1. Libraries and Copyright
Current Litigation

2. Outline
Background
Cases

3. Background

4. Background Section 106 Reproduction Derivative works or Adaptations
Distribution
Public performance (transmission)
Public display

5. Background Exceptions and Limitations 107 Fair Use 108 Libraries
109 Right of First Sale

6. Background
Fair Use

7. Court Cases- Background
How this stuff works...
Section 108 and Fair Use (107)
Who is litigating and why?

8. Court Cases
Diversery
Kirtsaeng
Hathitrust and Google
Georgia State

9. Court Cases - Diversery
Facts
The Story
Right of Distribution
Outcome
Library Distribution (Hoatling)
item in collection
item in catalog
item available to the public

10. Court Cases- Diversery
Why is this case important?
Making available

11. Court Cases - Kirtsaeng
Facts
The Story
Right of First Sale
Outcome

12. Court Cases - Hathitrust
Facts
The Story
Ignited over an orphaned works project
Authors Guild
Right of Reproduction and Distribution

13. Court Cases - Hathitrust
At Issue
Section 108 vs 107
Searchable index with snippets
Print disabled
Preservation

15. Court Cases - Hathitrust
District court
transformative use, and thus fair use

16. Court Cases - Hathitrust
Appellate court
Print disabled
fair use, but not transformative use
Indexing
transformative fair use
AG did not have standing
Preservation issue remanded to lower court

17. Court Cases - Hathitrust
Why is this case important?
Code of Best Practices
108 and Fair Use (107)
Fair Use - Transformative Use
Print Disabled

18. Court Cases - Georgia State
Facts
The Story
Right of Distribution and Reproduction
Outcome

19. Court Cases - Georgia State
Of 99 cases, only 5 were found not to be fair use
GA State found to be the prevailing party
Fair use-4 factors
Not transformative
The 5 losses has readily available electronic licensable excerpts

20. Court Cases - Georgia State
subsequent use
pages

21. Court Cases - Georgia State
transformative use
injunction
10% bright line struck down
fact vs creative
what is the copyrighted work
course packs
downloading and printing
university policies

22. Court Cases - Georgia State
Hathitrust
Section 108 v 107
Is transformative use necessary
Licensing market
market substitution - willingness to pay is irrelevant

23. Why is this case important
Because it affects Mark. :)

24. What does this mean?
Risk or Opportunity

25. Why are you here?

26. Etc….
SCLA
CHEER Repository
Open Access and Fair Use weeks