1. CHAPTER 6 Lightning, Protection & Insulation Coordination
LIGHTNING PHENOMENA
STROKE FORMATION
LIGHTNING PARAMETER
EMPIRICAL DESIGN METHODS
ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL (EGM)
INSULATION LEVEL

2. Lightning Phenomena
Lightning require the formation of certain type of clouds to be presence in their generation.
This type of clouds is known as cumulonimbus clouds more specifically is the lightning generating type.

3. Lightning Phenomena
Based on Ice Splinter Theory, moistures in the atmosphere combining with precipitating particles which are suspended in air are force higher up into the altitude by updraft.
Every km going higher up in altitude there is decreased about 0.4oC.
So the moistures experienced super cooling and formed crystalline ice with double layered ice structures.
During the process of super cooling, H2O undergo ionization break up into anions (H+) and cations (OH-).
The existences of temperature gradient in the super cooling moisture structure allowing the migration of H+ ions and OH- ions.
However due to lighter weight of H+ ions they become more mobile allowing them to move towards the outer shell, leaving the heavier ions OH- in the inner shell of the ice structures

4. Lightning Phenomena
Figure (a) show the physical relationship of moisture, precipitating particle with the updraft pushing the matters mentioned high in the latitude

5. Lightning Phenomena
Figure (b) show the formation of ice crystal with two-layered structure of positively charged externally and negative charged internally

6. Lightning Phenomena
Figure (c) : Splintering process of the ice crystal to form minute splinters pushing the positive charged splinters higher up in the altitude

7. Lightning Phenomena
Figure d shows the lower part of a thundercloud is usually negatively charged. The upper portion area is usually positively charged. Lightning from the negatively charged area of the cloud generally carries a negative charge to Earth and is called a negative flash. A discharge from a positively-charged area to Earth produces a positive flash

8. Stroke Formation
There are a number of different types of lightning strokes.
These include strokes within clouds, strokes between separate clouds, strokes to tall structures, and strokes that terminate on the ground.
The positive and negative strokes terminating on the ground are the types of most interest in designing shielding systems.

9. Stroke Formation Stepped Leaders
The actual stroke development occurs in a two-step process.
The first step is ionization of the air surrounding the charge center and the development of stepped leaders which propagate charge from the cloud into the air.
Current magnitudes associated with stepped leaders are small (in the order of 100 A) in comparison with the final stroke current.
The stepped leaders progress in a random direction in discrete steps from 10 to 80 m in length.

10. Stroke Formation

11. Stroke Formation Return Stroke
The second step in the development of a lightning stroke is the return stroke.
The return stroke is the extremely bright streamer that propagates upward from the earth to the cloud following the same path as the main channel of the downward stepped leader.
This return stroke is the actual flow of stroke current that has a median value of about A .
The velocity of the return stroke propagation is about 10% the speed of light.

12. Stroke Formation

13. Lightning Parameters
Strike distance
Stroke current magnitude
Keraunic Level
Ground Flash Density

14. Correlations between Return stroke current magnitude and strike distance
Return stroke current magnitude and strike distance (length of the last stepped leader) are interrelated. A number of equations have been proposed for determining the striking distance.
S is the strike distance to ground in (m)
I is the return stroke current in (kA)
The equation stroke current,

15. Keraunic Level
Keraunic level is defined as the average number of thunderstorm days or hours for a given locality.
A daily keraunic level is called a thunderstorm-day and is the average number of days per year on which thunder will be heard during a 24 hours period.
The average annual keraunic level for locations can be determined by referring to keraunic maps.

16. Annual frequency of thunderstorm days in the world

17. Ground Flash Density
Ground flash density (GFD) is defined as the average number of strokes per unit area per unit time at a particular location.
It is usually assumed that the GFD to earth, a substation, or a transmission or distribution line is roughly proportional to the keraunic level at the locality.

18. Ground Flash Density
If thunderstorm days are to be used as a basis, it is suggested that the following equation be used:-
Where
Nk is the number of flashes to earth per square kilometer per year
Nm is the number of flashes to earth per square mile per year
Td is the average annual keraunic level, thunderstorm days

19. The mapping of the lightning ground flash density of Peninsula Malaysia(courtesy of TNBR)

20. EMPIRICAL DESIGN METHODS
Two classical design methods have historically been employed to protect substations form direct lightning strokes:-
Fixed angles
Empirical curves
The two methods have generally provided acceptable protection

21. Fixed Angles
The fixed-angle design method uses vertical angles to determine:-
the number
position
height of shielding wires or masts
The angles used are determined by:-
the degree of lightning exposure
the importance of the substation being protected
the physical area occupied by the substation
The value of the angle alpha that is commonly used is 45°. Both 30° and 45° are widely used for angle beta.

22. Fixed angles for shielding wires

23. Fixed Angles
Fixed angles for mast

24. Empirical curves
From field studies of lightning and laboratory model tests, empirical curves have been developed to determine number, position, and height of shielding wires and masts (Wagner et al., 1941; Wagner, 1942; Wagner, McCann, Beck, 1941).
The curves were developed for shielding failure rates of 0.1, 1.0, 5.0, 10, and 15%.
A failure rate of 0.1% is commonly used in design.
The empirical curve method has also been referred to as the Wagner method.

25. Figure (a)
Figure (b)
Figure (a) Single lightning mast protecting single ring of object — 0.1% exposure. Height of mast above protected object, y, as a function of horizontal separation, x , and height of protected object, d . Figure (b) Two lightning masts protecting single object, no overlap — 0.1% exposure. Height of mast above protected object, y , as a function of horizontal separation, s , and height of protected object, d.

26. Empirical curves Areas Protected by Lightning Masts
If two masts are used to protect an area, the data derived from the empirical curves give shielding information only for the point B, midway between the two masts, and for points on the semicircles drawn about the masts, with radius x, as shown in Figure a.
The locus drawn by the semicircles around the masts, with radius x, and connecting the point B, represents an approximate limit for a selected exposure rate.
Any single point falling within the crosshatched area should have <0.1% exposure.
Points outside the cross-hatched area will have >0.1% exposure.
Figure b illustrates this phenomenon for four masts spaced at the distance s as in Figure a.

27. Figure a
Figure b
Areas protected by multiple masts for point exposures shown in Figure a with two lightning masts, Figure b with four lightning masts.

28. Empirical curves
The protected area can be improved by moving the masts closer together, as illustrated in figure below.
The protected areas are, at least, as good as the combined areas obtained by superimposing those of the previous figure .
The distance s′ is one half the distance s in the previous figure.
The size of the areas with an exposure greater than 0.1% has been significantly reduced.

29. Figure a
Figure b
Areas protected by multiple masts for point exposures shown in Figure a with two lightning masts, Figure b with four lightning masts with the distance s′ is one half the distance s in the previous figure.

30. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL (EGM)
Shielding systems developed using fixed angles and empirical curves of determining the necessary shielding for direct stroke protection of substations have historically provided a fair degree of protection.
However, as voltage levels (and therefore structure and conductor heights) have increased over the years, the classical methods of shielding design have proven less adequate.
This led to the development of the electrogeometric model.

31. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL(EGM)
Striking Distances To A Mast/Shield Wire
Where
Sm is the strike distance in meters
Sf is the strike distance in feet
I is the return stroke current in kiloamperes
K is a coefficient to account for different striking distances to a mast, a shield wire, or the ground plane

32. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL(EGM)
Mousa (1988) gives a value of k = 1 for strokes to wires or the ground plane and a value of k = 1.2 for strokes to a lightning mast.
The EGM theory shows that the protective area of a shield wire or mast depends on the amplitude of the stroke current.

33. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL(EGM)
Allowable Stroke Current
Bus insulators are usually selected to withstand a basic lightning impulse level (BIL).
Insulators may also be chosen according to other electrical characteristics, including negative polarity impulse critical flashover (CFO) voltage.
Flashover occurs if the voltage produced by lightning stroke current flowing through the surge impedance of the station bus exceeds the withstand value.

34. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL(EGM)
Where
IS is the allowable stroke current (kA)
BIL is the Basic lightning Impulse Level (kV)
CFO is critical flashover voltage of the insulation being considered (kV)
ZS is the surge impedance of the conductor through which the surge is phasing (ohm)
is the factor to account for the reduction of stroke current terminating on a conductor as compared to zero impedance earth

35. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL(EGM)
Application Of The EGM By The Rolling Sphere Method
Rolling sphere method employs the simplifying assumption that the striking distance to the ground, a mast or a wire are the same.
Use of the rolling sphere method involves rolling an imaginary sphere of radius S over the surface of a substation.
The sphere rolls up and over lightning masts, shield wires, substation fence, and other grounded metallic objects that can provide lightning shielding.
A piece of equipment is said to be protected from a direct stroke if it remains below the curved surface of the sphere.
Equipment that touches the sphere or penetrates its surface is not protected.

36. ELECTROGEOMETRIC MODEL(EGM)
Principle of the rolling sphere method

37. Examples
Determine the allowable stroke current (kA) through a substation equipment BIL of 850 kV, if given surge impedance is 350 ohm.
A 69 kV substation is protected by a lightning mast and has a basic insulation level (BIL) of 350 kV. Calculate the strike distance (Sm) in meters (m) if the surge impedance of the conductor is 300 Ω.

38. Insulation Co-ordination
Introduction
Insulation coordination is the process of coordinating the insulation level of electrical equipment and its associated surge arresters with the expected overvoltage that occur on the power system.
It is selection of suitable insulation levels of various components in any electrical system and their rational arrangement.
Substation equipment require properly applied surge arresters for reliable operation.

39. Insulation Co-ordination
It is required to ensure:-
Insulation shall withstand all normal stresses and majority of abnormal ones
Efficient discharge of over voltages due to internal or external causes
B/D shall be only due to external causes
B/D shall be at such places where least damage is caused
Safety of operating personnel and public
The purpose of insulation coordination is to reduce the risk of insulation failure of key electrical equipment.
The insulation levels of substation equipment should be co- ordinate with the protective levels of the surge arresters and spark gaps.

40. Insulation Level
Insulation Level is defined by the values of test voltages which the insulation of equipment under test must be able to withstand.
Basic Lightning Impulse Insulation Level ( BIL) :
The electrical strength of insulation expressed in terms of the crest value of a standard lightning impulse under standard atmospheric conditions.
Basic Switching Impulse Insulation Level (BSL) :
The electrical strength of insulation expressed in terms of the crest value of a standard switching impulse.
BSL may be expressed as either statistical or conventional.

41. Insulation Level Lightning Impulse Voltage
The BIL of substation apparatus and equipment is verified by applying a standard lightning impulse having a 1.2/50 μs waveshape.
Additional test on some equipment consist of the application of a 1.2/50 μs wave chopped at either 2 or 3 μs.
For example, a circuit breaker must withstand the application of a 1.2/50 μs impulse chopped at 3 μs, having a crest of 1.15 times the BIL and the application of a 1.2/50 μs impulse chopped at 2 μs, having a crest of 1.29 times the BIL.

42. Insulation Level
Busings must withstand the application of 1.2/50 μs impulse, chopped at 3 μs, having a crest of times the BIL.
Test on transformers include a 3 μs chopped wave test at 1.10 times the BIL.
Thus the lightning impulse strength of all insulations is defined by use of the standard lightning impulse waveshape.

43. Standard Lightning Impulse Voltage 1.2/50 us
Lightning impulse voltage Theoretical
Lightning impulse voltage Practical
Standard Lightning Impulse Voltage 1.2/50 us

44. Insulation Level
t1 is the equivalent time to crest based on the time taken to rise 10-90% of the crest.
t2 is the time between the origin of 10 – 90 % virtual front and the point where drops to half value .

45. Insulation Level Insulation Level Of An Equipment
Basic Insulation level is a term which includes the following characteristics of an equipment :-
Power frequency voltage withstand level.
Lightning impulse voltage withstand level.
Switching impulse voltage withstand level.
These withstand levels together characterize the insulation level of a substation equipment.
Each substation equipment has its rated insulation levels.

46. Insulation Level
These are specified in the respective standard of that equipment.
The substation insulation co-ordination is governed by impulse withstand values, lightning voltage withstand levels for voltages up to 220 kV and switching impulse for voltage of 345 kV and above.

47. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
Insulation co-ordination of a substation involves the following :-
To determine the appropriate insulation of transformers and other equipments.
To select the settings of co-ordinating gap.
To select the correct surge arresters at various locations.
Insulation co-ordination consists of steps taken to prevent damage to electrical equipment due to over voltage and to localize the flashovers to discharge over voltage at such points where they will cause minimum damage.

48. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
This is achieved by correlating the insulation strengths of line, switchgear, transformer, machines etc. and the characteristics of the overvoltage protective devices such as rod gaps, surge arresters.
The impulse withstand level of system components and the impulse protective level to protective devices are correlated.
The insulation level of an equipment is expressed in term of curve of the specified impulse wave called impulse withstand level.

49. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
Consider for example at 132 kV incoming line.
Basic insulation level of 550 kV is chosen.
The line insulation can withstand standard impulse wave of 860 kV crest value.
The breakdown voltage of line lightning arrester is 500 kV.
Transformer impulse voltage withstand is 550 kV.
Therefore, a high voltage surge coming from transmission line will be discharge to earth by lightning arrester.
The residual voltage less than breakdown voltage, the transformer insulation is protected.

50. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
The insulation coordination between equipment and a surge arrester

51. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
The following points should kept in mind while co- ordinating the insulation in the substation:-
Surge arrester should have the lower protective level characteristics. The residual voltage should be less than transformer insulation strength.
The voltage time curves of individual components must be taken into account. To withstand voltage characteristic of all the equipments should lie above the protective characteristic of the surge arrester with enough margin.
The insulation co-ordination should be based on worst possible atmospheric condition as regards rain, humidity, pollution etc.
The protective device such as surge arrester should give protection against wave of both polarities.

52. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
Margin Protection
The Margin of Protection (MP) is the difference between arrester discharge characteristics and equipment withstand level, at any given instant of time.
Where:-
BILequip : the BIL of the equipment
Var : the discharge of voltage of arrester
The margin of protection for the equipment protection and should not be less than 0.20 (20%)

53. Insulation co-ordination of a substation
Insulation coordination Between equipment and surge arrester

54. Example
A Substation transformer 66 kV/150 kV, have BIL of 275 kV/ 650 kV. A lightning arrester is installed on transformer terminal of 66 kV, has discharge voltage of 250 kV. Calculate the protection margin in percentage.