1. Project: IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: [WG-TG3 Closing Report Nov02]
Date Submitted: [15November02]
Source: [John Barr] Company [Motorola]
Address [1303 E. Golf Road, Schuamburg, IL 60196]
Voice:[ ], FAX: [ ],
Re: [02424r0P802-15_TG3-November02-Meeting-Objective-and-Agenda.xls]
Abstract: [TG3 Chair Report to WG]
Purpose: [TG3 chair report to WG to update them on work completed in Kauai.]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by
March 2002
doc.: IEEE /096r0
November 2002
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola
John Barr, Motorola

2. IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks
March 2002
doc.: IEEE /096r0
November 2002
802.15
IEEE Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks
TG3 Closing Report
November 2002, Kauai
Hawaii
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola
John Barr, Motorola

3. Agenda Goals of November Meeting Letter Ballot Status
March 2002
doc.: IEEE /096r0
November 2002
Agenda
Goals of November Meeting
Letter Ballot Status
Motion to forward to Sponsor Ballot
Sponsor Ballot Resolution Committee
Goals for January Meeting
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola
John Barr, Motorola

4. Goals of the November Meeting
March 2002
doc.: IEEE /096r0
November 2002
Goals of the November Meeting
Conference call status, including approval of any ad hoc business
LB22 comment resolution
Update draft as required
Prepare for ballot recirculation (if required)
Gain approval to move to sponsor ballot
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola
John Barr, Motorola

5. LB12 Comment Resolution Results
November 2002
LB12 Comment Resolution Results
75 out of 89 voters returned a ballot
41 voted yes (66.1 %)
21 voted no (33.9 %)
4 abstained (6.1 % of total votes)
69 resolved yes (97 %)
2 unsatisfied resolution (2.8 %)
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

6. November 2002
LB12 No Voter Status
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

7. LB17 Comment Resolution Results
November 2002
LB17 Comment Resolution Results
LB17 Ballot - Yes-64/No-9/Abstain-2 – 88%
BRC meeting in Schaumburg, August 6-8
LB17 Passed – 91.2%
Yes-67/No-6/Abstain-2
02273r18 – Comment Resolution Record
02334r7 – Security Comment Resolution Record
Technical – 131
Technical Required - 444
Editorial – 622
02299r17 – WG-LB17 Comment Resolution DBase
D11 Created for Recirculation Ballot (LB19)
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

8. November 2002
LB17 Comment Status
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

9. LB19 Comment Resolution Results
November 2002
LB19 Comment Resolution Results
LB19 Ballot - Yes-66/No-8/Abstain-1 – 89.2%
BRC meeting in San Diego, October 7-9
LB19 Passed – 94.6%
Yes-70/No-4/Abstain-1
02392r16 – Comment Resolution Record
02399r4 – Security Comment Resolution Record
Technical – 72
Technical Required - 326
Editorial – 153
02299r18 – WG-LB18 Comment Resolution DBase
D14 Created for Recirculation Ballot (LB22)
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

10. November 2002
LB19 Comment Status
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

11. LB22 Comment Resolution Results
November 2002
LB22 Comment Resolution Results
LB22 Ballot - Yes-66/No-8/Abstain-1 – 89.2%
Comment Resolution IEEE 802 Hawaii
LB22 Passed – 94.6 %
Yes-70/No-4/Abstain-1
02457r2 – Comment Resolution Record
Technical – 24
Technical Required – 62 (11 + 2(LB19) unsatisfied)
Editorial – 159
02458r5 – WG-LB22 Comment Resolution DBase
D15 Being Prepared for Sponsor Ballot
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

12. November 2002
LB22 Comment Status
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

13. Sponsor Ballot Support
November 2002
Sponsor Ballot Support
Sponsor Ballot Resolution Committee
Chair, James Gilb
Vice Chair, John Barr
Members:
Jim Allen, Allen Heberling, Bill Shvodian, Mark Schrader, Dan Bailey, Rene Struik, Gregg Rasor, Knut Odman, Jay Bain, Jeyhan Karaoguz
Motion Internal – No objections, passed by unanimous consent.
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

14. Motion to the Task Group
November 2002
Motion to the Task Group
Move to seek approval from the WG to seek approval from the SEC to forward IEEE P Draft D15 to Sponsor Ballot.
Mover: James Gilb Second: Al Heberling
No Objections – Passed by unanimous consent.
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

15. Motion to the Working Group
November 2002
Motion to the Working Group
Move to seek approval from the SEC to forward IEEE P Draft D15 to Sponsor Ballot.
Mover: James Gilb Second: John Barr
For – 38
Against – 0
Abstain – 4
Motion Passes
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

16. LB12 – LB22 - Resolution Comparison
November 2002
LB12 – LB22 - Resolution Comparison
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

17. November 2002
Final LB Summary
95% approval on LB22 (D14) with no new no votes and no technical changes to the draft. (Yes 70/No 4/Abstain 1)
84% participation (75 of 89 eligible voters)
13 unsatisfied TR comments from 4 voters
No unsatisfied TR comments from a new voter
Other than power management, all other unsatisfied comments are from a single voter who has not participated in IEEE meetings since January 2002.
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

18. Unsatisfied TRs Mandatory power management (6) (three voters)
November 2002
Unsatisfied TRs
Mandatory power management (6) (three voters)
Single SPS set instead of four. Agree on technical implementation. Disagree on number of supported instances.
Miscellaneous comments from a single voter:
Optional slotted Aloha for MCTAs (2)
Option for efficiency and alternate PHY support
Editorial change of GTS to CTA (1)
Force even byte alignment of IEs in frames (1)
Remove spreading of IEs over multiple beacons (1)
Reduces beacon size during transition periods
Remove ASIE (1)
Make MIFS & SIFS identical (1)
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

19. November 2002
Motion to the SEC
Move to seek approval to forward IEEE P Draft D15 to Sponsor Ballot.
Mover: Bob Heile Second: Stuart Kerry
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

20. November 2002
Goals for January
Conference call status, including approval of any ad hoc business.
Sponsor ballot comment resolution.
Update draft as required.
Approve sponsor ballot recirculation.
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

21. Publicity Committee Input
November 2002
Publicity Committee Input
Final working group letter ballot had 95% approval after comment resolution.
IEEE draft standard approved for sponsor ballot.
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola

22. Over the Edge to Sponsor Ballot
November 2002
Over the Edge to Sponsor Ballot
© William M. Shvodian
Dr. John R. Barr, Motorola