1. WLTP-24-03e_Appendix 3a
Transposition of GTR15 (WLTP) and GTR19 (Evap) into UN Regulations Update from WLTP Transposition Task Force September 2018

2. WLTP-24-03e Appendix UN Regulation WLTP
This document presents a draft of the potential structure and content of a new UNR WLTP.
Rob Gardner, TRL - September 2018

3. UNR WLTP: Section 1 - Scope
Scope and Application (?) [consider expanding title beyond just “Scope”]
This UN Regulation applies to the type approval of vehicles of categories M1, M2, N1 and N2 with a reference mass not exceeding [2,610 kg] with regard to the WLTP Type 1 test for criteria emissions [or use “emissions of gaseous compounds, particulate matter, particle number”] and to emissions of carbon dioxide and fuel consumption and/or the measurement of electric energy consumption and electric range, to the Type 4 test for Evaporative Emissions and to the Type 5 test for verifying the durability of pollution control devices.
This Regulation does not lay down rules for the Type II test, Type III test, Type VI test, in-service conformity, or On-Board Diagnostic (OBD) systems.
At the manufacturer's request, type approval granted under this Regulation may be extended from vehicles mentioned above to M1, M2, N1 and N2 vehicles with a reference mass not exceeding [2,840 kg] and which meet the conditions laid down in this Regulation.
[Dark red text below is from UNR101]
It does not apply to a category N1 vehicle if both:
(a) The engine type fitted to that type of vehicle has received type approval pursuant to Regulation No. 49, and
(b) The total annual worldwide production of N1 vehicles of the manufacturer is less than 2,000 units.
Equivalent approvals (???)
The following do not need to be approved to this Regulation – vehicles above 2,380 kg to which approvals to UNR 49 have been granted as an extension.

4. UNR WLTP: Section 2 - Definitions
Copy relevant definitions from Section 3 of GTR15 and Section 3 of GTR19
Copy (and amend for UNR) relevant definitions from Article 2 of EU 2017/1151? (Level 1a)
Copy relevant Japan definitions (Level 1b)
Plus other definitions in UNR R83 and UNR R101 that need to be copied

5. UNR WLTP: Section 3 - Application for approval
Copy ‘generic’ UNECE regulatory text from UNR R83 and amend as necessary
Check Article 3 and Article 4 of EU 2017/1151 for any new WLTP specifics that need to be incorporated?
Add equivalent text for Japan

6. UNR WLTP: Section 4 - Approval
Copy ‘generic’ UNECE regulatory text from UNR R83 and amend as necessary
Add equivalent text for Japan
Use this section to provide instructions for TAAs as to how they issue approvals for Level 1a, 1b and 2.
Mention concept of multi-stage approvals?

7. UNR WLTP: Section 5 - Specifications and tests
Introductory text - Copy and amend UNR R83, including information on small volume manufacturers
5.1 General
Incorporate relevant text from Section 5 of GTR15. NB: some is already included in the equivalent UNR R83 text (e.g. fuel inlet orifices and electronic system security).
Incorporate relevant text from Section 5 of GTR19. NB: some is already included in the equivalent UNR R83 text (e.g. security of hoses).
Incorporate amendments in Section 2 of Annex I to EU 2017/1151 (e.g. odometer security)
Add equivalent text for Japan

8. UNR WLTP: Section 5 - Specifications and tests
5.2. Test procedure
Copy and amend UNR R83 text to match requirements of UNR WLTP
Incorporate relevant requirements in Section 2 of Annex I to EU 2017/1151 (Figure I.2.4.) – which provide an update to UNR R83 Table A
Add equivalent text for Japan

9. UNR WLTP: Section 5 - Specifications and tests
5.3. Description of Tests
Add some generic introductory text
Type 1 test
Adapt main body of GTR15 to fit with the format of UNR 83
EU limits for 4 phase WLTC
Japan limits for 3 phase WLTC
Determination of CO2 Emissions And Fuel Consumption from Vehicles Submitted to Multi-stage Type-approval Or Individual Vehicle Approval (?)

10. UNR WLTP: Section 5 - Specifications and tests
5.3. Description of Tests cont.
[Reserved - Placeholder for Type II (2?) test]
[Reserved - Placeholder for Type III (3?) test]
Type IV (4?) test
Adapt main body of GTR19 to fit with the format of UNR 83
Type V (5?) test
Level 1a: Copy and amend UNR R83 section Add text from Annex VII of EU 2017/1151 which recognises the switch from NEDC to WLTP for the Type I/1 test
Level 1b: Japan developing procedure
[Reserved - Placeholder for Type VI (6?) test]

11. UNR WLTP: Section 6 - Modifications of the vehicle type
Level 1a - Copy (and amend for UNR) new extensions requirements from Section 3 to Annex I of EU 2017/1151 that reflect WLTP
Level 1b - Add equivalent text for Japan

12. UNR WLTP: Section 7 - Extensions
Level 1a - Align with EU 2017/1151 as amended by the 2nd Act
Level 1b - Add equivalent text for Japan

13. UNR WLTP: Section 8 - Conformity of production
Level 1a - Interim use of EU 2017/1151 procedure.
Copy (and amend for UNR) new CoP requirements from Section 4 to Annex I of EU 2017/1151, along with the new Appendix 1 and Appendix 2 to replace those currently in UNR R83.
Level 1b – Interim use of Japan procedure
Japan developing CoP Procedure
Level 2 - TBD

14. UNR WLTP: Section 9 – In Service Conformity
In Service Conformity will not be included in UNR WLTP – see UNR83 08 Series.

15. UNR WLTP: Sections
10. Penalties for non-conformity of production
Standard UNR text
By the time that the UNR WLTP is applicable there will be a new EU Type Approval Framework in place. Need to check whether the current UNR83 text would remain applicable.
11. Production definitively discontinued
See Section 10.
12. Transitional provisions
If ‘Approach 1’ or ‘Approach 2’ are used we will need to include Introductory Provisions
13. Names and addresses of Technical Services responsible for conducting approval tests, and of Type Approval Authorities

16. UNR WLTP: Appendix 1 Verification of conformity of production for Type 1 test—statistical method
Level 1a – Align with EU 2017/1151 as amended by the 2nd Act
Level 1b – under development
Level 2 - TBD

17. UNR WLTP: Appendix 2 Calculations for Conformity of Production for EVs
Level 1a – Align with EU 2017/1151 as amended by the 2nd Act
Level 1b – under development
Level 2 - TBD

18. UNR WLTP: Appendix 3 Requirements for vehicles that use a reagent for the exhaust after-treatment system
For UNR WLTP or UNR series? TBD.
Level 1a – Align with EU 2017/1151 as amended by the 2nd Act (same as the UNR series Appendix 6 update)
Level 1b – Currently no requirement in Japan. Can consider but may not be needed in Japan. TBD
Level 2 - TBD
NB: Appendices 3-5 in UNR83 cover In-Service Conformity and have been deleted for UNR WLTP as ISC will be in UNR83 08 series. UNR83 Appendix 6 (SCR) therefore now becomes Appendix 3.
NB2: SCR requirements may be added to GTR15. If that happens then this appendix would be moved to Annexes Part B WLTP.

19. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part A
Annex A1: Engine and vehicle characteristics and information concerning the conduct of tests – this will exclude all the specific ‘non-Type 1/Type 4 info’ that is currently in UNR series (e.g. Section OBD).
NB: there will be a lot of duplication between the information documents for UNR WLTP and UNR83 08 if we take this approach. May need a novel approach.
Appendix 1 - Information on test conditions
Appendix 2 – WLTP Test Report
Appendix 3 – WLTP Road Load Test Report
Appendix 4 – WLTP Test Sheet
Appendix 5 – Evap Test Report

20. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part A cont.
Annex A2: Communication
Addendum to type approval communication No … concerning the type approval of a vehicle with regard to exhaust emissions pursuant to Regulation WLTP xxx series of amendments
Appendix 1 - Amend UNR R83 Annex 2 Communication and Addendum to Type Approval Communication to include the WLTP updates provided in Appendix 4 to Annex I of EU 2017/1151 – Level 1a
Level 1b - TBD
Annex A3: Arrangements of the approval mark

21. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B1: WLTC
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Level 1a – Include extra high phase. Remove GTR15 option to allow exclusion of extra-high phase
Level 1b – Exclude extra high phase
Level 2
4 phase WLTC – EU limits
3 phase WLTC – Japan limits
Annex B2: Gear selection and shift point determination for vehicles equipped with manual transmissions
No variation between Level 1a, Level 1b and Level 2

22. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B3: Reference fuels
Level 1a - Delete GTR15 reference fuels that are not in Annex IX of EU 2017/1151
Level 1b - Amend GTR15 to include the reference fuels for Japan
Level 2 - ‘Most stringent’ reference fuels to be determined.
Diesel reference fuel
Proposal from ACEA
Petrol fuel
JARI study underway. Results expected December 2018

23. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B4: Road load and dynamometer setting
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Level 1a and Level 1b – amend Amend GTR15 para to remove the +5oC option

24. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B5: Test equipment and calibrations
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Delete GTR15 Section 7 (Additional sampling and analysis methods)
Level 1a – include PN measurement requirements
Level 1b – exclude PN measurement requirements
Level 2 – include PN measurement requirements

25. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B6: Type 1 test procedures and test conditions
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Limits:
4 phase WLTC – EU limits
3 phase WLTC – Japan limits
Regional corrections
ATCT and Target speed correction in Level 1a and Level 2 for 4 phase cycle only (not 3 phase cycle)
dCO2 determination
Level 1a: 0.99
Level 1b: 1.0
Level 2: TBD

26. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B6: Type 1 test procedures and test conditions – cont.
Auxiliary devices
Level 1a: Daylight running lamps
Level 1b: N/A
Level 2: TBD
Dual-axis dyno for 4WD vehicles
Level 1a - Include paragraphs to from EU 2017/1151 (as amended)
Level 1b – TBD
Level 2 – TBD
Regenerative factor Ki
Level 1a – include Extra-High
Level 1b – exclude Extra-High
Level 2 - EU accept 3_phase_Ki, and on the other hand, JPN accept 4_phase_Ki

27. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B6: Type 1 test procedures and test conditions – cont.
Ambient Temperature Correction Test
Level 1a – copy EU 2017/1151 Sub-Annex 6a
Level 1b – N/A
Level 2 – ATCT for 4 phases. No ATCT for 3 phases.
Target speed correction
Level 1a – copy EU 2017/1151 Sub-Annex 6b
Level 2 – Correction for 4 phase results. No correction 3 phase results.

28. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B7: Calculations
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Table A7/1 Step 2b Correction of CO2 results against the target speed and distance
Level 1a – copy from EU 2017/1151
Level 1b – N/A
Level 2 - copy from EU 2017/1151 for 4 phase results
Table A7/1 Step 8 Averaging of criteria emissions
Level 1a - EU 2017/1151 "In the case of the combined THC+NOx emissions, the highest value of the sum referring to either the VH or VL is to be used“
Level 2 - Calculate the average. Region can decide whether to use average or individual value. Japan 3-phase, EU 4-phase - allows the option to exist in Level 2 - TBD.

29. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B7: Calculations
Section 7.3 Criteria for drive trace indices
Level 1a – RMSSE threshold 1.3
Level 1b – RMSSE threshold 0.8
Level 2 – TBD
xxx

30. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B8: Pure electric, hybrid electric and compressed hydrogen fuel cell hybrid vehicles
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Phase specific fuel consumption (paragraphs and )
Level 1a – not required
Level 1b – include
Level 2 – CO2/fuel consumption is just performance value, no need to consider stringency”. Include in Level 2.
Electric energy consumption
Level 1a – required
Level 1b – not required
Level 2 - CO2/fuel consumption is just performance value, no need to consider stringency. Include in Level 2

31. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B8: Pure electric, hybrid electric and compressed hydrogen fuel cell hybrid vehicles
Appendix 3 para 1.4 c)
Level 1a – EU 2017/1151 includes ATCT here
Level 1b – N/A
Level 2 – TBD
Appendix 5 Utility Factors
Level 1a – EU UF values
Level 1b – Japan UF values
Level 2 - EU UF values for 4 phases. Japan UF values for 3 phases.
Appendix 6 paras 2.3(d), 3.3(d) & 4.3(d) - Option to replace reference test cycle with applicable WLTP city test cycle.
Level 1a – delete – option not allowed in EU
Level 2 – delete option

32. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B8: Pure electric, hybrid electric and compressed hydrogen fuel cell hybrid vehicles
Appendix 7 - Phase specific fuel consumption (paragraph )
Level 1a – not required
Level 1b – include
Level 2 – CO2/fuel consumption is just performance value, no need to consider stringency”. Include in Level 2.

33. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part B – Type 1 Test (WLTP)
Annex B9: Determination of method equivalency
Base on GTR15 Amendment 5
Same text for Level 1a, Level 1b and Level 2

34. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part C
Annex C1: [Reserved for Type 2 test (?)]
Annex C2: [Reserved for Type 3 test (?)]

35. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part C cont.
Annex C3: Type 4 test - Evaporative emissions
Base on GTR19 Amendment xxx

36. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part C cont.
Annex C4: Type 5 test – Durability
Level 1a – base on EU 2017/1151 as amended
Level 1b – under development
Level 2 - TBD

37. UNR WLTP: Annexes Part C cont.
Annex C5: [Reserved for Type 6 test – Low temperature test]

38. Contact information Rob Gardner, TRL Ltd on behalf of the European Commission (Task Force Leader) Alessandro Marotta, European Commission