1. Service Guideline Stands for Common Evaluation Principles
Ruri Hiromi JPNIC ip-wg
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

2. Subjects Common Principles What do we need to solve?
Guideline will help?
Have a discussion
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

3. my presentation at APRICOT 2000(1)
Registries shall not interfere with business issues of the applications,
Registries shall not regard administrative ease on address assignments,
Registries shall gather minimum information necessary for evaluation of applications,
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

4. my presentation at APRICOT 2000(2)
Requesters shall reply to any of the above information requests by all means but they are allowed to ask reasons of the requests by the registries,
Registries shall evaluate technologies for its procedures with a common standard before adoption.
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

5. The points to be discussed(1)
inconsistency among IRs.
harmonization of understanding
Approaches to the brand-new services
Approaches to the new technologies
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

6. The issues to be discussed(2)
Show examples at not be interfered with business opportunities
standardization and sharing new rules
equaled quality of the RIR/NIR allocation and assignment criteria
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

7. Proposal
Making a guideline
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

8. Vision Stable address administration
consistency among APNIC, NIR and LIR hostmasters
efficiency in address usage allocations and assignments
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

9. Definition of the "guideline"
For judgment
Support Policy paper
For brand-new technology
For brand-new business model
Up-to-dated
opened
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

10. Additional Benefits Consistency of assessment
Give a strong recommendation from IR
Beyond hierarchy (Confederation members and ISPs)
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

11. Action Item Mailing list for discussion
Setup a working group within APNIC with members
Writing and publishing
Make it open
Appropriate modification
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

12. Conclusion Making and Sharing the guideline
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2

13. Thank you for listening
JPNIC(c) All rights reserved
2019/6/2