1. Item 11a
Medical Appraisal in Scotland Refresher Course for Experienced Appraisers

2. Introductions ….. Name Specialty
Reflections on your experience of being an appraiser (1 +ve, 1-ve)
Expectations of the course

3. Aims
Encourage appraisers to re-evaluate and refresh their skills in appraising medical colleagues (from a range of specialties):
in the light of feedback they receive on the course
and
their experience of observing other appraisers

4. Aims continued….
Encourage a consistent and high quality approach to medical appraisal across Scotland
Confirm that appraisers are appraising at an appropriate level and, if not, address concerns
Consider what further changes to appraisal may be required as a result of revalidation requirements

5. Programme for the day and working methods
Looking at a range of Supporting Information from different Specialties
Working experientially with the Supporting Info
in trios (& pairs) with a tutor
Working with challenging appraisees with a range of issues in trios (& pairs).
Tutors role playing appraisees
Reviewing videos of your role play appraisals and self critiquing performance

6. Ground rules Confidentiality Feedback Protocol for Managing Concerns
As an observer, as an appraiser, as an appraisee
Protocol for Managing Concerns

7. Video recording The purpose of video recording
Consent, ownership and confidentiality

8. We need your feedback!
We have developed a secure on-line feedback facility
This will activate at 6pm tonight and send you an invite by
Please complete it as part of your post-course reflections within a week of the event

9. Three Roles for a challenging appraisal
Appraiser – begin by exploring the job the appraisee does and then move into issues flagged up in the Scenario
Appraisee – (The tutor) will try to respond naturally to the Appraiser’s interventions
Observer – What works well? What could be done differently?