Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

The First Fifth-Generation Academic Journal

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "The First Fifth-Generation Academic Journal"— Presentation transcript:

1 The First Fifth-Generation Academic Journal
Newpubli The First Fifth-Generation Academic Journal Newpubli: from New Publication

2 Publisher: Newpubli Corporation
Registration city: Chicago Registration year: 2015

3

4 Five generations of journals
Journal generation Type Open access Article selection criteria (superiors are published and inferiors are rejected ) Article-ranking (superiors and inferiors are clearly differentiated) 1st Printed No Strict 2nd Online 3rd Yes 4th Looser 5th Further looser

5 Five generations of journals
Journal generation Type Open access Article selection criteria (superiors are published and inferiors are rejected ) Article-ranking (superiors and inferiors are clearly differentiated) 1st Printed No Strict 2nd Online 3rd Yes 4th Looser 5th Further looser Newpubli is the first e.g. PLOS One

6 1st – 4th Generations Decision Internal selection per format
Internal selection per value Outside selection via peer review Decision Superior articles are published; inferior articles are rejected

7 5th Generation (Newpubli)
Internal selection per format Decision Preprint publication Value ranking via peer review Superior articles are formally published with high ranks, and inferior articles are formally published with lower ranks

8 How to rate the value of a preprint
If you think the preprint is as valuable as those published in journals of the following impact factors You should rate the value rank of the preprint to be 0.0–0.5 1 0.5–1.5 2 1.5–2.5 3 2.5–3.5 4 3.5–4.5 5 4.5–5.5 6 5.5–10.5 7 10.5–20.5 8 ≥20.5 9

9 How to rate the value of a preprint
If you think the preprint is as valuable as those published in journals of the following impact factors You should rate the value rank of the preprint to be 0.0–0.5 1 0.5–1.5 2 1.5–2.5 3 2.5–3.5 4 3.5–4.5 5 4.5–5.5 6 5.5–10.5 7 10.5–20.5 8 ≥20.5 9 The ranking is of relatively clear standards The ranking is highly rated to the current evaluation system based on impact factors

10 How to calculate the value rank?
No one knows your rating which is hidden in the database The median of the ratings of ≥ 5 experts is calculated as the value rank of the preprint

11 How to calculate the value rank?
The ranking is mechanistically fair The ranking is statistically fair No one knows your rating which is hidden in the database The median of the ratings of ≥ 5 experts is calculated as the value rank of the preprint

12 1. Enter the web page of the abstract
How to rate and comment? 1. Enter the web page of the abstract 2. Sign in your account 3. Rate the value here 4. Make comments here

13 Other features of Newpubli
Publish articles only from all fields of biomedical sciences in the first three years Can publish manuscripts as and only as preprints before their full text has been completed (but their abstracts and supporting data should have been well described) 40% shares of Newpubli shall be bestowed to authors and reviewers in the beginning years according to their contribution

14 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision 1st 70 days 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 5th 6 days

15 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected 1st 70 days 80% 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 50% 5th 6 days 5%

16 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article 1st 70 days 80% 0.9 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 50% 3.5 5th 6 days 5% 2.8/0.9 Let us see a mock example to see the difference of an article of a little value to be published by different journals.

17 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article 1st 70 days 80% 0.9 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 50% 3.5 5th 6 days 5% 2.8/0.9 Let us see a mock example to see the difference of an article of a little value to be published by different journals. The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 2 may be 0.9

18 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article The value rank of the article 1st 70 days 80% 0.9 / 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 50% 3.5 5th 6 days 5% 2.8/0.9 2 Let us see a mock example to see the difference of an article of a little value to be published by different journals. The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 2 may be 0.9

19 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article The value rank of the article 1st 70 days 80% 0.9 / 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 50% 3.5 5th 6 days 5% 2.8/0.9 2 Let us see a mock example to see the difference of an article of a little value to be published by different journals. The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 2 may be 0.9 The rank being 2 indicates this article is as valuable as those published in journals whose IFs are

20 A mock example: Publishing an article of low value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article The value rank of the article Readers are indicated the article is likely of low value 1st 70 days 80% 0.9 / Yes 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 50% 3.5 No 5th 6 days 5% 2.8/0.9 2 Let us see a mock example to see the difference of an article of a little value to be published by different journals. The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 2 may be 0.9 The rank being 2 indicates this article is as valuable as those published in journals whose IFs are

21 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision 1st 70 days 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 5th 6 days

22 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected 1st 70 days 50% 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 0% 5th 6 days

23 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article 1st 70 days 50% 12 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 0% 3.5 5th 6 days 2.8/12

24 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article 1st 70 days 50% 12 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 0% 3.5 5th 6 days 2.8/12 The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 8 may be 12

25 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article The value rank of the article 1st 70 days 50% 12 / 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 0% 3.5 5th 6 days 2.8/12 8 The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 8 may be 12

26 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article The value rank of the article 1st 70 days 50% 12 / 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 0% 3.5 5th 6 days 2.8/12 8 The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 8 may be 12 The rank being 8 indicates this article is as valuable as those published in journals whose IFs are

27 Another mock example: Publishing an article of high value
Journal genera-tion The time needed for making decision The possibility for the article to be rejected The impact factor (IF) of the journal publishing the article The value rank of the article Readers are indicated the article is likely of high value 1st 70 days 50% 12 / Yes 2nd 3rd 4th 60 days 0% 3.5 No 5th 6 days 2.8/12 8 The IF of Newpubli as a whole may be 2.8 The IF of the collection of the articles in Newpubli whose ranks are 8 may be 12 The rank being 8 indicates this article is as valuable as those published in journals whose IFs are

28 Five mechanisms Newpubli uses to control quality of articles
Only experienced researchers are qualified to submit manuscripts to Newpubli Newpubli accepts only the manuscripts which are well- written, of clear statements on competing interests and other relevant issues, and of no ethical problems The preprints rated to be of the lowest value rank will be transferred to the sister journal of Newpubli, Newpubli Express, for formal publication The preprints rated to be of high ranks will be awarded using honors and journal shares to encourage authors to submit superior manuscripts The articles shall be reviewed again and/or retracted if some academic or ethical flaws have been identified

29 Impact factor (IF) of Newpubli
The IF of any journal cannot be calculated until the journal is 3 years old The IFs of the whole journal and each collection of the articles sharing the same value rank can be calculated separately It is interesting to wait and see whether the value rank is highly related to the IFs

30 Newpubli: the publisher smiles
Need not judge whether manuscripts are of enough value Cut down greatly the costs of the journal Publish many articles rapidly with clear value ranks every year Of great public good and impact Provide free open access publication for authors Attract many readers Obtain great ad revenue Obtain support from governments and donors

31 Newpubli: authors smile
Articles shall be published within days rather than months Articles shall not be rejected for inadequate value or prejudice Articles shall be evaluated fairly and timely Need not pay any fee for open access publication Have opportunities to be promoted in honor Have opportunities to be owners of the journal

32 Newpubli: readers smile
Open access Much more articles shall be published, which can meet some special needs of many readers Articles are ranked per value, which is useful for readers to search articles and judge their value

33 Newpubli: the society smiles
Research data and scientific ideas shall be published much more rapidly, which is useful to promote the progress of the society Many more articles shall be published, which is useful to solve deficiency of information Articles shall be ranked per value, which is useful to solve deluge of information

34 A much better future needs your contribution

35 Thank you for reading


Download ppt "The First Fifth-Generation Academic Journal"

Similar presentations


Ads by Google