1. Comment Resolution Summary Letter Ballot 1 Category: RCPI
January 2004
doc.: IEEE /xxxx
September 2004
Comment Resolution Summary Letter Ballot 1 Category: RCPI
Joe Kwak
InterDigital Communications
Joe Kwak
Areg Alimian CMC, Bernard Aboba Microsoft

2. RCPI Comment Summary Total Number of Comments: 94 Number reassigned: 4
January 2004
doc.: IEEE /xxxx
RCPI Comment Summary
September 2004
Total Number of Comments: 94
Number reassigned: 4
Unknown Comment: 1
SubCategories:
18 Simple Errors
13 Misc
6 Accuracy
8 Backwards compatibility
2 Measurement bandwidth
7 RCPI Definition
3 Histogram step sizes
12 Probe Response
8 RCPI for noise measurement
9 Measurement Range
2 Measurement Resolution
Joe Kwak
Areg Alimian CMC, Bernard Aboba Microsoft

3. RCPI SubCategory Details
January 2004
doc.: IEEE /xxxx
September 2004
RCPI SubCategory Details
Measurement Accuracy: 1 for less accuracy, 4 for more accuracy (+/- 3dB suggested)
Backward Compatibility: 3 voters all concerned about changes to PHY and RxVector.
Measurement BW: 2 voters concerned with variable channel BWs. Suggested to use TGj as model for linking measurement BW to defined channel BW.
Histogram steps: 1 for smaller steps, 2 for larger steps
Probe Response: Suggested resolution to all by Black in 11-04/1095
Joe Kwak
Areg Alimian CMC, Bernard Aboba Microsoft

4. RCPI SubCategory Details (cont)
September 2004
RCPI SubCategory Details (cont)
RCPI for Noise Measurement: Kwak to provide contribution to resolve at next meeting.
Measurement Range: 4 voters for decreasing measurement range, not sure if extra bit would be useful.
Measurement Resolution: 1 voter suggests .5db-->1dB
MISC: Most of these are requests for clarification, not difficult but takes some work
Joe Kwak

5. ISSUES Request to resurrect Fast Scan from 11-03/0834?
September 2004
ISSUES
Request to resurrect Fast Scan from /0834?
Add RCPI to Association Request/Response?
Joe Kwak

6. Comments Ready for Review and Vote
September 2004
Comments Ready for Review and Vote
RCPI in Probe Response (addressed in 11-04/1095:
25, 27, 28, 31, 316, 336, 337, 339, 775, 777, 942
Simple Errors:
21, 180, 183, 197, 203, 207, 215, 216, 231, 375, 448, 492, 555, 563, 627, 636, 783, 935
Joe Kwak