1. Making your feedback count
Peer Evaluations
Making your feedback count

2. Vague Category Did Well Can Improve Good intro
Introduction
Captured attention?
Previewed main ideas?
Clear transition into body?
Good intro
Body
Vivid, clearly-explained content?
Logical reasoning?
Appropriate and credible sources?
Lots of really good content
Conclusion
Strong closure?
Left an impact?
Not such a good ending
Organization
Easy to follow?
Clear transitions between points?
Could improve the organization
Delivery
Confidence, eye contact, volume, pausing, rate, vocal variance, gestures, distracting mannerisms…
Really good delivery

3. Contradictory Category Did Well Can Improve
Introduction
Captured attention?
Previewed main ideas?
Clear transition into body?
Easy to know what you’re going to talk about
Was there a preview? (might have missed it)
Body
Vivid, clearly-explained content?
Logical reasoning?
Appropriate and credible sources?
Good sources and stats
Conclusion
Strong closure?
Left an impact?
Little boring – just restated your main points
Organization
Easy to follow?
Clear transitions between points?
Logical flow
Hard to follow main points
Delivery
Confidence, eye contact, volume, pausing, rate, vocal variance, gestures, distracting mannerisms…
Good eye contact
Nice voice
Look up more

4. Overly Generous Category Did Well Can Improve Awesome – loved it! Yes.
Introduction
Captured attention?
Previewed main ideas?
Clear transition into body?
Awesome – loved it!
Body
Vivid, clearly-explained content?
Logical reasoning?
Appropriate and credible sources?
Yes.
Conclusion
Strong closure?
Left an impact?
Best ending I’ve heard.
Organization
Easy to follow?
Clear transitions between points?
Easy to follow.
Delivery
Confidence, eye contact, volume, pausing, rate, vocal variance, gestures, distracting mannerisms…
Great eye contact.
Very confident.
Give him an A!

5. Overly Critical Category Did Well Can Improve
Introduction
Captured attention?
Previewed main ideas?
Clear transition into body?
Seems irrelevant. I find no connection with the opening or the topic.
Body
Vivid, clearly-explained content?
Logical reasoning?
Appropriate and credible sources?
Dull. I couldn’t pay attention. Did not have anything to do with me.
Conclusion
Strong closure?
Left an impact?
Consistent with the rest of speech. Terrible.
Organization
Easy to follow?
Clear transitions between points?
I couldn’t follow due to the lack of interest.
Delivery
Confidence, eye contact, volume, pausing, rate, vocal variance, gestures, distracting mannerisms…
Read off of cards
Too quick
Annoying voice

6. Helpful Category Did Well Can Improve Introduction Captured attention?
Previewed main ideas?
Clear transition into body?
Excellent story
Good questions – related topic to class
Emphasize the preview more
Body
Vivid, clearly-explained content?
Logical reasoning?
Appropriate and credible sources?
Visual aids enhanced concepts.
Kept relating topic to the audience through examples – I liked this.
Conclusion
Strong closure?
Left an impact?
Didn’t provide much closure since your voice trailed off
Organization
Easy to follow?
Clear transitions between points?
Logical progression of ideas – history first, different aspects of the problem next
Transitions need to be emphasized more clearly
Delivery
Confidence, eye contact, volume, pausing, rate, vocal variance, gestures, distracting mannerisms…
Very good volume
Strong eye contact – very natural
Swayed back and forth.
Slow down – you started off pretty fast during the intro and sounded nervous.