1. Education or Enforcement what is the priority?
Mick Doyle
Superintendent Roads Policing

2. Education or Enforcement
Police Enforcement
Police Discretion and Diversion
National Schemes
Local Innovation
Future Opportunities

3. Police Enforcement Is the risk of getting caught a deterrent?
Is the level of police activity effective?
Is it intelligence led or just about collecting numbers?

4. Police Discretion and Diversion
What is discretion?
Where should it be applied?
Points or Diversion?

5. National Diversion Schemes
ACPO NDORS
Driver Improvement
Speed Awareness
Rider Improvement (pilot)

6. Local Innovation High Speed Mobile Phones Seat Belts
Young Driver Scheme

7. Education Courses in TVP

8. KSI’s in TVP

10. To reduce young driver collisions
By increasing their awareness of the key issues associated with young driver crashes
By addressing these key issues with them using forward thinking training methods 10

11. e-learning Modules Anatomy of a crash Attitude and Alertness
Safety Margins
Overtaking
Anticipation and Awareness 11

13. Evaluation 12 months / 5,000 drivers
Effect of YDS on collisions and violations
Effect of YDS on attitudes
immediately before and after
after six months
Five Control Groups 13

14. Education through Enforcement that is the priority!
Mick Doyle
Superintendent Roads Policing

15. Future Opportunities ?
Evaluation!

16. Education or Enforcement what is the priority?
Mick Doyle
Superintendent Roads Policing