1. ISO/IEC TR 19763 -4 (11) ( Structured Model Registration)
SC32WG2 Nxxxx
ISO/IEC TR (11) ( Structured Model Registration)
Masaharu Obayashi
SC32/WG2 interim meeting at RedWood

2. Scope of proposed sub project
This is a proposal to reorganize the content between two existing parts of the multi-part International Standard ISO/IEC Metamodel framework for interoperability (parts 2 and 4), modifying the respective titles and scopes of these parts, and converting one of the parts (part4) into a TR.
Part 2 (10): Core model and basic mapping (IS)
This part provides a common base to all the other parts of ISO/IEC The metamodel specified by this part consists of the metamodel for registering models and the metamodel for basic mappings among them, and are inherited by all the other parts of ISO/IEC
Part 4 (11): Structured model registration (TR)
This part provides the way of model registration for encapsulation approach. The metamodel of this part specifies the metamodel for registering complex metamodels and models including relationship among them. The standardization of business concepts and business models (or metamodels) to be registered for specific business domains is out of scope in this part of ISO/IEC
Working Draft:
SC32WG2 N1439 Working Draft for ISO/IEC PDTR (11)

3. Concept World Terminology Domain Profile Domain Vocabulary Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Concept
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

4. Artifact World (Domain)
Terminology
Domain Profile
ISO
Domain Vocabulary
ISO
Metamodel UN
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
ANSI
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
US Auto
use
Code
Model
JP Auto ….
JIS …. GM
use
use ….
Instance
Toyota
Instance ….
Instance
Honda
Ford
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

5. Example: ISO 20022 Repository
The ISO Repository consists of two major parts: the Data Dictionary and the Business Process Catalogue.
The Data Dictionary contains Business Concepts, Message Concepts and Data Types. All these items are reusable and are called Dictionary Items. The Data Dictionary as a whole is under release control.
The Business Process Catalogue is organised in Business Areas. The communication requirements and the interaction requirements in the various Business Areas are supported by Business Transactions. All items that are stored in the Business Process Catalogue are called Catalogue

6. Example: ISO 20022 Data Dictionary
Business Concepts are Dictionary items with a business semantic meaning. The following items are part of this category: Business Associations, Business Components, Rules, Business Elements and Business Actors/Roles.  
Data Types are Dictionary items that unambiguously specifies the set of valid values of a Business Element or of a Message Element.
Message Concepts are Dictionary items used in messages. The following items are part of this category: Message Components, Rules and Message Elements

7. Structured Model Registration
UoD
Looking & modeling a specific target from many views
MetaModel
Model
Instances
registering
Specified by model
Process
Service
Registry

8. (1) Specialization approach
UoD
UML Tool Repository
Written by many languages (UML profile)
Looking & modeling a specific target from many views
MFI-3 MetaModel
MFI-5 MetaModel
MFI-7 MetaModel
Model
Model
Model
Instances
Instances
Instances
Metadata
Metadata
Metadata
Registering the abstraction of content according to metamodel of MFI
Extract values of metadata
Ontology
Process
Service
MFI Registry

9. (2) Encapsulation approach (Structured model registration)
UoD
Looking & modeling a specific target by many views
Metamodel needed for interpretation
MFI-3
MetaModel
MFI-5 MetaModel
MFI-7
MetaModel
Model
Model
Model
Instances
Instances
Instances
Written by many languages
Registering as books
Process
Ontology
Service
Looking & modeling a bookshelf
MFI & MDR MetaModel
Model
Reading sections　and mapping content after retrieving
Registry

10. Classification World (1) structure
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Classification
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

11. Classification World (2) Term
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
Classification
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

12. Classification World (3) Structure & Term
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Classification
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

13. Graphical Notation for MFI-4 (11)
Domain Profile
Concept
(Classifier)
Sign
Conceptualization
Instances
ComponentSet
Component
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

14. Mapping World (1) Structure
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
Model Mapping
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

15. Mapping World (2) Term Code Mapping Terminology Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model ….
Code Mapping ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

16. Mapping World (3) Structure & Term
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model ….
use ….
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Data Mapping
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

17. Classification Mapping(1)
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
Model Mapping based on Classification Mapping
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

18. Classification Mapping(2)
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model ….
Code Mapping based on
Classification Mapping ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

19. Classification Mapping(3)
Terminology
Domain Profile
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system
use …. ….
Realm Profile
Code
Code system
Model
Realm Profile ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
Data Mapping based on Model and Code Mapping
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

20. Model Evolution Terminology Domain Profile v1 Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system v1
use …. ….
Realm Profile v1
Code
Code system v2
Model
Realm Profile v2 ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

21. Classification Evolution
Terminology
Domain Profile v1
Domain Vocabulary
Metamodel
Code system v1
use …. ….
Realm Profile v1
Code
Code system v2
Model
Realm Profile v2 ….
Code
Model ….
Code
Model
use
Code
Model …. ….
use
use
Classification
Changed ….
Instance
Instance ….
Instance
Instance
Classification
Changed
Affinity Domain
Affinity Domain
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

22. Example: MDMI

23. Example: MDMI

24. Example: MDMI

25. Example: Mapping in MDMI

26. Example: Mapping in MDMI

27. Example: Mapping in MDMI

28. Example: Mapping in MDMI

29. Example: Mapping in MDMI

30. Example: Mapping in MDMI

31. Registering Mapping in MFI-4 (11)

32. Translation Rule Type
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

33. MM-M Transformation Kind (1)
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

34. MM-M Transformation Kind (2)
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

35. Transformation Kind (1) Example
UML
OWL
Mapping UML to OWL
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

36. M-V Transformation Kind (1)
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

37. M-V Transformation Kind (2)
2018/11/23
(c) 2007 Masaharu Obayashi

38. Registering Mapping in MFI-4 (11): Examples with instances

39. heating and cooking units
procurement
fisher
farmer
food
heating and cooking units
cook
ingredients
Role and Goal
driver
recipe
recipe of salad
Process
cut
stir
dish
making a lunch box
butcher
mixer
Service
model
model instance

40. Role and Goal cook food fisher farmer heating and cooking units driver
Sign
Concept
(Classifier)
Instances
Domain Profile
ComponentSet
Component
Conceptualization
RG metamodel
RG model
A-E
Process metamodel
Process model
Process
RG-P mapping
Role and Goal
Role
Goal
cook
food
fisher
farmer
Domain Profile
Aaa Role
Domain Profile
Abc Process
Bbb Goal
Concept
(Classifier)
Concept
(Classifier)
heating and
cooking units
Sign
Sign
driver
T-I
T-I
Conceptualization
Conceptualization
Instances
Instances
RG-P mapping
ingredients
ComponentSet
ComponentSet
procurement
Component
Aaaa-Bbb RG instance
Abc Process instance

41. Process and Service recipe cut stir dish mixer recipe of abc butcher
Domain Profile
Process
Domain Profile
Service
recipe
Concept
(Classifier)
Concept
(Classifier)
cut
Sign
Sign
A-E
A-E
stir
Conceptualization
Conceptualization
Instances
Instances
dish
P-S mapping
ComponentSet
ComponentSet
Component
Process metamodel
Service metamodel
Process model
Service model
mixer
Domain Profile
Abc Process
Domain Profile
Xyz Service
Concept
(Classifier)
Concept
(Classifier)
recipe of abc
butcher
Sign
Sign
T-I
T-I
Conceptualization
Conceptualization
Instances
Instances
P-S mapping
making a lunch box
ComponentSet
ComponentSet
Component
Abc Process instance
XYZ Service instance