Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
Program Evaluation Alternative Approaches and Practical Guidelines
by Jody L. Fitzpatrick, James R. Sanders, Blaine R. Worthen PowerPoint Presentation Gerri Spinella, Ed.D.
2
Participant-Oriented Evaluation Approaches
Chapter 8 Participant-Oriented Evaluation Approaches
3
Chapter 8 Concepts Participant - Oriented Evaluation Differentiation
In Contemporary Approaches Approaches in Practice Definitions Key Terms Differences in Transformative Approaches Strengths Limitations
4
What are the key concepts of the participant -oriented approach?
Essential Questions What are the key concepts of the participant -oriented approach? How might we differentiate among the many different contemporary participative approaches? How do the practical participatory approaches differ from transformative ones? Contrast the different participatory-oriented approaches used in practice. What are the major strengths and limitations of the participatory- oriented approach?
5
Key Terms/Leader Participant-Oriented Evaluation Approach
Robert Stake – Responsive Approach Egon Guba, Yvonna Lincoln – Naturalistic Approach Bradley Cousins – Practical Participatory Evaluation (P-PE) Michael Patton – Development Evaluation David Fetterman – Empowerment Evaluation Democratically-Oriented Approaches
6
Guba and Lincoln – Naturalistic Evaluation
Views/Values - Stakeholders Evaluator – Facilitator for Consensus-Building Stake – Responsive Approach Program Worth or Merit Evaluator – In depth Discussion/Observation with Stakeholders Participant-Oriented Approaches Capacity Building – Self Determination Evaluator – Empower Stakeholders with Transformation
7
Participatory Approaches
Characteristics: Participatory Approaches Direct & Active Participation Over Time Participant Ownership Professional Evaluator as Partner/Facilitator/Coach Evaluation Capacity
8
Control over evaluation or technical design-making process
Stakeholder selection Depth of participation Categories: Participatory Approaches
9
Participatory Evaluation Approaches
Practical (P-PE) Developmental Transformative Stakeholder-based Empowerment Deliberative Democratic Participatory Evaluation Approaches
10
Empowerment Evaluation
Transformative Empower stakeholders Primary decision-makers are evaluators Empowerment Evaluation Embodies social equity and equality Ideal model to guide evaluator’s practice Deliberative Democratic Evaluation
11
STRENGTHS & LIMITATIONS
Increase understanding and use of evaluation by stakeholders Provides more valid and useful information STRENGTHS Concerns about bias More time and cost to involve stakeholders LIMITATIONS
12
Chapter 8 Reflection How would you as a leader provide a non-biased approach in building organizational capacity using the participant-oriented evaluation?
Similar presentations
