1. TGn Closing Report Nov 2004 04/1512 r0
July 2004
doc.: IEEE /0658r0
November 2004
TGn Closing Report Nov /1512 r0
Bruce Kraemer, Chair
Garth Hillman, Secretary
Kraemer, Conexant; Hillman, AMD
Bruce Kraemer, Conexant

2. November Goals Administrative introduction
Review partial proposals and conduct Q&A panel
Submitted questions first
Received one technical paper to facilitate comparison
Review 4 complete proposals and conduct Q&A
More than one round
Hold panel discussion and hear closing remarks
Conduct low hurdle vote – roll call used
Prepare January plans
Kraemer, Conexant; Hillman, AMD

3. Low Hurdle Ballot Results
November 2004
Low Hurdle Ballot Results
Vote Type
Consider
Proposal
MITMOT
Proposal
TGnSync
Proposal
WWiSE
Proposal
Qualcomm
47.4
73.7
64.7
56.8
25% approval level needed to continue
Votes cast : 266
Spreadsheet of detailed results will be posted to private IEEE website in pdf format as soon as possible. Availability will be announced via reflector.
Kraemer, Conexant; Hillman, AMD

4. Plans for January Revised technical presentations posted 2weeks prior
November 2004
Revised technical presentations posted 2weeks prior
Additional written questions posted 1 week prior to meeting
Written answers from authors posted on Friday prior to meeting
Administrative introduction 1 hr
Elect vice chair . 5 hr - 1 hr
Revised technical presentations (2hr block) 1 hr PHY, 1hr MAC
Technical comparison , clarifications, discrepancies
Presentation time, random speaker sequence for each round
Request 20 min for Q&A and/or submit questions via
Revised comparison report ( ) – 1hr
Market/application reports -.5hr
Additional technical presentations 1hr
1st round of Q&A 4 hr
Summary statement 5-10 min
Down select vote - special order or conditional based on adequate discussion
Plans for March
(Elect technical editor when one proposal remains)
Kraemer, Conexant; Hillman, AMD

5. November 2004
End
Kraemer, Conexant; Hillman, AMD