1. Mental and physical comorbidity in an Arab national primary health care setting
Dr. Muhammad Ajmal Zahid
Chairman,
Department of Psychiatry,
Faculty of Medicine,
Kuwait University.

2. Background
Comorbidity is defined as the co-occurrence of mental and physical disorders in the same person, regardless of the chronological order in which they occurred or the causal pathway linking them
Comorbidity is an important topic because it is one of the commonest relationships among medical illnesses, with a significant impact on the mode of presentation, clinical severity, response to treatment and psychosocial burden of illness.
The pathways causing comorbidity of mental and medical disorders are complex and bidirectional, such that, while medical disorders may lead to mental ones, mental conditions may place a person at risk for medical disorders, and mental and medical disorders may share common risk factors

3. Objectives
Estimate the prevalence of the comorbidity between common mental disorders (anxiety/ depression / somatization) and chronic physical illnesses (diabetes mellitus, hypertension, heart disease and bronchial asthma) in a national random sample of primary health care attendees
Explore the relationship of comorbidity with type of illness and socio- demographic characteristics.

4. Sampling
Out of the total number of 87 primary health centers in all the five state Governorates, sixteen centers were blindly selected from the random table.
The sample size was calculated to significance level set at 0.05% and a precision of 2%, for an estimated 16% prevalence of psychiatric disorders. An adequate sample size (using power curve) was estimated to be 1000 participants. As a result, a total number of consenting subjects were recruited so as to allow for 5% of the missing data cases.

5. Procedures
Sixteen physicians administered the PHQ's to all the consenting primary clinic attendees, and their demographic characteristics recorded while they waited for consultation with the physician.
Both the English and the Arabic versions of the questionnaires were made available.
The treating physicians were requested to refer any patient found to be mentally ill.
The patients were recruited on alternative working days during the 5- month period from 1st May to 30th September, 2012.

6. Measures
The Patient Health Questionnaire -Somatic/Anxiety/Depression (PHQ- SAD) is an easy-to administer, brief diagnostic assessment tool, designed to measure probable rates of psychiatric morbidity in the primary care settings.
The physical diagnoses, based on the International Classification of Diseases, 10th edition (ICD-10), were assigned by the primary care physicians. All the physically ill patients were receiving treatment for their respective ailments which had been confirmed, where necessary, with by further investigations and the hospital doctor consultation.

7. Association of demographics
Physical illnesses
Mental illnesses
Physical illnesses
Older
Divorce
Poor living conditions
Illiteracy
Mental illnesses
Older
Female
Kuwaitis
Lower levels of education

8. Relationship of mental illnesses to physical morbidity
Higher prevalence of mental illnesses
Higher psychopathology scores
Increasing number of physical illnesses

9. Association of physical and mental morbidity

10. Association of (number) physical illnesses with (types) mental disorders

11. Severity of psychopathology with number of physical illnesses

12. Severity of psychopathology with type of physical illnesses

13. Results (1) Total number of patients = 1046
275 (26.3%) had only physical condition
148 (14.1%) had 2 physical conditions
33 (3.2) had at least 3 physical conditions
670/360 (53%) had physical-mental comorbidity while mental illness in those without physical illness was 21.8% (376/82)
(OR = 4.1, P < 0.001)
Subjects with heart diseases and asthma consistently had higher psychopathology scores.

14. Results (2) 670/1046 (64%) had at least one medical illness
diabetes mellitus (37.01%),
hypertension (34.18%),
heart diseases (7.2%) and
non-chronic physical illnesses (9.4%)
442/1056 (42%) had at least one mental disorder
Somatization
Depression
anxiety disorder
442/223 (50%) had mental-physical comorbidity

15. Weaknesses and strengths
Cross-sectional design
Cut-off scores used to ascertain caseness
Limited range of medical illnesses
Sample large and representative
Standardized instruments
Limited range of illnesses reflect service delivery system with ready availability of specialist centers

16. Conclusions
The findings call for the primary care physicians to be sensitive to the psychosocial context of patients who present primarily with physical conditions; more so for patients with multiple medical illnesses and social disadvantage.
The primary clinic physicians need to be trained to adopt holistic (bio- psycho-social) approach to assess the primary clinic attendees.
The primary clinic physicians need to be trained to treat the common psychiatric disorders (anxiety, depression, somatization) at the primary care level.

17. Thank you