Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byJudith Barker Modified over 6 years ago
1
Forms of Defence automatism mental disorder intoxication
mistake of fact mistake of law self-defence compulsion
2
DEFENCES TO CRIMES 1. Justification 2. Excuse 3. Mitigation
3
JUSTIFICATION Defendant will not be held liable for conduct that is justified Action is permitted for protective reasons
4
JUSTIFICATION Necessity (Not the same defence in the USA)
Self Defence (Must be reasonable force) Defence of Others Prevention of a Crime Defence of Property
5
MITIGATION Heat of Passion (Mitigates murder to lesser charge)
Imperfect Self defence Mistaken Justification Coercion/Duress (Not a defence to murder!) Diminished Capacity
6
EXCUSES TO CRIMINAL CONDUCT
Insanity Diminished Capacity Infancy Intoxication Mistake Duress Consent Entrapment
7
Automatism: A defence based on a claim that one's actions were not voluntary
Examples: Sleepwalking pneumonia Stroke Hypoglycaemia Psychological blows Reflex actions Acid Test: Did one’s body commit the offence independent of their mind.
8
Mental Disorder: A defence based on a claim that one is not capable of appreciating their actions.
Examples: mental disability schizophrenia Acid Test: Did one know that they committed the offence without understanding that it was wrong.
9
Intoxication: A defence based on a claim that one is not capable of appreciating their actions due to momentary intoxication. Examples: alcohol drugs Acid Test: Was one’s ability to appreciate their actions compromised to the point that they were unable to form necessary mens rea.
10
Mistake of Fact: A defence based on a claim that one committed the offence because they mistook a critical fact. Example: Serving alcohol to a minor who provided fake ID Acid Test: Would the person have not committed the offence if they had known the true fact.
11
Mistake of Law: A defence based on a claim that one committed the offence because they did not know that their action was against the law. This is an exception to Section 19 of the Criminal Code (Ignorance of the law is not an excuse). Colour of Right: The offence believed they had a pre-existing right that allowed them to commit the offence. Example: Taking property to which one believed they had a claim. Officially Induced: The accused was informed that the act was not an offence by a representative of the state. Example: Ministry of Transport informed one that they could drive with an expired license.
12
Self Defence: A defence based on a claim that one committed the offence in order to protect themselves, another person, or property. Example: Hitting someone to prevent an attack. Acid Test: Could the person have avoided harm without having resorted to physical violence.
13
Compulsion: A defence based on a claim that one committed the offence in order to avoid harm posed by way of a threat. Example: Stealing money in order to avoid being assaulted. Acid Test: Did the person face imminent harm that could not have otherwise been avoided? Cannot be used as a defence for: murder sexual assault etc. (anything where another life is seen as more valuable that the accused’s life)
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.