Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
802.11k San Antonio Agendas Richard Paine richard.h.paine@boeing.com
November 2004 802.11k San Antonio Agendas Richard Paine Richard Paine, Boeing
2
Radio Resource Measurement
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Radio Resource Measurement 802.11k San Antonio 11/15/04 WG Opening Plenary + Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
3
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Meeting Objectives Radio Resource Measurement Whole San Antonio Meeting: LB71 Technical Comment Resolution Letter Ballot Preparation Richard Paine, Boeing
4
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Technical Comment Categories Radio Resource Measurement Security (Paine) Periodic (Kwak) RCPI (Black/Kwak) Histograms (Soomro) TPC (Black) STA (O’Hara/Miles) MIB (Gray) PICS (Black) Hidden (Black) Beacon (Emeott) ANA (Paine) Parallel (Black) QoS (Kwak/Qi) Request/Report (Emeott) Miscellaneous (Emeott) Deferred (Whole Group) Richard Paine, Boeing
5
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Important Documents Radio Resource Measurement LB71 Comment Resolution Spreadsheet (04/0964r22) LB71 Reordered Categories and Numbers for San Antonio (04/1422r0) Richard Paine, Boeing
6
Next Telecom 11/24/04 11/24/04 Meeting: San Antonio Issues
November 2004 Next Telecom 11/24/04 11/24/04 Meeting: San Antonio Issues Editorial Comment Resolution Richard Paine, Boeing
7
802.11k San Antonio Agenda 11/16/04 Tuesday
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Radio Resource Measurement 802.11k San Antonio Agenda 11/16/04 Tuesday + Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
8
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Agenda Radio Resource Measurement Patent Policy Inappropriate Topics Documentation and Presentation Rules Review comment category work progress Resolve issues Richard Paine, Boeing
9
Radio Resource Measurement
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Radio Resource Measurement 6. Patents IEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s), including patent applications, provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder or applicant with respect to patents essential for compliance with both mandatory and optional portions of the standard. This assurance shall be provided without coercion and prior to approval of the standard (or reaffirmation when a patent becomes known after initial approval of the standard). This assurance shall be a letter that is in the form of either a) A general disclaimer to the effect that the patentee will not enforce any of its present or future patent(s) whose use would be required to implement the proposed IEEE standard against any person or entity using the patent(s) to comply with the standard or b) A statement that a license will be made available without compensation or under reasonable rates, with reasonable terms and conditions that are demonstrably free of any unfair discrimination This assurance shall apply, at a minimum, from the date of the standard's approval to the date of the standard's withdrawal and is irrevocable during that period. Approved by IEEE-SA Standards Board – December 2002 Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
10
Inappropriate Topics for IEEE WG Meetings Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Inappropriate Topics for IEEE WG Meetings Radio Resource Measurement Don’t discuss licensing terms or conditions Don’t discuss product pricing, territorial restrictions or market share Don’t discuss ongoing litigation or threatened litigation Don’t be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed… do formally object. If you have questions, contact the IEEE Patent Committee Administrator at Approved by IEEE-SA Standards Board – December 2002 Richard Paine, Boeing
11
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Documentation Radio Resource Measurement Documents must be on the server before presenting Word document with changes to D1.0 + Powerpoint to present Them + Powerpoint with motion to instruct the editor Richard Paine, Boeing
12
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Meeting Objectives Radio Resource Measurement Whole San Antonio Meeting: Validate Seattle Ad Hoc Work LB71 Technical Comment Resolution Preparation for Letter Ballot Richard Paine, Boeing
13
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 San Antonio Work Radio Resource Measurement Comment Incorporation into new draft (D2.0) Technical Comment Resolution Next major milestone: Letter Ballot Richard Paine, Boeing
14
November 2004 Richard Paine, Boeing
15
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Work Approach Radio Resource Measurement 25% Simple Answers do those as you process them – Summarize them Some take more time and thought, but can go in category submission 25% Will need to go before the group as controversial Richard Paine, Boeing
16
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Motion to Approve Minutes of Seattle Ad Hoc 2 and Berlin to San Antonio Meeting Move to accept the minutes of the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 (04/1200r3) and minutes of Berlin to San Antonio Teleconferences in documents 04/1187r0, 04/1188r0, 04/1189r0, 04/1398r0, 04/1399r0, and 04/1401r0. Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
17
November 2004 Motion to Approve Accepted/Declined Editorial Comments of Berlin-San Antonio Teleconferences Move to accept the “Accepted” and “Declined” Editorial Comments of the Berlin-San Antonio teleconferences as documented in the approved minutes in 04/1187r0, 04/1188r0, 04/1189r0, 04/1398r0, 04/1399r0, and 04/1401r0. Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
18
Motion to Approve Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Work
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 “accepted” and “declined” comments in document 04/0964r22 and documented in 04/1429r1 (submitted 11/15/04). Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
19
Motion to Mark Accepted LB71 Comments as Editor to Do
November 2004 Motion to Mark Accepted LB71 Comments as Editor to Do Move to allow the chair to mark all the “accepted” comments in document 04/0964r22 as “editor to do”. Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
20
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Technical Comment Categories Radio Resource Measurement Security – Paine (Security) Neighbor Report/Capability Bits/Channel Report/Powersave – O’Hara (Neighbor) Request/Report/Parallel + Randomization Interval – Black (Parallel) Periodic – Kwak (Periodic) RCPI (11g) – Kwak (RCPI) paper on RCPI Subcategories, submission from Joe Noise Histogram – Amjad Soomro (Noise) – defining measurement (not RPI) TPC – Klein (TPC) gave inputs to Simon Barber, working on submission for Thu STA – Myles & O’Hara (STA) MIB – Gray (MIB) PICS – Black (PICS) Editorial – Teleconferences (Editorial) Hidden Node – Black (Hidden) ANA – Paine (ANA) Signal Quality – Kwak and Qi (QoS) Miscellaneous – Emeott (Misc) Sensing Time Histogram/bin duration+bin offset – Soomro (Medsense) Beacon Request – Emeott (Beacon) Richard Paine, Boeing
21
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Presentations Radio Resource Measurement 04/1440r0 Joe Kwak 04/1390r0 Joe Kwak 04/1439r0 Joe Kwak 04/1213r0 Stephen Wang 04/1410r0 Floyd Simpson 04/1409r0 Floyd Simpson 04/1403r0 Stephen Wang 04/1379r0 Stephen Wang 04/1207r0 Simon Black 04/1208r0 Simon Black 04/1206r0 Simon Black 04/1425r0 Steve Emeott 04/1204r2 Emily Qui 04/1436r0 Mike Moreton Wed Afternoon Richard Paine, Boeing
22
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Presentations (contd) Radio Resource Measurement 04/1387r0 Dirk Kuijsten Wed pm Richard Paine, Boeing
23
Motion to Approve Seattle Periodic Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Periodic Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Periodic “accepted” and “declined” comments in document 04/0964r22 and documented in 04/1429r1 (64,86,120,121,122,376,400,440,441,442,447,441,450,451,452,453,467,474,475,477,479,994). Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
24
Motion to Approve Seattle Hidden Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Hidden Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Hidden “accepted” comments (149,256,356,402,483,602600,603,608,610,612,1010) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
25
Motion to Approve Seattle Neighbor Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Neighbor Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Neighbor “accepted” comments (162,163,164,167,168,169,170,171,239,243,246,248,253,254,255,286,368,663,665,666,674,675,677,678,681,682,685,690,693,703,705,735,736,738,739,743,750,752,753,751,756,769,770,771,773,796,812,813,817,911,914,1035) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
26
Motion to Approve Seattle RCPI Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle RCPI Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 RCPI “accepted” comments (21,180,183,197,203,207,215,216,231,375,448,492,555,563,627,783,935,997) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
27
Motion to Approve Seattle Misc Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Misc Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Misc “accepted” comments (293,313,314,315,330,340,344,342,352,353,355,374,605,606,609,613,776,779,780,946,) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
28
Motion to Approve Seattle Security Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Security Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Security “accepted” comments (717,718,912,922,930,1014,1020) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
29
Motion to Approve Seattle PICS Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle PICS Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 PICS “accepted” comments (830,832,834,835,836,839,838,840,841,842,843,844,846,847,856,851,855,853) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
30
Motion to Approve Seattle Neighbor Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Neighbor Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to decline the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Neighbor “declined” comments (668,684,687,686,709,710,713,719,720,721,747,748,755,800,801,805,806,811,814,923,931,952,) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
31
Motion to Approve Seattle Security Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Security Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to approve the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Security “declined” comments (714) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
32
Motion to Approve Seattle Miscellaneous Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Miscellaneous Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to decline the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Misc “declined” comments (288,323,329,341,849,902,903,904,907,909,910,920,956,963,966) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
33
Motion to Approve Seattle PICS Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle PICS Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to decline the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 PICS “declined” comments (830,837) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
34
Motion to Approve Seattle Editorial Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Editorial Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to decline the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Editorial “declined” comments (328,482) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
35
Motion to Approve Seattle STA Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle STA Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to decline the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 STA “declined” comments (54) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
36
Motion to Approve Seattle Neighbor Ad Hoc 2 Work
November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Neighbor Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to decline the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Neighbor “declined” comments (668,684,687,686,709,710,713,719,720,721,747,748,755,800,801,805,806,811,814,923,931,952,) Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
37
802.11k San Antonio Agenda Wed 11/17/04
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Radio Resource Measurement 802.11k San Antonio Agenda Wed 11/17/04 Sign In + Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
38
November 2004 Richard Paine, Boeing
39
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Agenda 11/17/04 Radio Resource Measurement Technical Comment Review Richard Paine, Boeing
40
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Presentations Radio Resource Measurement 04/1440r0 Joe Kwak 04/1390r0 Joe Kwak 04/1439r0 Joe Kwak 04/1213r0 Stephen Wang 04/1410r0 Floyd Simpson 04/1409r0 Floyd Simpson 04/1403r0 Stephen Wang 04/1379r0 Stephen Wang 04/1207r0 Simon Black 04/1208r0 Simon Black 04/1206r0 Simon Black 04/1204r2 Emily Qui Floyd Vote Richard Paine, Boeing
41
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Presentations (contd) Radio Resource Measurement Vote on Approval of Seattle Work 04/1425r0 Steve Emeott 04/1390r1 Joe Kwak 04/1436r0 Mike Moreton Wed Afternoon 04/1387r0 Dirk Kuijsten Wed pm Richard Paine, Boeing
42
Motion to Approve Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Work
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Motion to Approve Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Work Move to accept the Seattle Ad Hoc 2 “accepted” and “declined” comments in document 04/0964r24 and documented in 04/1429r3 (submitted 11/17/04, 9:30am). Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
43
Motion to Mark Accepted LB71 Comments as Editor to Do
November 2004 Motion to Mark Accepted LB71 Comments as Editor to Do Move to allow the chair to mark all the “accepted” comments in document 04/0964r24 as “editor to do”. Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
44
Radio Resource Measurement
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Radio Resource Measurement 802.11k San Antonio Agenda 11/18/04 Sign In + Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
45
November 2004 Richard Paine, Boeing
46
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 San Antonio Agenda 11/18/04 Radio Resource Measurement Fix 1194r0 beacon report before deferred Deferred Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Tech Comment Resolution Technical Comment Resolution Motions for Working Group Richard Paine, Boeing
47
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Presentations Radio Resource Measurement 04/1440r0 Joe Kwak 04/1390r0 Joe Kwak 04/1439r0 Joe Kwak 04/1213r0 Stephen Wang 04/1410r0 Floyd Simpson 04/1409r0 Floyd Simpson 04/1403r0 Stephen Wang 04/1379r0 Stephen Wang 04/1207r0 Simon Black 04/1208r0 Simon Black 04/1206r0 Simon Black 04/1204r2 Emily Qui Floyd Vote Richard Paine, Boeing
48
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Presentations (contd) Radio Resource Measurement Vote on Approval of Seattle Work 04/1425r0 Steve Emeott 04/1436r0 Mike Moreton Wed Afternoon 04/1390r1 Joe Kwak 04/1387r0 Dirk Kuijsten Wed pm John Klein Presentation on Comment Resolution (04/1508r0) Joe Kwak (04/1440r1) Floyd Simpson Vote (04/1409r0) Steve Emeott - Process beacon report comments Deferred Seattle Ad Hoc 2 Comments (04/1494r0) 5:30pm Motion on marking “Accepted” Comments as Editor-to-Do Motions for Working Group Richard Paine, Boeing
49
November 2004 Motion to Approve Accepted/Declined Editorial Comments of Berlin-San Antonio Teleconferences Move to accept the “Accepted” and “Declined” Editorial Comments of the Berlin-San Antonio teleconferences as documented in the approved minutes in 04/1187r0, 04/1188r0, 04/1189r0, 04/1398r0, 04/1399r0, and 04/1401r0. Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
50
Motion to Mark Accepted LB71 Comments as Editor to Do
November 2004 Motion to Mark Accepted LB71 Comments as Editor to Do Move to allow the chair to mark all the “accepted” comments in document 04/0964r24 as “editor to do”. Moved by: Seconded: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
51
Empowerment for Ad Hoc Meeting
November 2004 Empowerment for Ad Hoc Meeting Move to request the Working Group to empower TGk to hold an ad hoc meeting in Seattle the week of 1/4 as required to conduct business necessary to progress the Letter Ballot 71 comment resolution process, including creating drafts for Letter Ballot, conducting teleconferences, and handling other business necessary to progress through the IEEE standards process. TGk Movers: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
52
Empowerment for Teleconferences
November 2004 Empowerment for Teleconferences Move to request the Working Group to empower TGk to hold weekly teleconferences (Wednesdays at 11:30am Eastern time) through 2 weeks after the Atlanta plenary as required to conduct business necessary to progress the Letter Ballot process, including creating and issuing drafts for Letter Ballots and handling other business necessary to progress through the IEEE standards process. TGk Movers: Result: X/X/X Richard Paine, Boeing
53
Radio Resource Measurement
August 2002 doc.: IEEE /506r0 November 2004 Radio Resource Measurement 802.11k San Antonio 11/19/04 WG Closing Plenary + Richard Paine, Boeing Richard Paine, Boeing
54
802.11k San Antonio Closing Plenary Report
November 2004 802.11k San Antonio Closing Plenary Report Richard Paine Richard Paine, Boeing
55
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Meeting Objectives Radio Resource Measurement Whole San Antonio Meeting: LB71 Technical Comment Resolution Letter Ballot Preparation Richard Paine, Boeing
56
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Meeting Objectives Met Radio Resource Measurement Whole San Antonio Meeting: LB71 Technical Comment Resolution Votes on Comment Resolutions Richard Paine, Boeing
57
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 LB71 Technical Issues Radio Resource Measurement Neighbor TSF Offset Histograms No ACK Report Request/Report Richard Paine, Boeing
58
Radio Resource Measurement
November 2004 Accomplishments Radio Resource Measurement 26 Technical Comment Presentations 3 Technical Presentations 180 Editorial Comments Approved that were Resolved by Teleconferences 204 Technical Comments Approved that were Resolved by Seattle Ad Hoc 2 San Antonio LB71 Comment Resolution (142 Technical Comments) Richard Paine, Boeing
59
Objectives for Jan 2005 Interim
November 2004 Objectives for Jan 2005 Interim Letter Ballot Objectives for Mar 2004 Letter Ballot Comment Resolution and Recirc Richard Paine, Boeing
60
November 2004 Plans Plan until next meeting: Weekly Teleconferences on Wed 11:30am Eastern Time starting on 11/24/04 Plan for start of next meeting: Letter Ballot Comment Resolution and Draft 2.0 Preparation Next major milestone: Letter Ballot Richard Paine, Boeing
61
Next Telecom 11/24/04 11/24/04 Meeting: Editorial Comment Resolution
November 2004 Next Telecom 11/24/04 11/24/04 Meeting: Editorial Comment Resolution Richard Paine, Boeing
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.