Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

2015 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "2015 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting"— Presentation transcript:

1 2015 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting
Ameren Transmission Company of Illinois July 19, 2016

2 Agenda Main Purpose is to review ATXI 2015 Transmission Rate True-Up Calculations Protocol Timeline 2015 True Up Calculation Total Revenue Requirement Comparison – Projected vs Actual Attachment O/Schedule 9 True-up Attachment MM Revenue Requirement and True-up 2015 MVP Spend ROE Complaint Cases An additional meeting will held to review the 2017 Projected Transmission Rate calculations. Tentatively set for October 3rd.

3 (Forward-Looking Protocols)
Protocol timeline Date Schedule (Forward-Looking Protocols) June 1 Posting of annual true-up for prior year September 1 Deadline for annual true-up meeting Posting of net projected revenue requirement for following year October 15 Deadline for annual projected rate meeting November 1 Deadline for joint meeting on regional cost-shared projects March 15 Transmission Owners submit informational filing to the Commission

4 ATXI Revenue Requirement Comparison
Projected 2015 vs Actual 2015

5 Atxi 2015 Rate Base Page.Line 2015 Projection 2015 Actual Change
Percent 2.6 Total Gross Plant 80,778,000 87,757,036 6,979,036 9% 2.12 Total Accum Depreciation 4,717,000 5,373,349 656,349 14% 2.18 TOTAL NET PLANT 76,061,000 82,383,687 6,322,687 8% 2.18a 100% CWIP RECOVERY 471,564,000 462,818,690 -8,745,310 -2% ADJUSTMENTS TO RATE BASE 2.20 Account No. 282 -12,824,000 -24,006,415 -11,182,415 87% 2.21 Account No. 283 -2,720,000 -3,545,081 -825,081 30% 2.22 Account No. 190 2,470,000 3,990,057 1,520,057 62% 2.25 Land Held for Future Use N/A 2.26 CWC 866,625 1,386,288 519,663 60% 2.27 Materials & Supplies 2.28 Prepayments 190,000 375,152 185,152 97% TOTAL ADJUSTMENTS -12,017,375 -21,799,998 -9,782,623 81% 2.30 TOTAL RATE BASE 535,607,625 523,402,380 -12,205,245

6 ATXI 2015 Expenses Page.Line 2015 Projection 2015 Actual Change
Percent O&M 3.1 Transmission 367,000 1,700,440 1,333,440 363% 3.1a Less LSE Expenses N/A 3.2 Less Account 565 3.3 A&G 6,566,000 9,389,861 2,823,861 43% 3.4 Less FERC Annual Fees 3.5 Less EPRI, ect. 50,000 185,211 135,211 270% 3.5a Plus Trans. Reg. Comm. Exp 3.8 TOTAL O&M 6,933,000 11,090,301 4,157,301 60% 3.12 TOTAL DEPRECIATION 1,132,000 1,921,460 789,460 70% TAXES 3.13 Payroll 3.16 Property 82,401 3.18 Other 155,000 204,132 49,132 32% 3.27 Income Taxes 24,806,313 24,229,707 -576,605 -2% TOTAL TAXES 24,961,313 24,516,240 -445,072 TOTAL EXPENSES 33,026,313 37,528,002 4,501,689 14%

7 Atxi 2015 capital structure
Actual Capital Structure Projection Page.Line $ % Cost Weighted 4.27 Long Term Debt 192,308,000 44% 4.2700% 1.8700% 4.28 Preferred Stock 0% 0.0000% 4.29 Common Stock 247,121,000 56% % 6.9600% 4.3 Total 439,429,000 100% 8.8300% Actual Capital Structure Actual 182,307,692 3.1010% 1.3639% 232,202,030 6.9351% 414,509,722 8.2989% Change in Actual Return % Hypothetical Capital Structure Actual Actual Capital Structure Return Hypothetical Capital Structure Return 8.2972% Difference applied to Attachment MM %

8 ATXI 2015 total revenue requirement
Page.Line 2015 Projection 2015 Actual Change Percent 2.30 TOTAL RATE BASE 535,607,625 523,402,380 -12,205,245 -2% 4.30 Rate of Return on ACS 8.83% 8.30% -0.53% -6% 3.28 Return from ACS 47,306,341 43,436,896 -3,869,445 -8% 2.30a 100% CWIP RECOVERY 471,564,000 462,818,690 -8,745,310 4.30e Incremental Rate of Return on HCS -0.02% 0.00% 0.02% -91% 3.28a Incremental Return from HCS -90,541 -7,935 82,606 Total Return 47,215,800 43,428,961 -3,786,839 Total Expenses 33,026,313 37,528,002 4,501,689 14% 3.29 TOTAL GROSS REV. REQ. 80,242,113 80,956,963 714,850 1% 3.30 Less ATT. GG Adjustment N/A 3.30a Less ATT. MM Adjustment 71,386,314 71,231,892 -154,422 0% 3.31 GROSS REV. REQ. UNDER ATT. O 8,855,799 9,725,070 869,272 10%

9 Atxi 2015 Net Revenue Requirement For Schedule 9
Page.Line 2015 Projection 2015 Actual Change Percent 1.1 Gross Revenue Requirement 8,855,799 9,725,070 869,272 10% 1.6 Total Revenue Credits 423,000 1,100,154 677,154 160% 1.6a Historic Year Actual ATRR* 8,860,739 0% 1.6b Projected ATRR from Prior Year* 7,406,002 1.6c Prior Year ATRR True-Up* 1,454,736 1.6d Prior Year Divisor True-Up* (45,647) 1.6e Interest on Prior Year True-Up* 9,706 1.7 NET REVENUE REQUIREMENT 9,851,594 10,043,711 192,118 2% * 2013 True-up included in 2015 Projection and Actual.

10 ATXI 2015 Attachment O True Up for Schedule 9
Ameren Transmission Company of Illinois 2015 Attachment O Revenue Requirement True-Up (WP 4) For the Year Ended December 31, 2015 Attachment O Net Actual Revenue Requirement (Attachment O, Pg 1, Line 7) 10,043,711 Net Projected Revenue Requirement (2015 Projected Attachment O, Pg 1, Line 7) 9,851,594 Under/(Over) Recovery of Net Revenue Requirement $ ,117 Historic Year Actual Divisor for Pricing Zone (AIC Attachment O, Pg 1, Line 15) 6,922,407 Projected Year Divisor for Pricing Zone (AIC 2015 Projected Attachment O, Pg 1, Line 15) 7,095,335 Difference between Historic & Projected Yr Divisor 172,928 Prior Year Projected Annual Cost ($ per kw per yr) 1.3885 Prior Year Under/(Over) Divisor True-up $ ,110 Total Under/(Over) Recovery $ ,227 Monthly Interest Rate (to be updated through July, 2016) 0.0311% Interest For 24 Months $ ,226 Total Under/(Over) Recovery Including Interest $ ,454 (Amount to be included in Projected 2017 Attachment O)

11 ATXI Attachment MM Calculation - Page 1
Attachment O Line Page, Line, Col. Transmission Allocator No. 1 Gross Transmission Plant - Total Attach O, p 2, line a col 5 (Note A) 547,049,166 1a Transmission Accumulated Depreciation Attach O, p 2, line 8 col 5 4,693,803 2 Net Transmission Plant - Total Line 1 minus Line 1a (Note B) 542,355,363 O&M TRANSMISSION EXPENSE 3 Total O&M Allocated to Transmission Attach O, p 3, line 8 col 5 11,090,301 3a Transmission O&M Attach O, p 3, line 1 col 5 1,700,440 3b Less: LSE Expenses included in above, if any Attach O, p 3, line 1a col 5, if any - 3c Less: Account 565 included in above, if any Attach O, p 3, line 2 col 5, if any 3d Adjusted Transmission O&M Line 3a minus Line 3b minus Line 3c 4 Annual Allocation Factor for Transmission O&M (Line 3d divided by line 1a, col 3) 36.23% OTHER O&M EXPENSE 4a Other O&M Allocated to Transmission Line 3 minus Line 3d 9,389,861 4b Annual Allocation Factor for Other O&M Line 4a divided by Line 1, col 3 1.72% GENERAL AND COMMON (G&C) DEPRECIATION EXPENSE 5 Total G&C Depreciation Expense Attach O, p 3, lines 10 & 11, col 5 (Note H) 722,457 6 Annual Allocation Factor for G&C Depreciation Expense (line 5 divided by line 1 col 3) 0.13% TAXES OTHER THAN INCOME TAXES 7 Total Other Taxes Attach O, p 3, line 20 col 5 286,533 8 Annual Allocation Factor for Other Taxes (line 7 divided by line 1 col 3) 0.05% 9 Annual Allocation Factor for Other Expense Sum of line 4b, 6, and 8 1.90% INCOME TAXES 10 Total Income Taxes Attach O, p 3, line 27 col 5 24,229,707 11 Annual Allocation Factor for Income Taxes (line 10 divided by line 2 col 3) 4.47% RETURN 12 Return on Rate Base (Note I) Attach O, p 3, line 28 col 5 43,436,896 13 Annual Allocation Factor for Return on Rate Base (line 12 divided by line 2 col 3) 8.01% 14 Annual Allocation Factor for Return Sum of line 11 and 13 12.48% HYPOTHETICAL CAPITAL STRUCTURE (HCS) RETURN 15 Annual Allocation Factor HCS Return (Note J) Attach O, p 4, line 30e 0.00%

12 ATXI Attachment MM Calculation - Page 2
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) Line No. Project Name MTEP Project Number Project Gross Plant Project Accumulated Depreciation Transmission O&M Annual Allocation Factor Annual Allocation for Transmission O&M Expense Other Expense Annual Allocation Factor Annual Allocation for Other Expense Annual Expense Charge (Note C) Page 1 line 4 (Col 4 * Col 5) Page 1 line 9 (Col 3 * Col 7) (Col 6 + Col 8) Multi-Value Projects (MVP) 1a Pana-Sugar Creek - CWIP 2237 $ ,099,171 $ 36.23% $ 1.90% $ ,712,694 $ ,712,694 1b Pana-Sugar Creek - Plant in Service - No HCS $ ,478,744 $ ,645 $ ,392 $ ,163 $ ,556 1c Pana-Sugar Creek - Land - No HCS $ ,246,528 $ ,722 $ ,722 1d Sidney-Rising - CWIP 2239 $ ,931,651 $ ,132 $ ,132 1e Sidney-Rising - Plant in Service - No HCS $ ,106,101 $ ,305 $ ,197 $ ,035 $ ,232 1f Sidney-Rising - Land - No HCS $ ,285,913 $ ,444 $ ,444 1g Adair-Ottumwa - CWIP 2248 $ ,052,148 $ ,000 $ ,000 1h Adair-Ottumwa - Plant in Service - No HCS $ 1i Adair-Ottumwa - Land - No HCS $ ,929 $ ,469 $ ,469 1j Palmyra-Pawnee - CWIP 3017 $ ,736,281 $ ,899,306 $ ,899,306 1k Palmyra-Pawnee - Plant in Service - No HCS 1l Palmyra-Pawnee - Land - No HCS $ ,170,113 $ ,306 $ ,306 1m Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - CWIP 3022 $ ,606,966 $ ,628 $ ,628 1n Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - Plant in Service - No HCS 1o Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - Land - No HCS $ ,394,442 $ ,525 $ ,525 1p Pawnee-Pana - CWIP 3169 $ ,771,366 $ ,942 $ ,942 1q Pawnee-Pana - Plant in Service - No HCS 1r Pawnee-Pana - Land - No HCS $ ,429,159 $ ,185 $ ,185 1s Adair-Palmyra - CWIP 3170 $ ,621,106 $ ,013 $ ,013 1t Adair-Palmyra - Plant in Service - No HCS 1u Adair-Palmyra - Land - No HCS $ ,450 $ ,626 $ ,626

13 ATXI Attachment MM Calculation - Page 2 (continued)
(1) (2) (10) (11) (11a) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) Line No. Project Name MTEP Project Number Project Net Plant Annual Allocation Factor for Return Annual Allocation Factor for HCS Return Annual Return Charge Project Depreciation Expense Annual Revenue Requirement True-Up Adjustment MVP Annual Adjusted Revenue Requirement (Col 3 - Col 4) (Page 1 line 14) (Page 1 line 15) (Note J) (Col 10 * (Col a)) (Note E) (Sum Col. 9, 12 & 13) (Note F) Sum Col. 14 & 15 (Note G) Multi-Value Projects (MVP) 1a Pana-Sugar Creek - CWIP 2237 $ ,099,171 12.48% 0.00% $ ,239,618 $ $ ,952,312 $ (492,359) $ ,459,953 1b Pana-Sugar Creek - Plant in Service - No HCS $ ,461,099 $ ,879 $ ,524 $ ,206,959 $ ,206,959 1c Pana-Sugar Creek - Land - No HCS $ ,246,528 $ ,815 $ ,537 $ ,302 $ ,839 1d Sidney-Rising - CWIP 2239 $ ,931,651 $ ,979,339 $ ,890,471 $ (134,662) $ ,755,808 1e Sidney-Rising - Plant in Service - No HCS $ ,102,796 $ ,354 $ ,259 $ ,845 $ ,845 1f Sidney-Rising - Land - No HCS $ ,285,913 $ ,436 $ ,880 $ ,241 $ ,121 1g Adair-Ottumwa - CWIP 2248 $ ,052,148 $ ,253 $ ,253 $ $ ,253 1h Adair-Ottumwa - Plant in Service - No HCS $ $ $ 1i Adair-Ottumwa - Land - No HCS $ ,929 $ ,837 $ ,305 $ ,305 1j Palmyra-Pawnee - CWIP 3017 $ ,736,281 $ ,151,876 $ ,051,182 $ (404,306) $ ,646,876 1k Palmyra-Pawnee - Plant in Service - No HCS 1l Palmyra-Pawnee - Land - No HCS $ ,170,113 $ ,019,339 $ ,174,644 $ ,216,042 $ ,390,687 1m Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - CWIP 3022 $ ,606,966 $ ,323,189 $ ,524,817 $ $ ,525,374 1n Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - Plant in Service - No HCS 1o Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - Land - No HCS $ ,394,442 $ ,505 $ ,030 $ ,343 $ ,373 1p Pawnee-Pana - CWIP 3169 $ ,771,366 $ ,963,388 $ ,567,330 $ ,313 $ ,626,643 1q Pawnee-Pana - Plant in Service - No HCS 1r Pawnee-Pana - Land - No HCS $ ,429,159 $ ,837 $ ,022 $ ,587 $ ,608 1s Adair-Palmyra - CWIP 3170 $ ,621,106 $ ,946,666 $ ,395,680 $ ,601 $ ,683,281 1t Adair-Palmyra - Plant in Service - No HCS 1u Adair-Palmyra - Land - No HCS $ ,450 $ ,000 $ ,626 $ ,215 $ ,841 2 MVP Total Annual Revenue Requirements $71,231,892 $1,516,874 $72,748,766 3 Rev. Req. Adj For Attachment O

14 Atxi 2015 attachment MM True-up For Schedule 26-A
(b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) (j) (k) Actual Projected Attachment MM True-Up Applicable MTEP Annual Revenues Adjustment Interest Total Line Project Revenue Allocated Principal Rate on No. Name Number Requirement 1 to Projects 1 Under/(Over) [Col. (d), line 1 x (Col. (e), line 2x / Col. (h) x Col. (i) p 2 of 2, Col. 142 Col. (e), line 3)]2 Col. (g) - Col. (f) Line 5 x 24 months 2 Col. (h) + Col. (j) 1 Actual Attachment MM revenues for True-Up Year 1 66,274,859 2a Pana-Sugar Creek - CWIP 2237 15,120,908 14,038,210 12,952,312 (1,085,898) 0.03% (8,105) (1,094,003) 2b Pana-Sugar Creek - Plant in Service - No HCS 778,416 722,679 1,206,959 484,280 3,615 487,895 2c Pana-Sugar Creek - Land - No HCS 405,274 376,255 610,537 234,282 1,749 236,031 2d Sidney-Rising - CWIP 2239 7,297,352 6,774,842 6,890,471 115,629 863 116,492 2e Sidney-Rising - Plant in Service - No HCS - 335,845 2,507 338,352 2f Sidney-Rising - Land - No HCS 183,729 170,574 184,880 14,306 107 14,413 2g Adair-Ottumwa - CWIP 2248 216,008 200,541 151,253 (49,288) (368) (49,656) 2h Adair-Ottumwa - Plant in Service - No HCS 2i Adair-Ottumwa - Land - No HCS 94,653 87,876 94,305 6,429 48 6,477 2j Palmyra-Pawnee - CWIP 3017 35,301,697 32,773,999 37,051,182 4,277,183 31,925 4,309,108 2k Palmyra-Pawnee - Plant in Service - No HCS 2l Palmyra-Pawnee - Land - No HCS 1,176,298 1,092,072 1,174,644 82,572 616 83,188 2m Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - CWIP 3022 2,061,101 1,913,521 1,524,817 (388,704) (2,901) (391,605) 2n Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - Plant in Service - No HCS 2o Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove - Land - No HCS 488,283 453,321 488,030 34,709 259 34,968 2p Pawnee-Pana - CWIP 3169 4,009,140 3,722,075 4,567,330 845,255 6,309 851,564 2q Pawnee-Pana - Plant in Service - No HCS 2r Pawnee-Pana - Land - No HCS 404,762 375,780 493,022 117,242 875 118,117 2s Adair-Palmyra - CWIP 3170 3,738,008 3,470,356 3,395,680 (74,676) (557) (75,233) 2t Adair-Palmyra - Plant in Service - No HCS 2u Adair-Palmyra - Land - No HCS 110,686 102,761 110,626 7,865 59 7,924 3 Subtotal $ ,386,315 $ ,274,862 $ ,231,893 4 Under/(Over) Recovery $ ,957,031 $ ,001 $ ,994,032 5 Applicable Interest rate per month (expressed to four decimal places) interest rate to be updated through July 31, 2016 0.0311% Amount excludes True-Up Adjustment, as reported in True-Up Year projected Attachment MM, page 2, column 15. 2 Rounded to whole dollars.

15 Atxi 2015 MVP SPEND Ameren MVPs Ameren Name 2015 CAPEX MTEP #s
MTEP Description Illinois Rivers $354 million 2237 Pana - Mt. Zion - Kansas - Sugar Creek 345 kV line 2239 Sidney to Rising 345 kV line 3017 Palmyra-Quincy-Meredosia - Ipava & Meredosia-Pawnee 345 kV Line 3169 Pawnee to Pana kV Line 3170 New Palmyra Substation (Maywood) Spoon River $23 million 3022 Fargo-Galesburg-Oak Grove 345 kV Line Mark Twain $2 million 2248 Adair - Ottumwa 345 Adair-Palmyra 345 kV Line

16 ROE complaints Current ROE is 12.38% MISO ROE Complaints
1st Complaint (EL14-12) Covers November 12, 2013 through Feb 11, 2015 Received initial decision from administrative law judge on December 22, 2015 with a recommended Base ROE at 10.32% Expect final FERC order in October 2016 2nd Complaint (EL15-45) Covers February 12, 2015 through May 11, 2016 Received initial decision on June 30, 2016 with a recommended Base ROE at 9.70% Expect final FERC order in first half of 2017

17 FERC approved a 50 basis point adder for participation in an RTO
ROE complaints FERC approved a 50 basis point adder for participation in an RTO Effective January 6, 2015, but will not be used until after final orders in the ROE complaints are issued Refunds will be required, but format is not yet determined Will impact Schedules 7,8, 9, 26, 37, 38, 26A Amounts could be either be rolled into the future revenue requirements and reduce future rates actual refunds to all customers requiring MISO to calculate adjustments for all months beginning with November 13

18 QUESTIONS?

19 Appendix Supplemental Background Information
(Not covered during presentation)

20 Appendix - MISO ATTACHMENTs O & MM
Calculate rates for Schedules 9, 26 & 26-A Attachment GG - Schedule 26 Attachment MM - Schedule 26-A Attachment O - net revenue requirement billed under Schedule 9 Schedules 26 and 26-A are billed by MISO Schedule 9 is billed by Ameren

21 Appendix - MISO ATTACHMENT MM
Cost recovery for Multi-Value Projects (MVPs) Criteria for being considered Developed through planning process and support energy policy Multiple types of economic value across multiple pricing zones with benefit to costs > 1 Address at least one: Projected NERC violation Economic-based issue Cost shared across MISO based on load AMIL Zone is approximately 10% Ameren MVPs will primarily be built by ATXI AIC will be responsible for modifications needed to its existing facilities

22 Appendix - MISO ATTACHMENT O & MM
All transmission costs included in Attachment O calculation Schedule 9 based on net revenue requirement – reductions for: Costs recovered in Schedules 26 & 26-A Since ATXI has no Attachment GG projects, there is no deduction for 26 Revenue Credits Point-to-Point revenue in Schedules 7 & 8 Rental revenue Revenue from generator interconnections

23 Appendix - Miso transmission expansion plan (MTEP)
Developed on an annual basis building upon previous analysis MISO, Transmission Owners & Stakeholders Includes subregional planning meetings MTEP goals Ensure the reliability of the transmission system Ensure compliance with NERC Standards Provide economic benefits, such as increased market efficiency Facilitate public policy objectives, such as meeting Renewable Portfolio Standards Address other issues or goals identified through the stakeholder process Multiple future scenarios analyzed End result – comprehensive, cohesive plan for MISO footprint MTEP approved by MISO Board of Directors

24 Brief history of development
MISO MVPS Brief history of development Began investigating value added expansion in 2003 2008 Regional Generation Outlet Study (RGOS) - formed basis of Candidate MVP portfolio Portfolio refined due to additional analysis MISO approved portfolio of 17 Projects Seven transmission line segments (MTEP proj numbers) in Ameren territory Ameren identifies these three projects as: Illinois Rivers (four line segments) Spoon River Mark Twain (two line segments) Broadly cost-shared, AMIL pricing zone allocated 10% of each MVP no matter where project is located or who builds it

25 Appendix - MAP OF AMEREN MVPs

26 Appendix - Rate incentives
FERC approved the following rate incentives for Illinois Rivers in Docket No. EL10-80 CWIP (no AFUDC) Abandonment (requires additional filing prior to recovery) Hypothetical capital structure during construction for ATXI FERC approved similar incentives for Spoon River and Mark Twain Projects in Docket No. ER

27 Appendix - Miso web links
Transmission Pricing - Attachments O, GG & MM Information Ameren OASIS MTEP 15 MTEP 16 Schedule 26 & 26-A Indicative Charges

28 Additional questions on these topics can be sent to Ameren at:
Appendix - Atxi Additional questions on these topics can be sent to Ameren at:


Download ppt "2015 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting"

Similar presentations


Ads by Google