1. HARQ Ad-Hoc Report
IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9)
Document Number:
IEEE C802.16j-07/559
Date Submitted:
Source:
Shashikant Maheshwari Voice:
NSN
Venue:
IEEE Session #52, Atlanta, GA, USA
Base Contribution:
IEEE j /D1
Purpose:
HARQ Ad-Hoc report on comments resolution on remaining HARQ related comments on IEEE j/D1 (80216j-07/45r3)
Notice:
This document does not represent the agreed views of the IEEE Working Group or any of its subgroups. It represents only the views of the participants listed in the “Source(s)” field above. It is offered as a basis for discussion. It is not binding on the contributor(s), who reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release:
The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications thereof, in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication; to copyright in the IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE
Patent Policy:
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE-SA Patent Policy and Procedures:
< and <
Further information is located at < and < >.

2. HARQ Ad-Hoc Report
20 comments were assigned to HARQ Ad-Hoc for comment resolution
Grouped into 6 categories based on relevance of the comments
HARQ issues , 942, 948, 949,
minor editorial/technical -169, 418, 748, 752, 755, 756,
Erroneous tx , 761
HARQ for tunneling -723, 759, 767
HARQ for RS Grouping -731, 753, 768
HARQ for DCH -728, 962
Held two Conference Call
Conference calls notes and proposed resolutions are covered in HARQAhCmts_v2.0.xls (uploaded at )
Proposed resolutions for the comments are included in 27_HARQ_Adhoc.cmtr (uploaded at )
Out of 20 comments, 10 comments are resolved. Proposing following resolution for those comments.
Accept : (1 comment)
Accept-Modify : 418, 748, 752,768, 932 ( 5 comments)
Reject : (1 comment)
Superceded : 731, 753, 761 (3 comments)

3. Plan for resolving remaining comments
10 comments are deferred and still to be resolved in this meeting
HARQ Issue - #942, #948, #949
#948 - C80216j-07/524r1 (from Malaga meeting)
C80216j-07/544r1 and C80216j-07/550 in response to #942 were submitted in HARQ ad-hoc CC
Require further discussion and harmonization between three contributions
Minor Editorial/Technical - #169
C80216j-07/557 was submitted before HARQ ad-hoc CC #2. Author was not present to discuss the contribution
Erroneous tx - #760
Require further discussion between Aik/Ken
HARQ for Tunneling - #723, #759, #767
C80216j-07/403r2 and C80216j-07/489r2 (from Malaga meeting)
C /449 submitted before HARQ ad-hoc CC#2 (response to #723)
Requires further discussion and harmonization
HARQ for DCH - #728, #962
Derek mentioned that harmonization is still ongoing and require more time. Therefore not discussed.

4. Status on remaining comments
10 comments are deferred, 6 comments are resolved in this meeting
HARQ Issue - #942, #948, #949
Propose to accept-modify #948 - C80216j-07/524r1
Supercede 942 and 949
Minor Editorial/Technical - #169
Need discussion at TG level
Erroneous tx - #760
Propose to reject (approved by commenter)
HARQ for Tunneling - #723, #759, #767
Propose to accept-modify #759 (C80216j-07/403r3) and #767 (C80216j-07/489r2 )
Supercede comment #723
HARQ for DCH - #728, #962
Revised contribution was uploaded yerderday evening, first time. Need further discussion. Defer until tomorrow afternoon.