Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Non-compliant behavior in a regulatory biosecurity framework

Published byPaul Leonard Modified over 6 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Non-compliant behavior in a regulatory biosecurity framework"— Presentation transcript:

1 Non-compliant behavior in a regulatory biosecurity framework
Claire McKee 22 November 2017

2 What is our role? . Policy advice, market access negotiation, client service and industry regulation Primary industries Biosecurity Australia’s rivers & freshwater ecosystems Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 2

3 Biosecurity at the border in 2016/17:
20 million inbound travellers 158 million inbound mail items 18,000 inbound vessels 970,000 import cargo assessments 450,000 commercial consignments 520,000 non-commercial consignments 3,653 Approved Arrangements (brokers, depots, importers, treatment providers) . Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 3

4 Conscious regulatory opponents: summary
Concept: ‘a brain behind the harm’ Malcolm Sparrow Elements Duel regulator vs regulated Deliberate adaptation Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 4

5 Conscious regulatory opponents: detail
Assess type/nature of regulatory controls Opponents who intend to outwit regulator Develop novel methods to evade regulatory controls Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 5

6 Regulator ≠ conscious regulatory opponents
Wide spectrum Environmental Transport, workplace safety Tax Law enforcement Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 6

7 So what? Implications for probability based assessments
Less predictive Agility/adaptiveness Case study: imported prawns/Operation Cattai Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 7

8 So what: regulatory tools/tactics implications
Understand how regulatory opponents think/act Tiger/red teams Novel strategies/counter tactics Less predictable New/emerging pattern detection important Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 8

9 So what: regulatory intelligence
Emergent capability Different to defence/law enforcement Common regulatory tools Behaviour regulation, education, voluntary compliance, best practice Efficacy of regulatory tools New tools/tactics Department of Agriculture and Water Resources Claire McKee 22 November 2017 9

Download ppt "Non-compliant behavior in a regulatory biosecurity framework"

Similar presentations

Invasive Species as a Trilateral Challenge Preventing the Introduction and Spread of Aquatic Invasives Species in North America Commission for Environmental.

Invasive Species as a Trilateral Challenge Preventing the Introduction and Spread of Aquatic Invasives Species in North America Commission for Environmental.
Emergency Responder Sensitive PREPAREDNESS, RESPONSE AND RECOVERY ~ STRATEGIES FOR ~ AGROTERRORISM Jerry Gillespie,

Emergency Responder Sensitive PREPAREDNESS, RESPONSE AND RECOVERY ~ STRATEGIES FOR ~ AGROTERRORISM Jerry Gillespie,
Paul Hubbard Portfolio Manager, Border and Transportation Security Information Sharing: Barriers and Solutions Sept 9 Workshop Summary Presented to Armed.

Paul Hubbard Portfolio Manager, Border and Transportation Security Information Sharing: Barriers and Solutions Sept 9 Workshop Summary Presented to Armed.
A practical overview from planning to practice on the destruction of methane generated from manure in piggeries. Source: Clean Energy Regulator (CER) July.

A practical overview from planning to practice on the destruction of methane generated from manure in piggeries. Source: Clean Energy Regulator (CER) July.
Quality Risk Management ICH Q9 Annex I: Methods & Tools

Quality Risk Management ICH Q9 Annex I: Methods & Tools
U.S. Department of Agriculture Office of Food Safety Food Safety and Inspection Service Winston Felton, D.V.M. Dearborn Circuit Supervisor Madison District.

U.S. Department of Agriculture Office of Food Safety Food Safety and Inspection Service Winston Felton, D.V.M. Dearborn Circuit Supervisor Madison District.
Limits of Inspections and Enforcement, Tools and Approaches to Promote Private Sector Compliance and Improve Safety and Outcomes Donald Macrae, WBG Consultant.

Limits of Inspections and Enforcement, Tools and Approaches to Promote Private Sector Compliance and Improve Safety and Outcomes Donald Macrae, WBG Consultant.
1 CHCOHS312A Follow safety procedures for direct care work.

1 CHCOHS312A Follow safety procedures for direct care work.
Performance Metrics for EMS Self Assessment & Management Review 30 th Environmental and Energy Symposium & Exhibition April 5 – 8, 2004.

Performance Metrics for EMS Self Assessment & Management Review 30 th Environmental and Energy Symposium & Exhibition April 5 – 8, 2004.
INFORMATION SECURITY GOVERNANCE (ISG) Relates to the security of information systems Is an element of corporate governance.

INFORMATION SECURITY GOVERNANCE (ISG) Relates to the security of information systems Is an element of corporate governance.
United States Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Plant Protection and Quarantine Plant Protection & Quarantines Roles.

United States Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Plant Protection and Quarantine Plant Protection & Quarantines Roles.
Vehicle Recalls in Australia Robert Hogan General Manager, Vehicle Safety Standards Branch Administrator of Vehicle Standards Working Party 29 Enforcement.

Vehicle Recalls in Australia Robert Hogan General Manager, Vehicle Safety Standards Branch Administrator of Vehicle Standards Working Party 29 Enforcement.
1 Effective Safety & Health Assessments: Audits and Inspections Disclaimer: These safety materials, resources and PowerPoint ® presentations are not intended.

1 Effective Safety & Health Assessments: Audits and Inspections Disclaimer: These safety materials, resources and PowerPoint ® presentations are not intended.
D2.TTO.CL4.12 Slide 1. Subject Elements This unit comprises five Elements: 1.Describe the social and cultural impacts of tourism operations 2.Describe.

D2.TTO.CL4.12 Slide 1. Subject Elements This unit comprises five Elements: 1.Describe the social and cultural impacts of tourism operations 2.Describe.
ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS NOVEMBER 25, 2013. OVERVIEW Pros and Cons of Economic Instruments Tax Incentives and Allowances Non-tax Instruments Other Economic.

ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS NOVEMBER 25, OVERVIEW Pros and Cons of Economic Instruments Tax Incentives and Allowances Non-tax Instruments Other Economic.
Managing Farm Chemical Risks in Australia Roger B Toffolon Program Leader, Chemical Risk Management Australia China Agricultural Forum University of Western.

Managing Farm Chemical Risks in Australia Roger B Toffolon Program Leader, Chemical Risk Management Australia China Agricultural Forum University of Western.
Telecommunications Customer Equipment Compliance & Labelling Peter Cunningham Standards Section ITP 2006.

Telecommunications Customer Equipment Compliance & Labelling Peter Cunningham Standards Section ITP 2006.
How to Determine the Need to Regulate WTO TBT Committee Workshop on Good Regulatory Practice March 18 – 19 2008 Neil Eisner Assistant General Counsel U.S.

How to Determine the Need to Regulate WTO TBT Committee Workshop on Good Regulatory Practice March 18 – Neil Eisner Assistant General Counsel U.S.
TRP Chapter 3.1 1 Chapter 3.1 Regulatory approaches.

TRP Chapter Chapter 3.1 Regulatory approaches.
Introduction to Workplace Safety

Introduction to Workplace Safety

Similar presentations

Ads by Google