1. How to Write an Argumentative Essay: Common Core Style!
It all comes down to 5 letters: CERCA!

2. Wait . . . What is an argumentative essay?
An Argumentative essay aims to argue, convince, or prove with evidence something to a reader who may or may not agree with you.
CERCA can help to ensure that you cover your bases and make sure you have made a strong argument.

3. Remember that the introductory paragraph . . .
Is the most important paragraph of the essay
Must be at least words long or three-five sentences minimum
Needs to do several things
Follow AIRS format:
Attract readers attention
Identify the author and title of article (s)
Restate prompt in your own words
State the CLAIM
Created by José J. González, Jr.
Spring 2002

4. C.E.R.C.A. First, you must establish your Claim.
Your claim is often called your thesis statement. It is the statement that you plan to prove in your essay.
No Claim = no essay. The claim is essential!
A good claim is specific. It makes a focused argument (MTV‟s popularity is waning because it no longer plays music videos) rather than a general one (MTV sucks).

5. What makes my claim good?
Your claim needs to be something you can support with reasoning and evidence that is meaningful, not just “because I say so!”
The governor has continually done the community a disservice by mishandling money, focusing on frivolous causes, and failing to listen to his citizens.
Bad Claims:
Twinkies are delicious.
I think Lil Wayne is better than Drake.
The Toronto Mayor is a bad man.
Twinkies taste better than other snack cakes because of their texture, their creamy filling, and their golden appearance.

6. CERCA
Evidence
Think of yourself as a detective. You cannot accuse or arrest someone of a murder without sufficient evidence.
Claim: Mr. Jungman is the murderer
Evidence: His fingerprints are on the murder weapon. His footprints were seen leaving the crime scene. He has a motive.
Go back to the text to find your evidence.
Quotation
Paraphrasing
summarizing

7. Evidence
Evidence is concrete facts to support your claims. (That’s why you MUST go back to the text)
Your evidence must be relevant and verifiable. Just like the crime lab needs matching fingerprint samples from Mr. Jungman, you need to have facts and data to support your claim.

8. CERCA
Reasoning
It is one thing to provide evidence to support the claim, but you also have to explain how that evidence is significant to the claim (why it makes your claim valid).
“Mr. Jungman’s fingerprints match those on the knife found at the scene of the crime. This suggests that Mr. Jungman used the knife to murder the victim.”

9. CERCA Counterclaim (separate paragraph)
The prosecution lawyers (who wish to prove that Mr. Jungman is guilty) must anticipate and address any arguments that Mr. Jungman’s defense lawyer may present.
Therefore, you must include counterclaims in your essay to defend the claim from any rebuttals or arguments that someone who may not agree with you might bring up.

10. Counterclaim Think of a counterclaim as the opposing claim.
For instance, if you are writing an essay based on the previous claim – “The governor has done our community a disservice . . .” someone might say, “You're wrong, the media has put the governor in a negative light causing people to believe that he is not listening to the citizens”.
You need to be prepared for this counter attack with a counterclaim!

11. CERCA
Audience
If you are a prosecution lawyer trying to prove that Mr. Jungman is guilty, who is your audience?
Similarly, you must consider your audience when you are writing an argumentative essay! Considering the nature of your argument; who would be interesting in reading your essay?
Knowing your audience will help you make decisions about tone, word choice and writing style.

12. Important pre-writing activity
It is very important that you make a “plan of attack”. Make sure you pre-write your argument before you begin your essay.
This will ensure that your essay if focused and save you time in the long run.
Be sure to use your sentence stems in your evidence, this will help you make sure you use “textual evidence”.

13. Example
You finally made it! You have been waiting months to get into the restaurant of your dreams. Reservations are hard to come by. You have the night all planned – what to wear, how to do your hair, makeup, the whole thing planned in your mind. When you get there, you find out that you have been seated in the smoking section! In the articles “Why Smoking Should be Banned” by John Jones and “Smoking is My Right” by Seth Barton, the authors have very contrasting opinions and points of view about the right to smoke and where smoking should be allowed. Smoking in public places should never be allowed.