELS (SHVS#), AND SH1 W TUBE 2 (SH1T2)
LESS POWER IN SH#1, SH#2, SH#4
SH#1: kW --> kW ( kW) !!??
SH#2: kW --> kW (-6.50 kW)
SH#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
MUCH MORE POWER IN SHVS#1
SHVS#1: kW --> kW ( kW) !!??
SHVS#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
SH1 2 cm W TUBE#2 ~THE SAME 21
LESS POWER IN SH#1,SH#2, SH4
SH#1: kW--> kW ( kW)
SH#2: kW--> kW ( kW)
SH#1-4: kW--> kW ( kW)
MUCH MORE POWER IN SHVS#1
SHVS#1:58.40 kW-->80.55 kW ( kW)
SHVS#1-4: kW--> kW ( kW)
SH1 2 cm W TUBE#2~

22. 22 POWER DEPOSITED IN RESISTIVE MAGNETS (RS#) AND BEAM PIPE (BP#).
~ SAME POWER IN RS#1-5
~ SAME POWER IN BP#1-3 22

23. 23 TOTAL POWER DEPOSITED IN DIFFERENT AREAS AND SC#1-11 PEAK VALUES.
~SAME POWER IN SC#1-19: kW --> kW
SLIGHTLY LESS POWER IN SH#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
~SAME POWER IN RS#1-5: kW --> kW
~SAME POWER IN BP#1-3: kW --> kW
SLIGHTLY MORE POWER IN SHVS#1-4: kW --> kW ( kW)
~SAME TOTAL POWER IS TRG STATION: kW --> kW
SC#1 PEAK : > mW/g ~ NO CHANGE
SC#1-19 PEAK: ~ SMALL DIFFERENCES
SC# WTH !!?? 23

24. ENERGY FLOW FOR IDS120h FOR 60% W + 40% He SHIELDING FROM 100,000 EVENTS: WOR / WR
/ kW At R = 2 m
/ kW
at z = -2.5 m
/ kW
at z = 19 m
/ kW At R = 2 m
TOTAL POWER GOING THROUGH THE SURFACES: / kW
TOTAL POWER IN TARGET STATION: / kW
POWER GAP: / kW 24