Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
TOWARDS COMMUNITY DISASTER RESILIENCE REDUCING THE POTENTIAL FOR A “KNOCK OUT DISASTER”
More lectures at Disasters Supercourse - Walter Hays, Global Alliance for Disaster Reduction, Vienna, Virginia, USA
2
CREATING A COMMON AGENDA
3
EVERY TIME ANOTHER DISASTER OCCURS, WE’RE ARE WRITING THE NEXT CHAPTER IN THE “GLOBAL BOOK OF KNOWLEDGE” ON DISASTER RESILIENCE
4
KNOWLEDGE - Perspectives
BOOK OF KNOWLEDGE Perspectives On Science, Policy, And Change
5
EDUCATION FOR DISASTER RESILIENCE
REGIONAL BLUEPRINTS PACIFIC EUROPE ASIA LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN SUB-SAHARA AFRICA MEDITERRANEAN NORTH AMERICA TOPICAL BLUEPRINTS BLUEPRINTS FOR LIVING WITH … BLUEPRINTS FOR BUILDING TO WITHSTAND… BLUEPRINTS FOR LEARNING FROM… BLUEPRINTS FOR IMPLEMENTATION...
6
EDUCATION FOR DISASTER RESILIENCE
KNOWLEDGE MUNICH RE ANNUAL REPORTS, “TOPICS” PROCEEDINGS OF WCDR, JANUARY 2005 PROCEEDINGS OF INCEED, JULY 2005 PROCEEDINGS OF DAVOS, 2006, 2008, 2012 EDUCATION INTEGRATED CURRICULA GENERIC MODELS MODELS FOR SPECIFIC LOCATIONS MODELS FOR SPECIFIC HAZARDS TRAINING
7
TOWARDS GLOBAL DISASTER RESILIENCE
GOAL: TO FIND THE COMMON AGENDA (CA) OF TECHNICAL AND POLITICAL SOLUTIONS POLITICAL SOLUTIONS TECHNICAL SOLUTIONS CA
8
TOWARDS GLOBAL DISASTER RESILIENCE
FACT: THE COMMON AGENDA IS BASED ON EACH COMMUNITY’S STAPLE FACTORS POLITICAL SOLUTIONS TECHNICAL SOLUTIONS STAPLE FACTORS P T S O CA
9
ELEMENTS OF RISK IN EVERY COMMUNITY
HAZARDS EXPOSURE RISK VULNERABILITY LOCATION
10
HAZARDS, EXPOSURE, VULNERABILITY AND RISK DIFFER IN EVERY COMMUNITY
11
SO DO THE THE STAPLE FACTORS, WHICH VARY WITH
TIME PLACE CIRCUMSTANCES
12
SOCIAL (ARE THE PEOPLE AWARE OF WHAT THEY NEED?)
SOCIAL SYSTEMS SOCIAL (ARE THE PEOPLE AWARE OF WHAT THEY NEED?) TECHNICAL (IS THE STATE OF KNOWLEDGE AND PRACTICE BEING APPLIED?) ADMINISTRATIVE (WHO IS RESPONSIBLE AND ACCOUNTABLE?) POLITICAL (ARE PUBLIC POLICIES RELEVANT IN TERMS OF THE THREAT?) COMMUNITY STAPLE FACTORS LEGAL (ARE EXISTIN LEGAL MANDATES ENFORCED?) ECONOMIC (WILLINGNESS AND CAPACITY TO PAY FOR SAFETY?) GOAL: COMMUNITY DISASTER RESILIENCE
13
TOWARDS GLOBAL DISASTER RESILIENCE
GOAL: TO UNDERSTAND THE DIFFERENCES IN TECHNICAL AND POLITICAL THINKING POLITICAL SOLUTIONS TECHNICAL SOLUTIONS CA
14
DIFFERENCES IN PERSPECTIVES OF POLITICAL AND TECHNICAL PROFESSIONALS
BASED ON “NOT WELL ADVISED,” SZANTON (1981)
15
POLITICAL VERSUS TECHNICAL
THE GUIDING PRINCIPLE FOR THE POLITICAL DECISION IS TO HAVE THE “LEAST REGRETS” TECHNICAL THE GUIDING PRINCIPLE FOR THE TECHNICAL DECISION IS TO HAVE THE “BEST SCIENCE”
16
POLITICAL VERSUS TECHNICAL
THE DESIRED OUTCOME IS APPROVAL OF THE DECISIONMAKER’S CONSTITUENTS (ELECTORATE, STOCK HOLDERS) TECHNICAL THE DESIRED OUTCOME IS RESPECT OF THE SCIENTIST’S OR ENGINEER’S PEERS
17
POLITICAL VERSUS TECHNICAL
THE TIME HORIZON IS SHORT AND A SOLUTION IS WANTED NOW TECHNICAL THE TIME HORIZON IS LONG AND “THE SOLUTION” TAKES A LITTLE MORE TIME
18
POLITICAL VERSUS TECHNICAL
THE MOST VALUED OUTCOME IS A RELIABLE SOLUTION WITH UNCERTAINTIES SUBMERGED TECHNICAL THE MOST VALUED OUTCOME IS SCIENTIFIC INSIGHT WITH UNCERTAINTIES EMPHASIZED
19
MYTH VERSUS REALITY MYTH
IN EVERY COMMUNITY, THERE IS A GENERAL PUBLIC, WHICH HAS A COMMON PERCEPTION OF THE PROBLEM REALITY IN EVERY COMMUNITY, THERE ARE MANY PUBLICS, WHICH HAVE DIFFERENT PERCEPTIONS OF THE PROBLEM
20
MYTH VERSUS REALITY MYTH
ING A REPORT IS EFFECTIVE IN INFLUENCING THE COMMUNITY’S PUBLICS AND THE POLITICAL PROCESS REALITY ING A REPORT IS INEFFECTIVE IN INFLUENCING THE COMMUNITY’S PUBLICS AND THE POLITICAL PROCESS
21
MYTH VERSUS REALITY MYTH
FOR A SCIENTIFIC DECISION, SCIENTIFIC CONSENSUS IS A NECESSARY AND SUFFICIENT CONSIDERATION REALITY FOR A POLITICAL DECISION, SCIENTIFIC CONSENSUS IS ONLY ONE OF AT LEAST SIX CONSIDERATIONS
22
DECISIONS FOR DISASTER RESILIENCE
INTEGRATE THE STAPLE FACTORS BALANCE THE COMMUNITY’S STAPLE FACTORS DETERMINE BENEFIT/COST
23
RESULTS OF A COMMON AGENDA FOR DISASTER RESILIENCE
REDUCTION OF VULNERABILITY REDUCTION OF UNACCEPTABLE RISK NO “KNOCK OUT DISASTERS” POLITICAL ENABLEMENT ENHANCED TECHNICAL CAPACITY
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.