1. US Kickoff brief to Frameworks Convergence Meeting
Mr. Walt Okon
19 June 2012

2. Briefing Outline Overall architecture framework convergence vision
Current U.S. convergence initiatives
Change in structure and contents of DoDAF v2.03
U.S. Federal Government Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture
Next -- NATO Architecture Capability Team (Architecture CaT)
Architecture CaT Understanding
Approach for UAF – IDEAS, Common metamodel supporting multiple policies
Ideas for Architecture CaT Workshop Objectives, Invitees, and Agenda
19 June 2012 2

3. Overall architecture framework convergence vision
DoDAF
v1.5
1995
C4ISR F/W v1.0
v2.0
UAF
v2.05
2003
2007
JCIDS & NR-KPP
Applicability beyond C4ISR
Use-based
Integrated Architecture
2009
2010
2012
2014
v2.01
v2.02
v2.03
DoDAF/DNDAF
v2.04
1997
2016
2013
Joint Interoperability
DoDAF v1.0
C4ISR F/W v2.0
Net-centricity and SoA
SvcV views
26 AV/OV/SV/TV views
Linked to I&S policies
CADM 2.0
Fit-for-purpose
Data-centric architecture
Improved models of systems, services, capabilities, rules, measures
DoDAF Meta Model (DM2) based on IDEAS
Urgent CRs
52  1 XSD
IDEAS Foundation v1.0 fixes
TECHEDITS
DM2 OWL
Federal Common Approach
DNDAF Security Views
MODEM – DM2 Harmonization (IDEAS Domain Level)
NATO NAF
UDAF
Standardization, e.g.,
ISO
OMG
OASIS
Framework Objective:
Achieve a single integrated Architecture Framework for interoperability.
Achieve a US, Canada, and United Kingdom single Framework with a common Data Meta Model
Achieve alignment with the US Government Common Approach to Enterprise Architecture
19 June 2012 3 3

4. U.S. perceived benefits of a Unified Architecture Framework
Architecture federation and data exchange
Agreement on common concepts and meanings
Architectures can be assessed for interoperability and for capability gaps and overlaps in support of Coalition operations long-range planning
Defense, humanitarian, law enforcement, …
Standardization
Tools
Training
19 June 2012

5. Enabler – Revised Structure and contents of DoDAF v2.03
Vol. I - Normative
DM2 Conceptual Data Model (CDM) documentation
DoDAF Viewpoints & Models
Vol. II - Normative
DM2 Logical Data Model (LDM) documentation
DoDAF Model Specs
DoDAF Glossary
Vol. III - Normative
IDEAS documentation
DM2 Physical Exchange Specification (PES) documentation
DM2 OWL-DL documentation
In the DoD MDR “ARCH” namespace supporting the DoD EA COI - Normative
Links to IDEAS Foundation v1.0
SparxEA .EAP DM2 LDM file
DM2 PES XSD file
DM2 OWL-DL file
Vol IV - Informative
DoDAF Informative material (e.g., history of the DoDAF, 6-step, approximately 30 articles)
NOT under formal CM
19 June 2012

6. Enabler – Layers to Separate Evolving Policies from Enduring Architectural Concepts
DoDAF Models
Operational
Capabilities
Services
Systems
Data and Information
Standards
Projects
DM2
The 52 DoDAF models use the DM2 concepts
19 June 2012

7. Convergence in the US -- Common Approach
Documentation section identifies 50 artifacts, what DoDAF calls models
DoD led the Artifact Working Group that is updating these artifacts
19 June 2012

8. Draft Artifacts
19 June 2012

9. Draft Artifacts
19 June 2012 9

10. 19 June 2012

11. Vision and Near-Term Activities
“…committed on delivering key architectural products to support the federated C3 EA development as key governance tool for the achievement of NATO's Strategic Concept goals.”
Who:
16 countries + several NATO organizations in roster
Upcoming activities:
Architecture CaT Workshop NATO HQ
Architecture CaT Meeting # 4 12 Sept at NATO HQ
19 June 2012

12. Architecture CaT Current Work Plan
“Propose the structure and develop the content of the guiding framework for the development of a federated NATO C3 Enterprise Architecture, reusing national and NATO artefacts.”
“Nations are requested - in the context of the C3 Classification Taxonomy - to provide by the next CaT Meeting their key concepts for enterprise architecture, including definitions of terms; …”
“[Task 01] Harmonize and modernize Architecture Governance & Policy Documents”
“[Task 02] Assess NAF vs. TOGAF and make recommendation to C3 Board for (board action)”
19 June 2012

13. IDEAS Layered Approach
1. Foundation (upper ontology)
Ontologic concepts and relationships
Commonly used patterns, e.g., Resource Flow, Exchange
Universally accepted concepts and relationships, e.g., person, organization, material, etc.
2. Common patterns
3. Universal objects & relationships X X X X
Reports drawn from the architecture data specific to needs and policies of individual nations
national
views
national
views
national
views
national
views
19 June 2012 13

14. Workshop Our Objectives Invitees – entire roster?
For the two days
Related to Architecture CaT work plan
Long term (UAF?)
Invitees – entire roster?
Our Roles and Responsibilities to prepare and conduct workshop
Briefings
Facilitation
Communications
Read-ahead materials
Finalization of agenda
19 June 2012

15. Agenda Ideas Review objectives with attendees Introduction to IDEAS
IDEAS Role in DoDAF and MODAF
IDEAS Support for Architecture Federation
IDEAS Relationship to Current Architecture CaT Activities, e.g., C3 Taxonomy
IDEAS Compared to NAF and TOGAF
Plan to Complete IDEAS as a NATO Architecture Foundation
IDEAS Foundation, v1.0 (done)
Common Patterns (work to be done)
Universal Objects and Relationships (work to be done)
19 June 2012

16. Notional Plan for Common Patterns and Universal Objects and Relationships
(Dates are indicative of work needs, not resource commitments. Note: There is work effort to socialize DM2 changes to US DM2 user base.)
19 June 2012