1. Project: IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: [Task Group 1 Opening Report]
Date Submitted: [10Jul00]
Source: [Ian Gifford] Company [M/A-COM, Inc.]
Address [1011 Pawtucket Boulevard Lowell, MA USA ]
Voice:[ ], FAX: [ ],
Re: [-00/095r0, etc.]
Abstract: [TG1 chair report to WG.]
Purpose: [TG1 chair report to WG to update them from the last session (#6) to the current session (#7) on all the work items.]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by
July 2000
doc.: IEEE /172r1
July 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

2. IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks™
July 2000
doc.: IEEE /172r1
July 2000
IEEE Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks™
TG1 Report #1
July 2000 LaJolla, CA USA
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

3. Contents TG1 Summary Overview of Session #7/LaJolla
July 2000
doc.: IEEE /172r1
July 2000
Contents
TG1 Summary
Overview of Session #7/LaJolla
Objectives
Submissions
Session Graphic
Tentative TG1 Needs for Sep00 Interim
TG1 Draft Sources – Baseline
TG1 Draft Sources - Revision
Next Steps/TG1 Roadmap
TG1 Drafting History
Next Steps
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

4. July 2000
TG1 Summary
Letter Ballot #3 failed! 18/15/0/; out of 49 voting members, there were 33 responses (25 required for a valid vote). Detail:
15 yes w/o comment
3 yes with comment
15 no
0 abstains
16 failed to vote.
LB3 yielded 387 Comments to be resolved, summarized in –00/159r0 worksheet.
25 Comments were received in a late ballot; new total 412.
LB3 Comment Resolution 10-13Jul00, post meeting, and possibly into Aug00.
Once resolved, apply edits –00/159r0, BSIG v1.1, et. al. to next Draft
LB(4) Recirculation, est. Sep00
Draft ready for Sponsor Ballot prior to Nov00 Plenary
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

5. TG1 LaJolla 2000 Objectives Comment Resolution
July 2000
TG1 LaJolla 2000 Objectives
Comment Resolution
Planning for update to D0.7.2
Begin production of D0.8
Plan for production of D1.0
Triage of comments 6:30pm, 8am 7/11
Plan for baseline Draft/BT SIG Charter 9:30am, to be complete by 12pm
Detail comment resolution thereafter
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

6. Seattle - Submissions July 2000 doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/172r1 July 2000
From: Gifford, Ian C.
Sent: Friday, July 07, :41 AM
To: Tom Siep ( )
Subject: TG1 Planned Submissions or doc numbers
Tom,
Per our discussion here are the TG1 Planned Submissions or doc numbers - feel free to ad lib, etc.
Ooops USE 159!!! for Comment DB not error in prior ...
***
00/159 g 00159r0P WG Letter Ballot 3 Comments Resolution Worksheet xls Gifford
*00/161 g 00161r1P WG Operating Rules doc Gifford
*00/163 g 00163r2P TG1 July00 Meeting Objectives and Agenda xls Gifford
+00/168 g 00168r0P TG1 July00 Minutes doc Kinney
~00/172 g 00172r0P WG TG1 Opening Report ppt Siep
+00/176 g 00176r0P WG TG1 Closing Report ppt Siep
*00/181 g 00181r0P TG1 BTCongress-14June00-Siep-r1.ppt ppt Siep
~00/182 g 00182r0P WG July 00 Liaison Report 8 ppt Gifford
*00/183 g 00183r0P TG1 HomeRF IEEE ComSoc Pitch 8Jun00 ppt Gifford
*00/184 g 00184r0P TG1 Bluetooth IEEE ComSoc Pitch 8Jun00 ppt Gifford
+00/188 g 00188r0P TG1 WPAN2 SG Planning Report ppt Gifford
~00/189 g 00189r0P WG Draft Guidelines For Hosting Interim ppt Gifford
+00/190 g 00190r3P TG1 Bluetooth™ SIG Program Management Report 13Jun00 ppt Siep
Comments
C1 + Your baby
C2 ~ I'll send them as the come through.
C3 * Done just FYI --
Ian Gifford
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

7. TG1 Jul00 Session #7 Graphic
July 2000
doc.: IEEE /172r1
July 2000
TG1 Jul00 Session #7 Graphic
Legend:
WG = Working Group
AC = Advisory Core (of the WG)
TG1 = Task Group 1 WPAN or Bluetooth Derivation
TG2 = Task Group 2 WPAN to WLAN Coexistence
TG3 = Task Group WPAN-HR (High Rate) SG
MC = Marketing Committee
Joint = Joint Meeting of the & WGs
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

8. LB3 Results - Overview 49 Total Voting Members
July 2000
LB3 Results - Overview
49 Total Voting Members
33 Total Votes (18/15/0)
16 Total Failed to vote
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

9. July 2000
LB3 Results – Detail
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

10. LB3 Summary – Detail (cont.)
July 2000
LB3 Summary – Detail (cont.)
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

11. Type of comments (e/E/t/T) – LB3 #
July 2000
doc.: IEEE /172r1
July 2000
Type of comments (e/E/t/T) – LB3 #
Notes:
NadaG used a non-standard Type of Comment e.g., 32 "E/t" and 4 "e/t". I am unclear how to deal with these comments. The Editor-in-Chief interpreted them as "t’s”; which nets 59 total of which 36 are hybrid.
PatK forgot to code pwk19 e.g., Type of Comment e.g., "E/t/e/t”.
HoumanA used a non-standard numbering for comments e.g., 8a, 8b, etc. indicating he did not read the instructions. He supplied 62 not 48 comments.
MikeP used "e" 100% in the Type of comments (E/e/T/t) and added the N, t, T in the Part of NO vote (Y/N); indicating he did not read the instructions. Therefore he has 139 "e's" and he added 4 "t’s" and 3 "T’s" to the wrong column hence -7 "e’s" and a some T/t entries.
Dropped Dr. Yunxin Li as I could not find his comments. Source: BobH results *.xls file. FOUND 10JAN00…All 250 of them! He forgot to code yxl007.
Dropped Mr. Daniel R. McGlynn & Mr. Ivan Reede as they did not supply Comments w/ their “Nea” vote. Therefore these balloters failed to vote. Note: Ivan indicated 7Jan00 that he would change his “Nea” to a “Yea” w/o Comments if it stalled the WG Balloting process. He will not supply comments on his nea vote - lost HD & NadaG covered his comments.
TG1 appreciates the work these eighteen (18) Members did
in providing these 412 Comments! SteveS was late but is in queue.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

12. Type of comments (e/E/t/T) - LB1 #/%
July 2000
Type of comments (e/E/t/T) - LB1 #/%
412 Comments
Minor Editorial "e”
127 (31%)
Major Editorial "E”
140 (34%)
Minor Technical "t”
51 (12%)
Major Technical "T”
94 (23%)
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

13. Tentative TG1 Needs for Sep00 Interim
July 2000
Tentative TG1 Needs for Sep00 Interim
18-21Sep00 (4 Days)
25 People
Power Strips, w/ 1 outlet per chair
BR = Boardroom
LCD = PC Screen Projector & Screen (SVGA, 450 lumens)
FC = Flipchart with markers
TG1 will provide a Sep00 graphic for TG1 on Thursday, 13Jul00 to the WG
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

14. TG1 Draft Sources – Baseline
July 2000
23May00
TG1 Draft Sources – Baseline
4Nov99
8May00
10Jul00 ?
v1.1
D0.6
(v1.0A) +
IEEE Clauses
D0.7 = D0.6
+(BSIG v1.0B)
+-99/173r5a C1-5
+HCI
+Annex – Timers
+MSCs
+SDLs
D0.8=D0.7
+(BSIG v1.1)
+Informal
comments
+PICS
SDLs
Letter Ballot #1
Letter Ballot #2
Letter Ballot #3
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

15. TG1 Draft Sources - Revision
July 2000
TG1 Draft Sources - Revision
*~5Jul00
~20Aug00
*17Apr00
*8May00
*12May00
~12Jul00 ?
v1.1
D0.7.0
(v1.0B)
+HCI
+Annex
+Timers
+MSCs
+etc.
D0.7.1
(v1.0B)
+-99/173r6
C1-11
Annex
+SDLs
+PICS
D0.7.2
(v1.0B)
+-99/173r6
C1-11
Annex
+Informal
comments
D0.8
(v1.1)
C1-11
Annex
+etc.
Letter Ballot #3
40 Day LB
*Note: Date released by Editor-in-Chief
Available one (1) week before ballot starts.
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

16. Timeline - Summary 10-13Jul00 LaJolla, CA USA
July 2000
Timeline - Summary
10-13Jul00 LaJolla, CA USA
? [NEED INPUT HERE FROM SESSION #7]
18-21Sep00 Scottsdale, AZ USA
Finalize P /D1.0 for Sponsor Ballot
27Oct00 Deadline For RevCom Draft Submission
6-10Nov00 Tampa, FL USA
15-18Jan01 San Jose, CA USA
9Feb01 Deadline For RevCom Draft Submission
12-16Mar01 Hilton Head, SC USA
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

17. Timeline - Detail July 2000 Note: Critical date for receipt of BSIG
Specification v1.1 revision
Note: Backward scheduling from RevCom Deadlines
indicates we will miss 27Oct00 and slip to 9Feb01
…IEEE Std.
Source: IEEE802_15_1-editorial-plan-r5.mpp
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.

18. TG1 Drafting History July 2000 Draft 0.0 - Tom Siep 100%
283 Pages
Draft Tom Siep 100%
Draft BT-IEEE Editorial Working Group
331 Pages
1 Chief Editor/6 Technical Editors
6 Bluetooth Promoter Company Reviewers w/ internal help
~300 Comments
Draft BT-IEEE Editorial Working Group
308 Pages
1013 Comments
Draft 0.7 – Tom Siep 100%
617 Pages
Draft IEEE Task Group 1 Technical Editors
803 Pages
1 Chief Editor/11 Technical Editors
Draft IEEE Task Group 1 Technical Editors
773 Pages
412 Comments
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.