1. doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0 Date: 2017-11-06
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
TGax Editor’s Report
Date:
Authors:
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

2. Abstract Current status of comment resolution on the TGax draft
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
Abstract
Current status of comment resolution on the TGax draft
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

3. Draft history November 2017 Draft Page Count Release Date
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
Draft history
Draft
Page Count
Release Date
Approval Rate
Comments
Latest resolution document
D0.1
221
March 2016
1822
15/0535r8
D1.0
453
December 2016
58%
7418
17/0010r14
D2.0
596
October 2017
63%
3350
17/1682r0
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

4. LB230 comment breakdown General: 100 Technical: 2325 Editorial: 878
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
LB230 comment breakdown
General: 100
Technical:
Editorial: 878
Duplicates: 47
Grand total: 3350
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

5. LB230 commenters November 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0 Month Year
Count of CID
Column Labels N
N Total Y
Y Total
Grand Total
Commenter E G T
Mark RISON
134 6
244
384
Liwen Chu 12
198
210
Dorothy Stanley
156
kaiying Lv 20 5 33 58 34 2 53 89
147
Youhan Kim 19
103
122
Adrian Stephens 27 8 35 16 37 25 78
113
Yongho Seok
107
Robert Stacey 11 1 73 85 26
112
Yusuke Tanaka 71 30
101
Alfred Asterjadhi 14 36 50 3 47
100
Albert Petrick 72 24 97
SUNGEUN LEE 18 91 92
Sigurd Schelstraete 23 42 44 45 87
ron porat
yujin noh 54
Tomoko Adachi 29 74 75
James Yee 28 63
Massinissa Lalam 55
Guoqing Li 46 57 59
Abhishek Patil 48
Yasuhiko Inoue 4 7 43
Graham Smith 15
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

6. LB230 commenters November 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0 Month Year
Count of CID
Column Labels N
N Total Y
Y Total
Grand Total
Commenter E G T
Carol Ansley 32 5 2 39
Bin Tian 9 22 31 7 38
Yuichi Morioka 8 16 19 35
Po-Kai Huang 17 33
GEORGE CHERIAN 3 27 30
Woojin Ahn 23
Zhou Lan 1 28 29
Bo Sun 6 13 20 25
Lei Huang 24
Tianyu Wu
Duncan Ho
Laurent Cariou
James Lepp 21
Yanjun Sun
Chunyu Hu
Jarkko Kneckt 11 14
Joseph Levy
Rajesh Kumar
Bibhu Mohanty
Simone Merlin
Qi Xue
EVGENY KHOROV
Hemanth Sampath
Matthew Fischer 15
Peter Loc 4 10 18
Huizhao Wang
Hongyuan Zhang
Patrice Nezou
Osama Aboulmagd
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

7. LB230 commenters November 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0 Month Year
Count of CID
Column Labels N
N Total Y
Y Total
Grand Total
Commenter E G T
Yonggang Fang 1 8 5 2 15 16
Jinsoo Ahn 4 12 3
Roger Marks 14
Pascal VIGER 13
Chao Chun Wang 7
Lochan Verma 11
John Coffey 9
James June Wang 10
Yunbo Li
Qingjiang Tian
Jerome Vanthournout 6
Mark Hamilton
Geonjung Ko
Xiaofei Wang
Kazuyuki Sakoda
Kiseon Ryu
Fei Tong
Jianhan Liu
Sameer Vermani
Jing Ma
Jae Seung Lee
Jinjing Jiang
Xiaogang Chen
Stephen McCann
Vincent Knowles IV Jones
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

8. LB230 commenters November 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0 Month Year
Count of CID
Column Labels N
N Total Y
Y Total
Grand Total
Commenter E G T
Ming Gan 1 3 4
Michael Montemurro
Geert Awater
Yan Zhang
Kazuto Yano
Jeongki Kim
Li-Hsiang Sun 2
Naveen Kakani
Ian Sherlock
Andrew Myles
Shimi Shilo
Eugene Baik
Rojan Chitrakar
Zhigang Rong
Yuchen Guo
stephane baron
Yanchun Li
Zhiyong Huang
Erik Lindskog
Jian Yu
Xiayu Zheng
Jia Jia
Allert Van Zelst
Rui Cao
Chittabrata Ghosh
Richard Van Nee
xun yang
552 29
914
1495
340 72
1443
1855
3350
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

9. Comment resolution process
November 2017
Comment resolution process
Identify high level comment groups
Assign each comment group to a lead individual
Comment group lead can further subdivide and assign individual comments
Comment group lead is responsible for coordinating activity
Ensure that all comments are addressed
Address overlap with other topics
Each comment group is assigned to an ad-hoc where the resolutions for that group are discussed
We may want to load balance across the ad-hocs
Robert Stacey, Intel

10. PHY ad-hoc comment groups
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
PHY ad-hoc comment groups
Comment group
Clauses
Assignee
Introduction
28.1,
Lochan
MU and OFDMA overview
28.3.2,
Youhan
SU and MU beamforming overview
PPDU formats (including NDP formats)
28.3.4, ,
Tianyu
Transmit block diagrams and encoding procedure
28.3.5,
Feng
Transmit and receive specs
Jianhan
Transmit and receive procedures
Xiaogang Chen?
MCS overview and tables
28.3.7, 28.5
Bin
Mathematical description (including all fields)
, 28.{10,11,12}
Hongyuan
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

11. PHY ad-hoc comment groups
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
PHY ad-hoc comment groups
Comment group
Clauses
Assignee
HE-SIG-A subfields
Lochan
HE-SIG-B encoding, mapping, subfields
PHY SAP (including VECTOR tables)
8, 28.2, 28.4 Bo
Preamble
Jianhan
Data field
Hongyuan
Packet extension
Youhan
TXTIME
28.4.3
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

12. MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups
Comment group
Clauses
Assignee
Sounding protocol and frame formats
, 27.6
Alfred
Fragmentation
10.5, 27.3
Ming Gan
Acknowledgement procedures
10.24, 27.4, 9
George Cherian
A-MPDU content (includes multi-TID)
9.7.3, 10.13, 27.5,
Liwen Chu
NAV (including TXOP_DURATION)
27.2.2, , , , 9.2.5,
Po-Kai Huang
Duration-based RTS/CTS
27.2.1
Yongho Seok
MU-RTS/CTS
27.2.5, 17
EDCA (including MU EDCA)
10.22,
Laurent Cariou
TWT operation
, , 10.43, 27.7
Matt Fischer
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

13. MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups
Comment group
Clauses
Assignee
Operating mode (OMI and OMN)
27.8
Guoqing Li
Queue size and BSR operation
, , ,
Zhou Lan
BQR operation ,
Spatial reuse operation
, , 27.9
Matthew Fischer
UL OFDMA random access operation
27.5.5,
Chitto Ghosh
Reverse direction protocol
10.28
Jarkko
NDP feedback operation ,
Laurent Cariou
(fast) Link adaptation
, 27.13
Frank Hsu
HE BSS operation (including BSS color)
, , 27.16, 27.17
Alfred
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company

14. MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups
Month Year
doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0
November 2017
MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups
Comment group
Clauses
Assignee
PICS
Annex B
Edward Au
MIB
Annex C
General and MAC services
4, 5, 27.1
Guoqing Li
MLME SAP 6
Jae Seung
Multi-BSS ,
Abhishek
Power management
11.2, 27.14
MU operation
27.5
PPDU format and multirate
27.15, 10.7
Alfred
DFS operation ,
Youhan
Robert Stacey, Intel
John Doe, Some Company